Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Madeira Beach HR manager locks horns with mayor, two commissioners

MADEIRA BEACH — The city's human resources manager has broadened her complaint of a hostile work environment to include Mayor Travis Palladeno and Commissioner Nancy Oakley.

The original complaint was filed against Commissioner Robin Vander Velde weeks ago but gave little detail.

In a four-page memo sent to Interim City Manager Bill Mallory last week, Deborah Cline produced details not only against Vander Velde but against Palladeno and Oakley.

Describing the alleged actions by the three as "unwelcome behavior," Cline gave half a dozen examples that she says interfere with her ability to do her job.

"I will view any attempt to remove me from the city of Madeira Beach's employ, or from my position as human resources manager, as retaliatory in nature," Cline said in her memo.

Palladeno on Tuesday questioned Cline's "motivation" for the complaint. At the same time, he acknowledged that he, Vander Velde and Oakley are on the record as favoring the elimination of her position in next year's city budget.

During his election campaign, Palladeno promised to reduce city operational costs by eliminating and/or outsourcing administrative functions so that the saved money could be spent on improving the city's infrastructure.

"I am not raising taxes in this town. I am not going to do it," Palladeno said. "I won with 64 percent of the vote and I am doing what I said I would do."

When reached Tuesday about her complaints, Cline would only say that she wants her issues "resolved quickly" so that "everyone involved" can "focus on the pressing issues facing the city."

Specifically, Cline said she wants Vander Velde, Oakley and Palladeno to allow her to perform her job "without interference."

That interference, according to Cline, includes:

• The mayor questioning her right to speak with a St. Petersburg Times reporter.

• Comments by the mayor in multiple news articles that "disparage (Cline's) reputation and create hostile or disagreeable feelings" toward her.

• "Intentional sabotage" by Vander Velde and Oakley that violated the city's personnel policies and the city charter when they questioned Cline's ability to perform her recruitment and hiring duties.

• Vander Velde's questioning of Cline's ability to maintain security of personnel documents, and comments that Cline's sole possession of keys to locked personnel records was "a critical point of failure" in the city's security procedures.

"Her (Vander Velde's) implication that I did not hold records securely was an insult," Cline wrote. "Her accusations and implications are without merit and detrimental to my professional reputation."

Cline maintains that the "scrutiny and verbal attack" by Palladeno constitutes harassment.

She also complained about City Attorney Tom Trask, who she said told her he had been "told a number of things in confidence that I cannot divulge to you."

Trask, reached Tuesday, declined to comment and said the city's labor attorney, Tom Gonzalez, was handling the matter.

As remediation for her complaints, Cline not only wants them to stop but is demanding that no commissioner, the mayor or "their agents or representatives" be allowed to make "any disparaging comments/innuendos" about her ability to perform her job.

"Our attorney told me the allegations are just plain silly," Palladeno said Tuesday.

In an e-mail to Palladeno and Mallory, Gonzalez dismissed the human resources manager's claims.

"I see nothing in the complaint which describes a legally hostile workplace or harassment," Gonzalez wrote.

Specifically, he said, the "interference" alleged by Cline does not legally exist because "an individual commissioner has no authority," and that their actions are "not a violation of law" and don't "rise to the level of a grievance or complaint."

Gonzalez also said Palladeno's attempt to find out whether Cline had contact with a Times reporter is not an "unlawful" action.

Palladeno said Tuesday he intends to enforce the city's policy manual, which he says specifies that only the city manager, the city clerk, the mayor and commissioners are allowed to talk to the media.

"It's the rules, it's policy," he said, adding that if other city employees talk to the press, "they are not doing themselves any good."

Madeira Beach HR manager locks horns with mayor, two commissioners 06/14/11 [Last modified: Tuesday, June 14, 2011 5:23pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Joe Henderson: Only unanimous jury vote justifies extreme act of execution


    A ruling last week by the U.S. Supreme Court on Florida's death penalty law didn't generate a lot of chatter, but don't let that fool you.

    A jury recommended execution for Dontae Morris of Tampa by a 10-2 vote in one of his murder trials. The recommendation was unanimous when he was tried in the shooting deaths of two Tampa police officers.
  2. PolitiFact: Iowa's individual market is teetering, but it's not necessarily a sign Obamacare is collapsing


    Whatever your view of the health care debate, the news out of Iowa isn't good. In April, two large insurers, Wellmark and Aetna, said they would not offer health insurance policies on Iowa's federal health insurance marketplace in 2018. Medica, the only remaining insurer, recently said it too might pull the plug next …

    A protester outside a Cedar Rapids town hall meeting with Rep. Rod Blum, R-Iowa. (Getty Images)
  3. NATO chief responds to Trump, says allies to join anti-IS coalition


    BRUSSELS — NATO's chief affirmed Thursday that the alliance will join the international coalition fighting the Islamic State group but will not wage direct war against the extremists — an announcement timed for U.S. President Donald Trump's first appearance at a summit of the alliance's leaders.

    U.S. President Donald Trump is greeted by European Council President Donald Tusk as he arrives at the Europa building in Brussels on Thursday, May 25, 2017. Trump arrived in Belgium on Wednesday evening and will attend a NATO summit as well as meet EU and Belgian officials. [Associated Press]
  4. Looking Back: Gene Shalit gets cheeky with the New York Mets. (March 8, 1986)


    This story appeared in the pages of the St. Petersburg Times on March 8, 1986. What follows is the text of the original story, interspersed with photos of the event taken by Times staff photographer Ricardo Ferro.

    Gene Shalit is all smiles as he gets a behind the scenes look at  the New York Met locker room at Huggins-Stengel Field.

TIMES | Ricardo Ferro
  5. Death threats take Madeira Beach strife to new level

    Local Government

    MADEIRA BEACH — Politics here took a nasty turn last week when someone called City Manager Shane Crawford nine times, threatening to kill him, his wife and her children.

    Madeira Beach City Manager Shane Crawford