Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Simmering Summerfield homeowners association recall goes to Florida arbitrator

RIVERVIEW — Some residents were fed up. About $150,000 of the homeowners association's reserve money was spent — wrongly, they believed — and someone had to answer for it.

So a group in the sprawling Summerfield community gathered signatures to oust the board. But six months later, Summerfield's board hasn't budged.

That's because the board members say the petition process was rife with irregularities. The dispute has landed before a Tallahassee arbitrator.

Three months and several thousand dollars in legal fees later, the conflict rages on and might not conclude until October, about five months after some board members are up for re-election.

Depending on who's talking, the ongoing battle in the community off Big Bend Road is either about misplaced financial priorities or lingering personality conflicts.

Meet Lee Ann Daley, an eight-year resident who was the association's treasurer when the board voted to use reserve money for a community center addition and upgrades to accommodate handicapped people. She voted against it because she felt the decision was an abuse of spending power.

"I said, 'No, you can't do that,' " she said. "The board taking money out of the reserves was wrong, so I resigned."

Another resident pitched the idea of recalling the board. She learned that she needed a majority of residents to sign a recall petition. Ultimately, she said, 300 of 465 residents sided with her.

Rather than resign immediately, the board members picked apart her petition. Some signatures are invalid and others came from renters and people who had fallen behind in association dues, said board president Roland Santiago. The association followed Florida law by taking the issue to an arbitrator rather than immediately going forward with the proposed ouster, he added.

Santiago, who was among those targeted by the recall, chafed at the petition and reserve-spending conflict. Though some of the signatures were questionable, he said, the petition isn't representative of the community's wants.

"There are 3,400 homes in the community. The petition included 300 (names)," he said.

The dispute runs much deeper than reserve funds, Santiago said. Daley, whom he said had served a prior term on the board, wanted a shuffleboard court and activity room built rather than handicap-compliance improvements.

"Because she didn't get her project funded, she resigned," he said, attributing the tension to "personality conflicts."

Daley denies wanting a shuffleboard court, and said her last hours as a board member are characterized by deceptively inaccurate minutes. She agrees that her approach to some association issues might not have sat well with other board leaders.

"I tend to know what I'm talking about," she said. There was a time, she said, when another board member told her she came to meetings with an air of authority. "I have a very strong personality. I do a lot of research," she said. "I think they all disliked me. I don't think there was anyone there who cares for me. It's not a popularity contest."

Because of recall rules, Daley stands to be named as a board member should the petition hold. She insists she's not angling for power, and that she'll only take the unpaid position if no one else volunteers.

Brian Dwyer, who resigned his board position when he moved out of Summerfield in December, said there are questions as to whether Daley was forthright in the petition's language. He said the drive "was not handled properly," and "really just gave out tidbits of information." He described Daley's efforts as "cage rattling" and said money the board spent on lawyer's fees is a waste.

Lorraine Pinette, who led the petition drive along with Daley, countered that past history of reserve-fund spending gives reason for wariness.

None of the dozen or so residents at the community center on a recent weekday afternoon knew anything about the pending arbitration. And their opinions about the board were split between dislike and satisfaction.

The arbitrator will decide how many signatures are required for the recall, and whether those names were collected properly. Unlike criminal trials and civil suits, arbitrator's decisions don't set precedent like those of judges, said Mark Fenster, a professor and property-law expert at the University of Florida.

Lawyers who work on homeowners association cases might discuss the arbitrator's decision to prep for future cases, Fenster said, but each case is different.

"Any new dispute might have wrinkles in it," he said.

Victoria Bekiempis can be reached at (813) 661-2442 or

Simmering Summerfield homeowners association recall goes to Florida arbitrator 02/19/09 [Last modified: Thursday, February 19, 2009 3:30am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Romano: The choice does not have to be poverty or gentrification

    Local Government

    The memories must be protected. The music and the lore, too.

    The owner of Sylvia's Queen of Soul Food is refusing to give the city information on the restaurant's sales as required by his contract to occupy the city-owned Manhattan Casino. The information is needed to calculate whether the nonprofit Urban Development Solutions, headed by Larry Newsome, owes the city more than the $3,000 monthly base rent.
  2. Tests show North Korea earthquake not caused by nuclear test


    SEOUL, South Korea — South Korea's weather agency said a magnitude 3.0 earthquake was detected in North Korea on Saturday around where the country recently conducted a nuclear test, but it assessed the quake as natural.

    People watch a TV news program reporting North Korea's earthquake, at Seoul Railway Station in Seoul, South Korea, Saturday, Sept. 23, 2017. South Korea's weather agency said an earthquake was detected in North Korea on Saturday around where the country recently conducted a nuclear test, but it assessed the quake as natural. The signs read " The weather agency said a magnitude 3.0 earthquake was detected in North Korea." [Associated Press]
  3. New 6.2 magnitude earthquake centered in southern Mexico


    MEXICO CITY — The U.S. Geological Survey says the new earthquake to strike Mexico had a magnitude of 6.2 and was centered in the southern state of Oaxaca.

  4. Bucs players respond to Trump comments on anthem protests


    President Donald Trump shared his thoughts Friday night on NFL players protesting during the national anthem, suggesting that NFL owners should "fire" players who kneel during the anthem in protest. His remarks are alreading drawing responses from many NFL players, including some Bucs.

    Bucs players Mike Evans and Jameis Winston stand with coach Dirk Koetter during the national anthem in a game played in San Diego last season.
  5. Rays morning after: Wilson Ramos showing glimpses of what's possible in 2018


    The real payoff for the Rays signing C Wilson Ramos last off-season will come in 2018, when he can play a full season fully recovered from right knee surgery.

    Catcher Wilson Ramos connects for a two-run single in the fifth inning against the Cubs on Sept. 20, 2017.