Sunday, April 22, 2018
News Roundup

Owners of waterfront home sue Clearwater over halted demolition

CLEARWATER — At the south end of one of the fingers of land that make up Island Estates, there's a long line of well-kept waterfront homes with backyard access to the Intracoastal Waterway.

There's also one home site that looks like it got leveled by a hurricane. All that's left at 1 Windward Island Road are a few sections of concrete-block walls, broken marble floors, "No Trespassing" signs and a swimming pool filled with scum.

This apocalyptic landscape has been untouched for a year and a half. The well-to-do retirees who populate the neighborhood shake their heads in disbelief.

Now the property's owners are suing the city of Clearwater. They say the city shut down their home renovation in 2011 and accused them of violating Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) flood-zone regulations, even though city officials had previously given the project their approval.

The city isn't saying anything due to the lawsuit. "We don't comment on pending litigation," said City Attorney Pam Akin.

Lifelong Clearwater residents David and Aileen Bair own this lot on Island Estates. They bought a waterfront house and intended to remodel it and add nearly 700 square feet before moving in.

The Bairs' lawsuit claims:

• That Clearwater building officials approved their permit, which authorized the Bairs to demolish part of the existing house to make way for new construction.

• That when demolition was finished in August 2011, the city issued a stop-work order, asserting that the Bairs had demolished more than their permit allowed.

• And that when it turned out the city permit actually did allow that much demolition, the city backtracked and decided it should never have issued the permit in the first place.

The two sides have been at an impasse ever since.

"While the city admits they made mistakes, they rejected all of the changes we proposed, refusing to accept any responsibility for their errors and refusing to make any accommodations," said David Bair, co-owner of Quality Boat Sales in Clearwater. "I grew up here. I have never sued anyone. Suing the city is the last thing I would ever want to do. They have left us with no alternative."

However, Clearwater officials say the property owners are clearly violating FEMA's 50 percent rule. They point to how little is left of the original house.

The federal government requires a home to be elevated if the cost of repairs or renovations will exceed 50 percent of the value of the original building.

Even though Island Estates is a low-lying community just east of Clearwater Beach that is surrounded by water, the vast majority of its roughly 500 houses are not elevated. The Bairs didn't want to elevate their house.

Although officials aren't talking about the case, a thick file of documents in the city's Building Department sheds some light on what happened. When the Bairs applied for their construction permit in April 2011, their general contractor put the project's cost at $136,850. That was less than half of the structure's $285,462 value, according to an appraisal commissioned by the Bairs.

The permit was approved in July 2011.

When demolition work began that August, officials were surprised by how much of the house was taken down. They stopped the work.

"They came and said, 'You demolished more than what was permitted.' But that's just not true. They made a mistake," said the Bairs' attorney, Paul Raymond.

The following month, the Bairs' general contractor submitted another set of figures, putting the renovation project's cost at $231,600 and the original structure's value at $479,755.

All of this led to a lengthy series of plan revisions, technical correspondence, legal threats, an appeal to the city's flood board, and now a lawsuit.

In correspondence between the two sides, city officials appear to acknowledge that they made a mistake in approving the original permit. But they say that doesn't change the fact that FEMA rules were broken. Building officials are required to use retail pricing for materials and standard contractor fees when determining whether to invoke the 50 percent rule. A letter from Clearwater building officials to the Bairs' architect refers to this:

"An analysis is done using this type of data to establish the value of the proposed improvement. This part of the process was inadvertently omitted during the review process for your project, and although it is unpropitious that this omission occurred, the Building Department is yet charged with the responsibility of enforcing floodplain development regulations."

In 1990, FEMA threatened to cut Clearwater out of the federal flood insurance program for insufficient enforcement of the 50 percent rule in the city.

Mike Brassfield can be reached at [email protected] or (727) 445-4151. To write a letter to the editor, go to tampabay.com/letters.

Comments
Baseball: Bulls edge Knights to even series

Baseball: Bulls edge Knights to even series

After a two-hour weather delay Saturday evening at USF, the remote local threat of lightning finally dissipated.The postseason intensity never did.For the second consecutive night, the UCF-USF baseball series delivered, this time with the Bulls (25-1...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Perspective: The Heartland to Headwaters Florida Wildlife Corridor Expedition finds frustration and fear seeking a safe a path for wildlife across Interstate 4

Perspective: The Heartland to Headwaters Florida Wildlife Corridor Expedition finds frustration and fear seeking a safe a path for wildlife across Interstate 4

The original Florida Wildlife Corridor Expedition in 2012 was inspired by the how the Florida black bear roamed — and the space it needed to do so successfully. In 2010, expedition team member Joe Guthrie conducted research through the University of ...
Published: 04/22/18
Athletics’ Sean Manaea no-hits Red Sox

Athletics’ Sean Manaea no-hits Red Sox

OAKLAND, Calif. – Sean Manaea watched as Marcus Semien fired a ball from short to second baseman Jed Lowrie, turned around, and jumped into the arms of catcher Jonathan Lucroy. History was made at the Coliseum.Manaea no-hit the Red Sox on ...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Maple Leafs force Game 6 with Bruins

Maple Leafs force Game 6 with Bruins

BOSTON — Tyler Bozak and James van Riemsdyk scored 1:19 apart in the second period, and then the Maple Leafs killed off a 5-on-3 and three more power plays in a row to beat the Bruins 4-3 in Game 5 on Saturday night and avoid playoff eliminatio...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Marc Topkin’s takeaways from Rays’ 10-1 Saturday win over Twins

Marc Topkin’s takeaways from Rays’ 10-1 Saturday win over Twins

* Is it time to take the leap and believe this is the real Blake Snell? He talked a good game this spring and pitched well in his debut, but that rough second outing raised old doubts. But a good outing in Chicago and two dominant ones on the homesta...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Rays Tales: How low can this team go compared to those Devil Rays days?

Rays Tales: How low can this team go compared to those Devil Rays days?

When the Rays, in the opening weekend of their 20th anniversary celebration season, brought back and honored the inaugural 1998 Devil Rays squad, it got us thinking unexpected thoughts, such as which was a better team:The first one, or the current on...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Rays Journal: Team effort pays off in 10-1 win over Twins

Rays Journal: Team effort pays off in 10-1 win over Twins

ST. PETERSBURG – Let's be clear here, the Rays still have a long way to go, and a lot of ground to make up.But seeing them play like they did Saturday in beating the Twins 10-1, putting on a solid all-around show in cobbling their first three-g...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Lightning-Devils: How the NHL’s top offense went on the defensive

Lightning-Devils: How the NHL’s top offense went on the defensive

TAMPA — It was a couple of days after the Lightning beat the Bruins at home late in the regular season when associate coach Rick Bowness talked about how the defensive effort used in that shutout victory was the one the Lightning would need in ...
Updated: 6 hours ago
Rays will go forth with four starters

Rays will go forth with four starters

ST. PETERSBURG — Three weeks was enough for the Rays to officially ditch their three-man rotation plan.Starting Sunday, they will go forth with Yonny Chirinos as their fourth starter.Which is a five-star idea.The flaws in the three-man plan ...
Updated: 6 hours ago
Rookie? Lightning D Mikhail Sergachev’s playing like a seasoned pro

Rookie? Lightning D Mikhail Sergachev’s playing like a seasoned pro

TAMPA — Pardon Mikhail Sergachev if he isn't so good at one of hockey's greatest traditions. After all, growing a Stanley Cup playoff beard isn't easy when you're still just a teenager.As he stood in the Lightning locker room Saturday evening w...
Updated: 7 hours ago