Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

St. Petersburg's choice: Spend $50 million to keep the Pier or close it and save $1 million a year

ST. PETERSBURG — The city's iconic Pier is on such wobbly financial footing that taxpayers would save $1 million a year by simply closing it, according to a new city analysis.

The analysis creates questions about the city's long-held plans to spend $50 million to rebuild the Pier's deteriorating infrastructure.

Since 2001, the Pier has cost city taxpayers nearly $12 million, budget figures show. Last month, the city further reduced rents for about a dozen struggling tenants who threatened to close.

City officials acknowledge there is no plan to ever break even, let alone turn a profit.

The sobering financial outlook surfaced during a discussion about rebuilding the Pier's quarter-mile-long approach and pier head. The project would not include replacing the Pier building, which opened in 1973. The Pier is owned by the city but managed by a private company.

"In the private sector, nobody would spend $50 million with an operating subsidy (on top of) that," said City Council member Karl Nurse. "Nobody in their right mind would build it. Except the government."

City officials have not decided what to do, and a decision could be years away. Mayor Rick Baker is forming a citizen task force to recommend a course of action.

A 5-year-old engineering study determined that the Pier's approach and base must be rebuilt by 2014. Exposure to saltwater has weakened it, requiring costly maintenance and ongoing repairs. If the $50 million overhaul is approved, work is expected to begin in 2012.

The project would be paid for through a process called tax increment financing, which dedicates city and county property tax dollars for capital projects downtown.

While no one wants the Pier to disappear, economic realities suggest something might have to change. The city faces a possible $20 million budget shortfall next year.

Baker has asked each city department to plan for budget reductions up to 3 percent, and City Council members have discussed switching some employee work schedules from five eight-hour days a week to four 10-hour days.

Despite its cost, some defend the Pier as a treasured piece of city history.

"The Pier is an attraction," said City Council member Leslie Curran. "Love it or hate it, it does draw people not only to St. Petersburg, but Pinellas County."

But the Pier has seen attendance drop by almost half this decade — from nearly 2 million visitors in 2001 to just over 1 million in 2008.

The complex's small retail spaces have made it unattractive to regional and national chains, and uncertainty about the Pier's future make current tenants hesitant to improve their stores.

Negative perceptions of the kitschy shops have kept locals away.

Keeping it open indefinitely would cost taxpayers almost $1.5 million a year, plus the $50 million in needed infrastructure repairs.

Closing and fencing off the Pier would cost about $500,000, according to city officials. Demolishing the Pier and its approach would cost $6 million.

"These are the doomsday scenarios that have to be said," said City Council member Herb Polson. "You could spend $50 million and not see a thing differently. That's hard for the common man to understand."

36 years at the upside-down Pier

1973: Upside-down pyramid structure is built.

1975: "The Laser," an artistic display that featured inch-thick beams of light crisscrossing triangular patterns above the Pier, makes its debut. It's discontinued in 1978 due to technical difficulties.

1978: City enlists additional "foot patrolmen" to stave off drunks and other undesirables. The Pier is renamed "Pier Place."

1983: Double-decker bus service arrives, along with new laser lights.

1986: The Pier is closed for an $11 million renovation.

1987: A new $187,000 outdoor lighting system debuts.

1989: A nighttime curfew is enacted after a 16-year-old girl is shot and killed near the Pier. She and a group of friends were being escorted away by security guards when a friend of the girl's fired at a guard, but shot the girl instead.

2006: City officials announce plans for a major $50 million restoration.

St. Petersburg's choice: Spend $50 million to keep the Pier or close it and save $1 million a year 02/27/09 [Last modified: Saturday, February 28, 2009 9:28pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Steve Kornell says small fix can help St. Pete's sewage problems


    ST. PETERSBURG— Steve Kornell knows his idea won't put much of a dent in the $326 million bill the city must pay over the next five years to fix its inadequate and outdated sewer system.

    St. Petersburg City Council member Steve Kornell (right) during a 2012 council meeting at City Hall. [SCOTT KEELER  |  Times]
  2. Can the Bad Boys Mowers Gasparilla Bowl thrive in competitive sports market?


    ST. PETERSBURG — It's a funky name: the Bad Boys Mowers Gasparilla Bowl. But the new sponsors for the former St. Petersburg Bowl might need more than an eye-catching name to create a thriving, profitable contest.

    NC State head coach Dave Doeren clutches the championship trophy after winning the Bitcoin Bowl at Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg in 2014. Bowl organizers are changing the name of the game to the Bad Boy Mowers Gasparilla Bowl.

  3. Dirk Koetter says Bucs used team meeting to discuss social issues


    Four days before their preseason home opener against the Cleveland Browns, which had 12 players not stand for the national anthem prior to their last game, the Bucs used their team meeting to discuss social issues that might have led to that demonstration, coach Dirk Koetter said.

    "The main thing is we have to respect everybody's opinion," Dirk Koetter said, "because everybody is not going to agree." [AP photo]
  4. Rookie tight end Antony Auclair making case to stick with Bucs


    Don't let his modest preseason stats fool you: Antony Auclair, the undrafted rookie tight end from Canada is making a strong case to stick around on the Bucs' 53-man roster this season.

    Bucs tight end Antony Auclair (82) collides with a defender following a catch during training camp. [CHARLIE KAIJO   |   Times]
  5. Who is that 'Blacks for Trump' guy standing behind the president at his Phoenix rally


    At a number of political rallies over the last two years, a character calling himself "Michael the Black Man" has appeared in the crowd directly behind Donald Trump, impossible to miss and possibly planted.

    Michael the Black Man, variously known as Michael Symonette, Maurice Woodside and Mikael Israel, holds up a sign as President Donald Trump speaks to a crowd at the Phoenix Convention Center during a rally on Tuesday in Phoenix, Arizona.  [Ralph Freso | Getty Images]