Thursday, December 14, 2017
News Roundup

Report says Hernando County utilities worker's claim of harassment unfounded

BROOKSVILLE — A claim by a county utilities worker of retaliation and harassment by his bosses has been determined to be unfounded, according to the results of an investigation released by the county this week.

Chris Soto, an inspector in the Utilities Department and a Teamsters union steward, claimed he was being harassed and that assistant utilities director Jesse Goodwin was aggressive and hostile in talking with him about a possible job change.

In a Dec. 5 email, the day after his meeting with Goodwin, Soto wrote: "I believe this attempt to remove me from my position as an engineering inspector was a retaliatory action for the many union issues and grievances filed by employees that I have helped to represent.''

The investigator saw it differently.

"Christopher Soto's conversation with Jesse Goodwin may well have appeared to be threatening, intimidating, harassing and retaliatory in Soto's subjective perception,'' wrote investigator Kent Weissinger. "However, given all the information derived from the interviews of supervisors and employees, it seems likely that the conversation was not intended by Goodwin to be that way.''

The report is the latest peek into the workings of the Utilities Department, which has been plagued by harassment and discrimination allegations for several years.

Weissinger's report recounts details of dysfunction in the operation of the utilities office, including battles between employees. One, engineer Diana Koontz, has filed a federal discrimination complaint. Another, her supervisor, Dale Ravencraft, was forced to resign after he refused to discipline Koontz for what he considered a minor error.

Ravencraft wrote a long, scathing memo, detailing the internal strife and "hostile work environment" at the utilities office.

Even as Weissinger was investigating Soto's complaint, employees revealed another harassment allegation that is now being investigated separately.

In the midst of the internal turmoil, utilities head Susan Goebel-Canning started an internal efficiency study. The so-called "manpower evaluation'' is examining where the department might be able to cut costs.

On the morning of Dec. 4, Soto was called into Goebel-Canning's office to answer why witnesses had reported that he was in his county truck at two locations one day where no county work was taking place. He had explanations for each case. At the end of the session, Goodwin asked Soto to stop by the Wiscon Road utilities office later.

The two arrived at the office at the same time, and Goodwin asked to talk to Soto in the parking lot. He asked Soto if he would be willing to work temporarily as a water plant operator, a job he had done before he became inspector. Soto said he had no interest in that job.

"At that time, (Goodwin's) demeanor and tone began to change from pleasant to firm then to terse, bordering on contempt,'' Soto wrote in his email to the Teamsters, copied to the county's human resources head, Cheryl Marsden, and Assistant County Attorney Jon Jouben.

Then, Soto wrote, Goodwin began to talk to him about permanent placement in the operator's job if his inspector's job were to be eliminated.

"It was during that discussion the statement was made, 'The way I see it, you have two options. Take the job or not have a job,' '' Soto quoted Goodwin as saying.

"I found this comment to be intimidating and threatening, meant to bully me into complying with his wishes by playing on the fear of separation of employment,'' Soto wrote. "I was greatly offended by this openly aggressive and hostile statement.''

Soto told Goodwin that he thought Goebel-Canning had a negative perception of him because he has helped employees with workplace complaints as part of his union steward's job. Goodwin ended the conversation saying he would tell Goebel-Canning what his answer was regarding the plant operator's job.

Goodwin's version of the conversation was somewhat different. He denied telling Soto that he had to switch jobs or he would not have one.

But Goodwin did acknowledge that some people do not like working for him because he holds his employees accountable, especially when they are in the public eye.

Another employee told Weissinger that Goodwin's management style is "always a form of intimidation'' and he didn't think Goodwin realized the effect that had on some workers.

Months before the incident with Soto, Goebel-Canning had an informal counseling session with Goodwin.

"I explained to him that his tone comes across very strong to some employees and he needs to be mindful of that fact when conveying his message,'' she said.

Goodwin said that his approach is to get employees to do the work they were hired to do. Those who do their jobs should not feel intimidated by him, he said.

Soto took issue with Weissinger's findings.

"Intimidation is not a management style,'' Soto told the Times. "It's prohibited by the Fair Labor Act.''

He said the findings were "pretty much what I expected. … It's a document to cover the county's backside.''

Soto said other interviews with employees who agreed with his viewpoint were ignored by Weissinger. He called the investigation "a farce'' and "a dog and pony show.''

He said he plans to obtain the interview notes and submit them to an independent human resources expert.

Weissinger is a former assistant county attorney, and during his tenure he oversaw legal issues for the Utilities Department. He was chosen for the investigator's job for that reason and because Marsden had a conflict in investigating because she administers the employee contract and heads up the administration's negotiating team with the Teamsters, according to Jouben.

Soto is on the bargaining team for the Teamsters.

"The county considered Kent to be both independent and unbiased,'' Jouben told the Times in an email.

Barbara Behrendt can be reached at [email protected] or (352) 848-1434.

Comments

Lottery resultsNumbers drawn after 9 p.m. are no longer available by our deadlines. For results, please go to tampabay.com/lottery.Pick 2, 3, 4, 5Wed., Dec. 13, midday:53 738 7036e_SRit10321Wed., Dec. 13, evening:57 775 2681e_SRit55890LottoWed., Dec....
Updated: 5 hours ago

Winter meetings journal: Rays trade for money to sign top international free agent

LAKE BUENA VISTA — While most of the business conducted at the meetings impacts the big-league team one way or another, the Rays are working to finalize a move they hope pays off big sometime in the 2020s.In trading Wednesday to acquire $1 million in...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Market starting to set itself as Rays’ trade talks intensify

Market starting to set itself as Rays’ trade talks intensify

LAKE BUENA VISTA — Alex Colome claimed he was just showing good social media manners Tuesday night in following four Cardinals-related Instagram accounts since they were saying nice things about him.In doing so, whether for that reason or another mor...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Senate race motivated Alabama’s white, black evangelical voters in different ways

Senate race motivated Alabama’s white, black evangelical voters in different ways

Nationally, the word "evangelical" has become in recent years nearly synonymous with "conservative Republican" and Alabama is one of the most evangelical states in the country. But in Alabama, there is a difference: black Christians.While in many par...
Updated: 5 hours ago
Gators crash volleyball power party, play national semifinal Thursday

Gators crash volleyball power party, play national semifinal Thursday

KANSAS CITY, Mo. — It’s difficult to call a volleyball program that has been to the Final Four eight times an underdog, especially the way Florida rallied to beat Southern California and punch its latest ticket. Yet of the four schools descending on ...
Updated: 6 hours ago

High school scoreboard for Dec. 13

Wednesday’s scoreboardGirls soccerCountryside 3, St. Petersburg 1Girls basketballPalm Harbor U. 42, Largo 25
Updated: 6 hours ago
Minnesota Lt. Gov. Tina Smith named to fill Franken seat

Minnesota Lt. Gov. Tina Smith named to fill Franken seat

ST. PAUL, Minn. — Minnesota Gov. Mark Dayton appointed Lt. Gov. Tina Smith on Wednesday to fill fellow Democrat Al Franken’s Senate seat until a special election in November, setting up his longtime and trusted adviser for a potentially bruising 2018...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Florida Toys for Tots charity raffles off AR-15 rifle. Gun debate ensues.

Florida Toys for Tots charity raffles off AR-15 rifle. Gun debate ensues.

SPRING HILL — Hernando County Commission Vice Chairman Steve Champion wanted to do something to help raise money for the annual Toys for Tots drive. So he donated the grand prize for the Nov. 18 raffle:It was an AR-15 semiautomatic rifle.That led to ...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Thefts from cell towers interrupted service, deputies say

Thefts from cell towers interrupted service, deputies say

Lost cell signal recently? The culprit could be a 40-year-old Ruskin man who deputies said stole thousands of dollars worth of the equipment that powers cell towers. The theft interrupted cell tower signals on at least two occasions, deputies said, i...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Foot washes ashore in Canada, again; Abbas wants U.S. out as Mideast mediator; 12 sentenced to life for gang-raping kids; more in world news

Foot washes ashore in Canada, again; Abbas wants U.S. out as Mideast mediator; 12 sentenced to life for gang-raping kids; more in world news

CanadaJust another foot washing ashoreAnother human foot has been found on British Columbia’s coastline, the 13th such grim discovery since 2007. Police said a man was walking on the beach in Jordan River on Vancouver Island when his dog found the fo...
Updated: 7 hours ago