Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Sixteen residents sue Caddy's, Treasure Island

TREASURE ISLAND — The ongoing battle between Sunset Beach residents and Caddy's on the Beach is headed to court.

A class-action lawsuit filed against the popular beachfront bar and restaurant at 9000 W Gulf Blvd. has also ensnared the city of Treasure Island as a co-defendant.

At issue is whether Caddy's business activities violate city land-use regulations, leading to an "unlawful public nuisance," and whether the city, by allowing Caddy's to continue these operations, has failed to properly enforce its own zoning and land-use codes.

Some residents contend that Caddy's interferes with their property rights and lowers property values. Their complaints came to a head last spring when thousands of beach visitors jammed the beach and neighborhood streets.

Caddy's owner and operator Tony Amico says he is tired of fighting Sunset Beach residents, but he defends his right to operate.

During the height of the beach season, Amico said he spent about $12,000 a month for extra police and private security. He also had crews regularly clean the beach and set up portable toilets for beachgoers.

"I don't think we want to stop people from coming to the beach. Caddy's has been there since 1946 and now is a destination location where people stay all day. We are doing everything in our power to control the crowds. We are doing the best we can," Amico said.

City Manager Reid Silverboard declined to comment on the lawsuit, but did confirm that although many residents complain loudly about Caddy's during public meetings, no resident filed a formal code violation complaint in the past year.

Sixteen Sunset Beach residents are suing T.I. Holdings Inc., which owns Caddy's property; Gulf Sands Properties LLC, which owns and operates Caddy's; and the city of Treasure Island.

The residents are Andrew and Mary Beth Becker, Mike and Mary Daughtry, R.B. Nicholson, Raymond D. Green, Catherine J. Rezak, Randy and Dee Dee Kahn, Robin J. Welborn, William D. Fowler, Michael and Kathy DeLong, Robb Gottron, Stephen Poohar and Jeffrey S. Warner. Attorney David Bacon filed the suit Dec. 7 on their behalf.

The lawsuit's complaints against Caddy's include:

• The selling and serving of food and alcohol that attracts a crowd that exceeds the restaurant's occupancy, seating, parking and restroom capacities.

• "Abnormal and unreasonable" amounts of pedestrian traffic and vehicular traffic and "improper" parking on neighborhood streets, blocking residents' ability to leave or enter their properties and travel on their own streets.

• "Unreasonably excessive" noise from music played at Caddy's that interferes with residents' "quiet and peaceful enjoyment" of their properties.

• "Intoxicated and disorderly" conduct by Caddy's customers, who leave trash and debris on the beach and residential properties, and are guilty of frequent trespassing and "urinating" on private residential properties.

The residents are seeking an injunction to bar any commercial activities on the Caddy's properties that would be "unreasonably excessive" and violate city codes. They also want the court to order the city to "reasonably enforce" its own land-use regulations to prohibit unlawful business activities at Caddy's.

Sixteen residents sue Caddy's, Treasure Island 12/19/09 [Last modified: Saturday, December 19, 2009 3:30am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Deputies: Tampa man killed after car strikes tree


    TOWN 'N COUNTRY — A 24-year-old man was killed early Sunday after he lost control of his car, causing it to hit a pine tree.

  2. O.J. Simpson had a 'conflict-free life'? Not really, not in Florida


    LOS ANGELES — When O.J. Simpson told a Nevada parole board last week that he's led a "conflict-free life," he seemed to overlook a few episodes that had him cycling in and out of courtrooms and jail cells for nearly 20 years before the Las Vegas hotel-room heist that sent him to prison in 2008.

    Former NFL football star O.J. Simpson appears via video for his parole hearing at the Lovelock Correctional Center in Lovelock, Nev., on Thursday, July 20, 2017.  Simpson was granted parole Thursday after more than eight years in prison for a Las Vegas hotel heist, successfully making his case in a nationally televised hearing that reflected America's enduring fascination with the former football star.  [The Reno Gazette-Journal via AP]
  3. Baby Charlie protesters to rally as hospital reports threats


    LONDON — Protesters who want critically ill British baby Charlie Gard to receive an experimental medical treatment are planning a rally and prayer vigil Sunday, while hospital officials say emotions are running so high in the heart-breaking case they have received death threats.

    Reverend Patrick Mahoney from Washington DC, centre, speaks to the media outside the Royal Courts of Justice in London, as he joins other Charlie Gard supporters, Sunday July 23, 2017. Protesters who want critically ill British baby Charlie Gard to receive an experimental medical treatment gathered for a rally and prayer vigil Sunday, while hospital officials say emotions are running so high in the heart-breaking case they have received death threats. [Associated Press]