Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Tampa approves $165,000 settlement of lawsuit over arrest of deaf man

TAMPA — The City Council on Thursday voted to pay $165,000 to settle an excessive-force lawsuit brought by a deaf man whom police punched, kicked and stunned with a Taser on an Ybor City sidewalk nearly four years ago.

Jacob P. Cowie, 30, sued four Tampa officers in federal court over his arrest after the 2010 Krewe of Sant'Yago Knight Parade. A disorderly conduct charge against him was later dropped.

The council did not question the settlement but did ask officials to report on Jan. 9 how much the city has paid this year to make its legal problems go away.

"It seems like more and more," said council member Frank Reddick, who asked for the report. This year, the council has approved:

• $35,000 for a former city engineer who said she was fired because she has Chinese ancestry and is a woman. The city also agreed to rehire her.

• $200,000 to the mother of a fifth-grader who drowned at the Cyrus Greene Park pool four years ago while three lifeguards were on duty.

• $260,000 to four men and a woman arrested in an investigation of the Latin Kings gang. The case was based largely on the work of a felon turned informer who was allowed to break several laws.

• $75,000 to a woman hurt by a falling tree limb as she walked along a Palma Ceia street.

Those settlements, however, are dwarfed by the $3.75 million the city paid to a developer in 2012 over a City Council decision in 2004 to deny plans for a proposed condominium tower on Bayshore Boulevard at DeSoto Avenue.

Of the $165,000 settlement in the Cowie case, nearly $8,800 would go to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Service to cover Cowie's medical expenses. The rest would go to Cowie, who lives in Pinellas County, and his attorney, Michael Maddux.

"I think it's a solid settlement that reflects the egregious conduct that took place in this case," Maddux said. "I think a jury could have given him more money, but there's a value in closure and this case has gone on a long time."

Cowie said officers swarmed him as he was going to the aid of a friend being ejected from Gaspar's Grotto.

Officers said Cowie took a swing at the first officer who grabbed him. Cowie denies that. As that officer took Cowie to the sidewalk, Cowie's face slammed into a wrought-iron bench. Officers said they punched, kicked and used a Taser on Cowie because he would not stop resisting and let them see his hands.

Cowie suffered three broken bones in his face and a shoulder injury that not only required surgery, but also stopped his dream of a pursuing a career playing golf.

Cpl. Joseph J. Reese and Officers Gregory Pryor, Jayson G. Uriarte and John R. Gustafson were cleared by an internal affairs investigation. The city maintains police did not do anything wrong, but it did not want to risk taking the case to trial.

A bystander made a cellphone video of part of the arrest and posted it to YouTube. While city officials argued the video is misleading, a federal judge concluded that it "arguably contradicts the officers' version that plaintiff's hands were hidden under his body."

"On the contrary, the video appears to show Reese holding plaintiff's right arm even before the hitting, kicking and Tasering occur," U.S. Magistrate Judge Thomas B. McCoun III wrote in an order denying the city's motion to dismiss the case on summary judgment. "The left arm, when visible, is seen up near plaintiff's head as he claims."

Frank Reddick wants a report on the city’s legal settlements.

Frank Reddick wants a report on the city’s legal settlements.

Tampa approves $165,000 settlement of lawsuit over arrest of deaf man 12/19/13 [Last modified: Friday, December 20, 2013 12:03am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. For starters: Rays vs. Angels, with Cobb leading the way


    Rays veteran RHP Alex Cobb had a lot to say Monday about the team needing to focus on getting past .500 and building a winning record.

    And after the disappointing 3-2 loss that …

  2. Tampa murder suspect told police he wanted to stop neo-Nazi roommates from committing acts of domestic terrorism


    TAMPA — After he admitted to shooting two roommates and led police to their dead bodies, Devon Arthurs said he committed the killings to prevent the pair from carrying out terrorist acts, a prosecutor wrote in a court filing.

    Devon Arthurs, 18, told police  he shared neo-Nazi beliefs with his roommates, Jeremy Himmelman and Andrew Oneschuk, until he converted to Islam, according to a police report.
[Tampa Police]
  3. Pinellas School Board approves plan that aims to close achievement gap


    After months of behind-the-scenes negotiations, the Pinellas County School Board on Tuesday unanimously approved a plan that aims to tackle the achievement gap in 10 years and settles a long-running lawsuit over the education of …

    "I'm an optimist. I think this is going to work," Pinellas School Board member Linda Lerner said Tuesday after the board was presented with a plan that aims to settle a long-running lawsuit over the education of black students and close the achievement gap. The board voted 7-0 to approve the plan. [DIRK SHADD   |   Times]
  4. With big concerts approaching, Tampa Bay venues remain vigilant after Manchester attack

    Public Safety

    In the aftermath of an explosion that killed at least 22 people — including children — moments after a pop concert ended in England on Monday night, local venues are assuring the public that security will continue to be tight at the Tampa Bay area's upcoming big-ticket shows.

    Fans cross Himes Avenue in Tampa toward Raymond James Stadium before the start of Beyonce's Formation World Tour in Tampa on April 29, 2016. [LUIS SANTANA | Times]
  5. Kahwa Coffee to open second drive-thru store in St. Petersburg


    Kahwa Coffee will open its 12th location and fourth with a drive-thru in a former "farm store" in St. Petersburg.

    Kahwa Coffee will open its 12th location and fourth with a drive-thru in a former "farm store" in St. Petersburg.
[Times file photo]