Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Pasco County land ordinance faces test in federal court

The owners of a 16-acre commercial parcel outside San Antonio could be on the verge of defeating an ordinance that allows the county to bank land at low prices for future road corridors.

Pasco's so-called Right of Way Corridor Preservation ordinance is being challenged in federal court by Hillcrest Properties, which owns the parcel just west of Interstate 75 off Old Pasco Road. Hillcrest argues the ordinance unfairly forces owners to surrender land at no cost to the county if they want to develop their property.

Last month, a federal magistrate agreed, suggesting the law is unconstitutional.

The ordinance is a "calculated measure by the county to avoid the burdens and costs of eminent domain and take private property without just compensation," magistrate Thomas McCoun wrote in his March 9 report.

The ordinance has not been struck down. McCoun's recommendation now heads to U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday. The county now hopes to convince the judge not to follow the magistrate's findings.

Attorneys for the two sides filed responses to the report Friday. A ruling could be several weeks away.

The stakes are much higher than the fate of a 16-acre parcel near San Antonio. If the ordinance is ruled unconstitutional, the county will no longer be able to require such land donations and could have to pay more for right of way in the future. Also, a ruling could open the door for dozens of other landowners who received past approvals to sue the county for damages.

An adverse ruling wouldn't only affect Pasco and developers who do business there. It could also give other counties and cities pause before passing such a measure.

The ordinance, passed in 2005, says property owners must dedicate a portion of their land to the county if part of it falls on a map of future road expansions. If owners believe the dedication is unfair, they can argue their project won't generate enough traffic to justify the land dedication. They can also apply for a variance that the requirement creates an "inordinate burden."

The county's key goal was to plan for future road expansions and to save taxpayers millions of dollars by acquiring right of way before the cost balloons. Consider the recently completed widening of State Road 54 in Wesley Chapel. The project cost roughly $100 million, but only about 30 percent of the cost was for construction. The rest went toward buying land.

"Right now we get a lot of right of way under that ordinance, donated to the county," said County Administrator John Gallagher. "If that stops, one of two things happen. The impact fees go up to cover the additional cost of the right of way, or the roads don't get expanded."

And if the roads aren't expanded, some developments that generate too many car trips could be stalled.

Hillcrest in 2007 agreed to give up 50 feet of right of way for a future State Road 52 widening. But then the state Department of Transportation shifted the future alignment of the highway to the north, requiring an additional 90 feet of right of way.

Owners said that decision reduced developable land on the parcel by about 25 percent and caused a grocery store development to pull out. The county and Hillcrest tried to negotiate compensation for the land, but those talks broke down. Hillcrest sued in April 2010.

"The ordinance effectively forces landowners seeking development approval to choose between that approval and the right to be compensated for the taking of their property," Hillcrest's lawyers argue in court briefs.

Assistant county attorney Nicki Spirtos declined to comment on the suit because Merryday has not issued a ruling.

In court briefs, the county argues Hillcrest declined to seek remedies available under the ordinance and noted that a Hillcrest lawyer agreed to dedicate the land required by the county ordinance during a 2007 meeting of the Development Review Committee.

The county also argues Hillcrest cannot prove that the ordinance "always operates unconstitutionally." As such, the court cannot strike down the ordinance on its face.

Lee Logan can be reached at or (727) 869-6236.

Pasco County land ordinance faces test in federal court 04/07/12 [Last modified: Saturday, April 7, 2012 3:24pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Minors also a training ground for umpires with big-league dreams

    The Heater

    Umpire Tom Fornarola, 23, left, and Taylor Payne, 24, facing, talk before the start of the Gulf Coast League game between the New York Yankees and the Detroit Tigers at the Tigertown complex in Lakeland, Fla. on Wednesday, July 5, 2017.
  2. In Florida, nation's only lightning center closes after DARPA cuts funding


    University of Florida professor Martin Uman usually spends much of this summer at an old Army base about an hour northeast of Gainesville, shooting rockets at thunderclouds, then measuring the bright flashes of lightning that followed.

    Rocket-and-wire triggered lightning at the University of Florida's International Center for Lightning Research and Testing, which recently lost federal funding. A rocket trailing a grounded wire is launched toward an active thunderstorm at the ICLRT. One launch is from a tower, one from ground. When the wire is about as high as the Empire State Building, lightning is induced to strike the top of the wire, much as it strikes tall objects like the ESB. Interestingly, the cloud charge source is about 3 miles high, so a 300 yard-long wire can cause a 3 mile or more long lightning.  After that, there are several normal tortuous strokes ( downward leaders from the cloud charge/upward return strokes) which can be seen as the wind blows the individual strokes to the right. The time between strokes is about 50 thousands of a second. Between some strokes, continuing current can be seen. Continuing current is what generally starts forest fires. [Photo by Dr. Dustin Hill]
  3. Editorial: Reasonable clarity on gambling in Florida


    Gambling expansion strategies — and misfires — are nearly an annual ritual in Florida. There were the eight counties that voted to allow slot machines but were blocked by the Florida Supreme Court. There was the governor's $3 billion deal with the Seminole Tribe in 2015 that was never approved by the …

    Gov. Rick Scott agreed to a much simpler deal with the Seminole Tribe that embraces the status quo instead of expansion. And that’s a good thing.
  4. Amid U.S. real estate buying binge by foreign investors, Florida remains first choice

    Real Estate

    Foreign investment in U.S. residential real estate recently skyrocketed to a new high with nearly half of all foreign sales happening in Florida, California and Texas.

    A National Association of Realtors annual survey found record volume and activity by foreign buyers of U.S. real estate. Florida had the highest foreign investment activity, followed by California and Texas. [National Association of Realtors]
  5. Editorial: Hillsborough smartly embraces diversion program for youths


    Children who commit minor crimes can pay for their mistakes for a lifetime — losing a chance to attend college, join the military or obtain credit and a good job. That is unjust to the individuals and a burdensome cost to society, and Hillsborough County is taking the right new approach by giving some juveniles a …

    Hillsborough State Attorney Andrew Warren has announced an agreement between law enforcement agencies and the courts that will allow first-time offenders who commit nonviolent crimes as juveniles to be issued civil citations rather than face an arrest and prosecution.