Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Plug the loopholes and do the digital billboard deal in St. Petersburg

Several of our communities in the Tampa Bay area are dealing with the question of digital billboards.

Pinellas County has imposed a delay of up to a year on new ones, waiting for a federal safety study. The city of Tampa is wrestling with the issue, too.

As for St. Petersburg, the question must be answered immediately. Mayor Rick Baker has struck a proposed deal to allow them; the deal is in front of the City Council.

The mayor's deal with Clear Channel Communications involves a 10-for-1 swap.

The company, which owns 144 of the roughly 180 billboards in the city, would take down 100 signs, in exchange for 10 digital billboards on major highways — Interstate 275 and its spurs, 34th Street, and three boulevards: Gandy, Tyrone and Roosevelt.

The city's ban on billboards within 500 feet of a residential area would stay in effect. The new billboards would be larger, up to 14 feet by 48 feet.

Should the City Council approve the mayor's deal? I'd suggest there are three levels of consideration:

(1) The aesthetic tradeoff, which is somewhat a matter of opinion. The mayor feels that it is worth the trade, getting rid of 100 billboards around the city in exchange for 10 digital signs on the highways. If you hate digital billboards with a passion, you could make the opposite case.

(2) The safety question. Are digital billboards too distracting to drivers? There's a major federal study coming out in 2010, and critics of the St. Petersburg deal argue that any decision should be delayed (which is the path that Pinellas County took).

On the other hand, there already is a mountain of conflicting studies, and the 2010 report is not going to make new recommendations about rules, placement and so forth. The city's proposed rules for digital billboards do contain good safety requirements.

(3) On the most detailed level, there are some loose spots in the new ordinance and deal with Clear Channel the City Council is being asked to approve.

Personally, I wouldn't approve the ordinance without these changes. However, the mayor and his staff seem amenable to making them:

• Making it clear that all future requests for digital billboards — not just the Clear Channel deal — require a swap of existing signs. The practical effect would be to limit future digital billboards to existing owners.

• Making it clear that any digital billboard must be on the spot of an existing sign.

• Including a specific, 2,500-foot minimum distance between signs, in addition to the requirement that drivers not be able to see two at once.

• Clearing up confusing language over maximum allowed height, and a loophole that allows extra height in case of visual obstruction such as trees.

Lastly, a suggestion from the group Scenic St. Petersburg makes sense: We're talking about an industry known for challenging sign ordinances in court. Would it hurt to hire the Smartest Billboard Lawyer in the World for advice on whether this ordinance has unintended consequences?

This brings us back to the issues of whether to wait for the federal safety study, which is a reasonable thing to argue, and whether you just don't like digital billboards, which is a personal position.

Me, I'm a digital kind of guy. I'd plug the loopholes, check with a smart lawyer and take the deal. No plugs, no deal.

Plug the loopholes and do the digital billboard deal in St. Petersburg 12/07/09 [Last modified: Monday, December 7, 2009 8:19pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Fatal hit and run closes section of Nebraska Avenue


    TAMPA — Police are investigating a fatal hit and run crash early Sunday morning on Nebraska Avenue.

  2. Sunday Conversation: Roberto Torres talks immigration

    Human Interest


    Roberto Torres stands as one of the city's most impressive rising entrepreneurs. The owner of Blind Tiger Cafes, Black & Denim clothing company and CoWork Ybor has expanded his reach with locations at Tampa International Airport and The Morrison, a new mixed use development in the SoHo District. Torres, …

    Roberto Torres receives his American Dream award from U.S. Rep. Kathy Castor on Aug. 15.
  3. Tampa police officer shoots man in Ybor


    A Tampa police officer shot a man while investigating a trespassing call at a vacant house on the eastern edge Ybor City early this morning, police officials said.

    Daniel Olinger, 68, was shot by an officer investigating a tresspassing call early Sunday morning. [Tampa Police]
  4. Comedian and activist Dick Gregory dies at 84


    The comedian Dick Gregory rose to national prominence in the early 1960s as a black satirist whose audacious style of humor was biting, subversive and topical, mostly centered on current events, politics and above all, racial tensions. His trademark was the searing punchline.

    Dick Gregory, a comedian, activist and author, died Saturday. [Tribune News Service, 2011]