Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Urban design expert likes St. Petersburg Pier proposals

ST. PETERSBURG — As debate about the competing Pier designs reaches a crescendo, some of the loudest voices would like to dismiss the lot from consideration as the new waterfront icon.

Sammie Bond, for example, wouldn't mind returning to the 1920s-era, Mediterranean-style Million Dollar Pier.

"I grew up here; born in St. Pete in 1946 and enjoyed 'the old Pier,' which had terra-cotta barrel tiled roof, Spanish architecture and the bottom floor was open air with music playing,'' Bond declared in an email. "You could walk around after church on Sunday and eat a five-cent ice cream cone.''

Urban specialist Vikas Mehta, 45, understands the nostalgia but thinks there's no going back.

"If you think of the inverted pyramid and the Mediterranean structure that preceded it, they were all icons of their time. Today, they seem extremely dated. We are in a time when we are able to reflect our own culture through current, contemporary style,'' said Mehta, an assistant professor of urban design and architecture at the University of South Florida in Tampa.

"Rather than borrowing from a past style, to me it's important that any building or urban design for the Pier be contemporary, but more important, that it be a true public space and establish a symbiotic relationship with the land and water and with the species and humans."

He praised the competing concepts for the $50 million project, the Eye from West 8 Urban Design in New York, the Wave from BIG of Denmark and New York City, and the Lens from Michael Maltzan Architecture of Los Angeles.

"They are of our time, but they raise some very interesting questions about asking ourselves to sort of reconsider the role and definition of the icon,'' he said.

"You look at the images and they all have done a very good job of icon-making.''

From his viewpoint, the designs are urbane, dynamic, contemporary and forward-thinking.

That many residents are passionate about the city's waterfront and what ends up there was evident from the outcry that met the Tampa Bay Rays' proposal for a waterfront stadium. The city in 2010 marked the centennial of its downtown waterfront parks, running 23 blocks from Albert Whitted Airport north to Coffee Pot Bayou.

Far from being discordant with a waterfront punctuated by old-world structures, the contemporary Pier designs have their place, Mehta said, and he praised them for their attention to the ecology and ecosystem.

"The issues of ecology and environment and especially the education of those become extremely important as a part of experiencing the space,'' he said. "I think that is paramount in the design of the new Pier."

Mehta had good things to say about each of the three designs. He complimented the Eye by West 8 —modeled on a sea urchin and the subject of public derision — for the grace of its shape and form.

"It's a very, very believable man-made object that appears like a marine species,'' he said.

Mehta also liked the idea of West 8's shoal, the man-made beach surrounding the Eye, and the openness and flexibility of its interior space. He was less impressed by West 8's concept for the Pier approach, which he described as "extremely monotonous" and a "missed opportunity."

BIG, which produced the Wave, is known for innovative ideas, he said. While the firm's Pier design is dynamic, it's "extremely introverted," he said, adding that it's the least engaged with the water around it.

Besides, he said, "it's a very, very cold country imagery. It seems to be in a Scandinavian country or the North.''

The Lens, with its looping bridge, by Michael Maltzan Architecture, is his favorite.

"They have thought of it not only as an iconic object but as an iconic space. And oftentimes, when design firms do that, they lose one or the other. … This proposal creates a multitude of spaces and experiences.''

He called the design fluid, three-dimensional and "refreshingly nonlinear."

"I've always thought of the St. Petersburg waterfront as a series of coves that could be eventually developed and conceptualized with distinct identities. Interestingly, the Lens and the space contained by the loop could be read as another cove out in the water," Mehta said.

"The development along the waterfront is a work in progress, and with the Pier project, the Lens is something that will further activate it. I think it's very interesting that it actively looks back at the city and engages it.''

A panel of five jurors will rank the three designs Jan. 20 and then make a recommendation to the City Council.

Waveney Ann Moore can be reached at [email protected] or (727) 892-2283.

Urban design expert likes St. Petersburg Pier proposals 01/02/12 [Last modified: Tuesday, January 3, 2012 4:21pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Massive crocodile seen roaming the streets, and there was only 1 thing a cop could do

    Wildlife

    Name one thing you really don't want to see around 4 a.m. walking around your neighborhood.

    Watch out for that croc.

    A crocodile was seen roaming a street in Miami-Dade.
  2. Pinellas County Sheriff's employee resigns under investigation related to domestic violence arrest

    Crime

    LARGO — A civilian Pinellas County Sheriff's Office employee resigned Tuesday while under an internal investigation that began after he was arrested on domestic battery charges.

    Joshua Volz resigned Tuesday from the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office. He had been under investigation after he was arrested for domestic battery, according to police. [Pinellas County Jail]
  3. Mom accused of burying guns after fatal teen shooting declines plea deal

    Criminal

    TAMPA — The Valrico mother accused of hiding the guns after her teenage son shot and killed another boy in their garage told a judge Tuesday that she wants a trial, not a plea deal.

    Heidi Quinn is accused of hiding two guns after her son, Cody, fatally shot 17-year-old Jayquon Johnson in their garage. She faces charges of tampering with evidence. Her son was not charged in Johnson's death because authorities ruled it self-defense. He does face related drug charges. [Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office]
  4. Stone says no coordination between Trump campaign and Russia

    WASHINGTON (AP) — Longtime Donald Trump associate Roger Stone said Tuesday he's "aware of no evidence whatsoever" that Trump's campaign coordinated with Russians during the 2016 election.

  5. Pasco deputies: Citgo gas station was selling pipes for crack and meth

    Crime

    TRILBY — A Citgo gas station is facing hefty fines after Pasco County Sheriff's deputies said clerks weren't just selling gas, but doling out pipes for crack and meth.