Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Safety Harbor won't allow home to be used as facilitly for mentally disabled men

SAFETY HARBOR — At the end of a marathon meeting Tuesday night that lasted until 1:30 a.m., the City Commission voted to forbid a home in the Harbor Woods Village subdivision from being used as a family care home for six mentally disabled young men.

Bonnie Jo Hill, of Pinellas Park, owns the home at 59 Harbor Woods Circle and has renovated it in hopes of housing a half-dozen men aged 17 to 24. She has operated two other homes in Pinellas County since 2004.

But according to state law, community residential homes aren't allowed to be within 1,000 feet of each other unless the local government approves the home for a conditional use.

Hill said that when she bought the home, she didn't know there was an assisted living facility in the same neighborhood less than 300 feet away — Melody Place, at 35 Harbor Woods Circle.

The commission's unanimous vote came after a five-hour hearing.

Mayor Andy Steingold summed up the commission's reasons, saying it was unfortunate for the applicant because it was just too close to the existing group home, which would affect neighboring property values.

"I've got to balance the right to have a group home and the rights of the neighborhood," the mayor said.

Last week, Safety Harbor's planning and zoning board recommended denying the homeowner's application in a 6-1 vote because of the effect the home would have on adjoining property values.

The case called for a quasi-judicial hearing before the City Commission, where the applicant and an opposing party argue their cases by calling witnesses, cross examining and presenting evidence.

The commission chamber moved from standing-room only to three-quarters full as the hearing crawled on and on, from hour to hour, with cross examinations and emotional banter between lawyers often slowing the pace of the hearing.

Among the witnesses were Hill, her employees, residents of Harbor Woods Village and a land development consultant.

Hill's attorney, Richard Heiden, argued that denying the conditional use would be an act of discrimination and a violation of the federal Fair Housing Act.

"They don't have a voice," he said of the six young men. "The only voice is the law. And the law is clear."

According to the Fair Housing Act, it is illegal for any person or entity to refuse to make reasonable accommodations in rules, policies, practices or services when such accommodations may be necessary to provide those with disabilities equal opportunity to a live in a home.

The opposition, a group of homeowners from the Harbor Woods Village subdivision, maintained that they took issue with the effect the two community residential homes would have on the property values of nearby homes and the precedent that would be set by allowing an exception to the statute.

Deborah Martohue, the attorney who represented the homeowners, said the two homes in such close proximity could create a clustering effect, and could alter the neighborhood and go against the idea that family care homes are supposed to help integrate the inhabitants into average neighborhoods.

"You're clustering them," she said Wednesday. "You're isolating them, in a way."

After the hearing, Heiden said Hill is planning on taking legal action.

"At this point we are examining all lawful avenues of redress for what we consider to be discrimination last night," Heiden said Wednesday.

Hill assured that she was prepared for a long fight.

"It just can't be over," she said.

Safety Harbor won't allow home to be used as facilitly for mentally disabled men 04/20/11 [Last modified: Wednesday, April 20, 2011 7:39pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. World's plastic waste could bury Manhattan 2 miles deep


    WASHINGTON — Industry has made more than 9.1 billion tons of plastic since 1950 and there's enough left over to bury Manhattan under more than 2 miles of trash, according to a new cradle-to-grave global study.

    Plastic trash is compacted into bales ready for further processing at the waste processing dump on the outskirts of Minsk, Belarus.
  2. Sen. John McCain's type of cancer did not slow Tampa woman


    TAMPA —When 35-year-old Beth Caldwell heard about Sen. John McCain's brain tumor this week, she hoped he would stay positive.

    That's what helped her, she said.

    Beth Caldwell, 35, and her sons Gavin, 10, and Triston, 7. Caldwell had surgery to remove an aggressive brain tumor three years ago. [Photo Courtesy of Beth Caldwell]
  3. A week later, the lengthy, costly rebuilding plan for the Pasco sinkhole begins

    Public Safety

    LAND O'LAKES — A week after a massive sinkhole opened in Pasco County, county officials have begun planning the long-term cleanup, which could take months and millions of dollars.

    A sinkhole in Land O'Lakes, Fla., is seen Wednesday, July 19, 2017. The sinkhole ?‘ already one of the largest in Pasco County in decades ?‘ measures about 235 feet in width and 50 feet in depth, with the potential to expand further.
  4. Dade City's Wild Things blocks PETA officials at gates for court-ordered site inspection


    Times Staff Writer

    DADE CITY — Dade City's Wild Things founder Kathy Stearns refused to let People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals officials enter her facility on Thursday for a court-ordered inspection, court filings show.

    Dade City's Wild Things founder Kathy Stearns refused to let People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals officials enter her facility on Thursday for a court-ordered inspection, court filings show. This comes four days after 19 Wild Things tigers arrived at the Greater Wynnewood Exotic Animal Park in Oklahoma. A judge had granted an emergency injunction July 14, ordering Stearns not remove any tigers pending the upcoming PETA inspection. Photo from Facebook page of the Greater Wynnewood Exotic Animal Park in Oklahoma.
  5. St. Petersburg City Council approves $326 million sewage fix


    ST. PETERSBURG — Last week the City Council learned no criminal charges would result from the up to 200 million gallons of sewage St. Petersburg's sewer system released from …

    [LARA CERRI  |  Times]