Thursday, April 26, 2018
News Roundup

Push for more independent review of St. Petersburg impact fees takes detour

ST. PETERSBURG — Earlier this year city leaders sought more accountability in the collection of impact fees after a miscalculation that cost taxpayers nearly $160,000.

In a push for clarity to prevent similar mistakes, the City Council voted Jan. 12 to order an outside audit of all transportation impact fees collected since 2008.

But late last month — in the latest twist in a 7-year-old mistake that continues to vex City Hall — the council backtracked. Members voted instead to await the results of an internal review, then have external auditors review that work.

"There's nothing independent about this," said council member Wengay Newton. "Everyone with the city has already told me they don't know what happened. No matter what they bring back, they've already told me they didn't know who did what, they didn't know how it happened, and they don't know if it could happen again."

It's a City Hall mystery that started in 2004 when city plans examiner Don Tyre reviewed the Hilton at Carillon Park project and intentionally undercharged developers by more than $200,000 in transportation impact fees.

The error was discovered three years later by county reviewers.

A followup investigation by the city uncovered nothing. Tyre said he purposely miscalculated because he was told to do so by a supervisor, whom he didn't identify because he said he couldn't remember who it was.

The city sued to recoup the money from Hilton developers, but settled in November for $60,000 — $159,951 less than what was owed. Later, some council members said they regretted their vote to settle and blamed city staff for providing incomplete information.

Having voted against the settlement with Newton, Steve Kornell pushed for an outside review of the construction services department that made the error.

During the Jan. 12 meeting, Newton, Council Chair Leslie Curran, Jeff Danner, Charlie Gerdes and Karl Nurse joined Kornell to approve an outside audit.

Council members spent more than an hour debating the audit in a rambling discussion so confusing that the city clerk had to read back what they were voting on four separate times.

"Are you clear on that?" Curran said before approval. "Hallelujah," Curran said after the vote.

Not so fast.

Although the vote required the council to meet in a month to determine the audit's scope, the schedule was so cluttered with other workshops that they didn't discuss the topic again until March 29.

And that's when it fell apart.

Over an hour and 40 minutes, council members argued about what it was that they approved in January.

"Was it worth $50,000, whatever it was, and do an external audit?" Bill Dudley said. "My recollection is that we decided to, at that juncture, not to do it."

"That's not true," Kornell said.

But for much of the meeting, council members disputed this fact.

They demanded to review the minutes of the January meeting to determine how they voted. Upon seeing the minutes, Jeff Danner argued they were wrong.

"Get the tape," Danner said.

The video confirmed the minutes.

Further confounding matters was Mayor Bill Foster, who said his own internal audit of impact fee collection since 2008 was near completion. Foster said at the January meeting he supported an external audit if the council wanted it, but he also staunchly defended city employees by suggesting concerns were overblown.

Now, Foster was suggesting council members could wait and see what his internal auditor, Brad Scott, would find. Scott reviewed the Hilton case in 2007 in an investigation that was cursory at best. He didn't take notes. And at least two of the five people who could have been involved said they weren't interviewed.

Scott said this new internal review would be thorough.

Out of a total of 3,161 projects between January 2008 to December 2011, the report will review 100 with transportation impact fees.

"Given that we're two weeks away from the internal audit, it makes sense to wait and figure out what we want to do," Nurse said.

So the council approved having the external auditor, Laura Krueger Brock, forgo her own inquiry into the collection of fees and review instead the internal report once it's done.

Foster said the report will show the city is following proper procedure.

Dudley and Jim Kennedy voted against further review. They worried about the cost, which should be about $40,000. Newton objected because he thought it was pointless for outside auditors to review an audit by city employees. Kornell voted to support it.

Michael Van Sickler can be reached at (727) 893-8037 or [email protected]

Comments
The Lightning are fun, but does their playoff run translate into dollars for Tampa?

The Lightning are fun, but does their playoff run translate into dollars for Tampa?

TAMPA — As the Tampa Bay Lightning wait for its next playoff opponent to come to town, the city’s business community — large and small — say they’ve already won this NHL postseason.At WestShore Plaza this week, with blue and white banners surrounding...
Updated: 4 minutes ago
SOCom leader wanted to toss Google exec from car. Because he was right.

SOCom leader wanted to toss Google exec from car. Because he was right.

TAMPA — Standing in front of an audience of several thousand scientists, data wonks, geospatial intelligence analysts and other big thinkers, Army Gen. Tony Thomas drew some laughs when he talked about the time he felt the urge to toss Google CEO Eri...
Updated: 13 minutes ago
The last cigar factory in Tampa keeps rolling

The last cigar factory in Tampa keeps rolling

YBOR CITY -- History lives here, inside the J.C. Newman Cigar Co.Machines manufactured in the 1930s are still used to pack and roll the cigars, and the sights and smells are throwbacks. Tobacco bits litter the weathered wooden floor, and a pungent od...
Updated: 15 minutes ago
Romano: Is it still environmentally conscious if it’s based on a sham?

Romano: Is it still environmentally conscious if it’s based on a sham?

Let’s discuss biosolids waste. I promise, it won’t be gross or boring.No, this is more of a how-did-we-lose-money-again bedtime story.Our tale begins around 2006 when St. Pete officials began exploring a biosolids project. The city was eventually goi...
Updated: 1 hour ago
The Daystarter: Federal court blocks challenge to Florida’s system of restoring felon voting rights; what goes on in that pink house?; Lightning playoff run drives business

The Daystarter: Federal court blocks challenge to Florida’s system of restoring felon voting rights; what goes on in that pink house?; Lightning playoff run drives business

Catching you up on overnight happenings, and what to know today.• Another sunny day today with high temperatures in the low 80s, according to 10Weather WTSP. Friday brings the possibility of rain, and the weekend brings the heat: Sunday’s high is in...
Updated: 1 hour ago
The Iron Nun still going strong at age 88

The Iron Nun still going strong at age 88

TAMPA —These smart phones and computers and internet are big annoyances to Sister Madonna Buder.Every time she turns around, there's a message or a request or a question coming into one of her devices from somewhere in the world."What's all the...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Long wait at Wingstop ends in brawl, hot oil and 2nd degree burns

Long wait at Wingstop ends in brawl, hot oil and 2nd degree burns

TAMPA — A customer visited Wingstop on Sunday night to pick-up his order. What happened next was off-menu:Robert Williams said he suffered second-degree burns on his back and legs after a Wingstop employee threw hot oil on him during a scuffle.Willia...
Updated: 7 hours ago
FHP identifies driver in crash that killed

FHP identifies driver in crash that killed "smiling" teen

TRINITY — Friends said what they’ll remember the most about Lillia Morris is that she was always smiling.The 17-year-old Mitchell High School junior was killed Tuesday when a sport-utility vehicle ran a red light on State Road 54 and slammed into the...
Updated: 8 hours ago
Berlin stands against anti-Semitism; Toronto attack highlights misogynistic vitriol; inventor convicted of killing Kim Wall; more in world news

Berlin stands against anti-Semitism; Toronto attack highlights misogynistic vitriol; inventor convicted of killing Kim Wall; more in world news

Germany‘Today, we all wear kippa’ Germans of various faiths donned Jewish skullcaps and took to the streets Wednesday in several cities to protest an anti-Semitic attack in Berlin and express fears about growing hatred of Jews in Germany and across E...
Updated: 10 hours ago
Parents are buzzing about Pinellas’ newest magnet school

Parents are buzzing about Pinellas’ newest magnet school

ST. PETERSBURG — If the crowds that showed up for two open houses last week are any indication, the Pinellas County school district may have hit on a recipe that could finally turn around one of its most struggling schools.The two events drew more th...
Published: 04/26/18