Monday, January 22, 2018
News Roundup

Medicare Advantage muddle

Gov. Rick Scott, like many other Republicans, has pinned part of his re-election strategy on criticizing the Affordable Care Act. He's attacked President Barack Obama's signature legislation time and again in campaign ads, especially the law's effects on Medicare. The ads claim that rate cuts will drastically alter seniors' access to the doctors and care they want.

But the ads aren't telling the whole story. The Scott ads are about changes to Medicare Advantage, in which private companies administer insurance plans for Medicare-eligible recipients. That's not the same as what's referred to as traditional Medicare, which is what most people think of when they hear the name of the program.

Confused? That's probably the point. But don't worry, PolitiFact is here to help. We'll iron out the differences between the two programs, and why distinctions should be made when referring to Medicare.

You get what you pay for

In a nutshell, the main difference between traditional Medicare and Medicare Advantage is who runs the program.

The Medicare program has been available to retirees since 1966, and was designed to help provide seniors with subsidized health insurance. It includes Part A, which is for hospital care, and Part B, which is medical insurance, usually physicians' services.

In the 1970s, the government started to let private insurers into the Medicare business. The insurance companies run the plans and then get reimbursed by the government. The plans must cover all the same things Medicare does, and often include perks traditional Medicare does not, like vision or dental coverage or gym memberships.

The umbrella over these private plans was renamed Medicare Advantage, or Medicare Part C, in 2003. A prescription drug program is now called Part D.

About 15 million people are enrolled in Medicare Advantage, about a third of all Medicare recipients nationwide.

The table above illustrates the main differences between the government-run and privately run programs.

Why would someone choose Medicare Advantage over traditional Medicare? Medicare Advantage plans can offer coverage with premiums lower than traditional Medicare, which can be a big help to seniors on a tight monthly budget. Typically, the plans offer more generous coinsurance.

On the other hand, people in Medicare Advantage are restricted as to which providers they can see. Just like private insurance, the doctors in their networks can change.

People who are in traditional Medicare, on the other hand, can see any doctor or specialist who accepts Medicare.

People can choose their Medicare plan each year during open enrollment, which is in the fall. That's when the different Medicare Advantage plans announce their offerings, and it's the time of year when seniors can change plans if they don't like what they currently have.

Making cuts

Now that we know what Medicare Advantage is, why would it be cut?

The idea behind Advantage plans is that private insurers could administer Medicare coverage for less than the federal government could, and at some points that has been true. Currently it is not. When the Affordable Care Act was being debated in 2009, Advantage plans were being reimbursed at a rate 14 percent higher than traditional Medicare, on average.

Obamacare aims to pare down those overpayments and bring reimbursements in line with traditional Medicare, to the tune of $156 billion over 10 years.

That's been anathema to the private insurers, who have claimed the changes will result in higher rates, reduced services and fewer in-network doctors — all of which would lead to reduced enrollment. Several lawmakers have joined in this debate, siding with the insurance lobby. Medicare advocates, on the other hand, say the insurance companies are using scare tactics to keep reimbursements high and maximize profits.

So far, Obamacare hasn't harmed Medicare Advantage. Coverage has stayed largely the same, premiums have been flat and enrollment has gone up since the legislation became law.

Still, Democrats were relieved when the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services announced last week that it would be giving Medicare Advantage a 0.4 percent increase for 2015 instead of a 2 percent cut. Democrats hope it will take that away from the GOP as an issue in fall campaigns.

That brings us back to Scott, who has not been making the distinction in his campaign advertising. In one Web ad, he said doctor access would decrease and services would be cut, but didn't mention cuts were for Medicare Advantage, and doesn't note the true effects won't be known for months. Meanwhile, these cuts don't target people in traditional Medicare. We rated it Mostly False.

In a Spanish-language editorial in El Nuevo Herald he cited potential Medicare Advantage premium increases of $50 to $90 as fact, when they were only year-old estimates by the insurance lobby. Even the group that commissioned the report from which the projection was culled says it wasn't the proper number for Scott to use. Again, any such premium change wouldn't apply to traditional Medicare. We also rated that one Mostly False.

Like Scott's references to Medicare, many of the advertisements about this subject have not been clear that the reductions in payments will be going to Medicare Advantage. And even if that distinction were made clear, so far the changes haven't affected the program in the drastic way opponents have predicted.

PolitiFact Florida reporter Amy Sherman contribued to this report.

Comments

The Daystarter: Women’s March returns to St. Petersburg; PolitiFact Florida analyzes prison costs; Free dental clinic services in high demand; Arrrrr you ready for Gasparilla?

Catching you up on overnight happenings, and what you need to know today.• We’ll have a mild and sunny start to the week, with highs in the upper 70s, according to 10Weather WTSP. A weak cold front brings a chance of rain on Tuesday and slightly coo...
Updated: 8 hours ago
PolitiFact Florida: Claims about prison price-gouging decry $17 soup, $18 tampons

PolitiFact Florida: Claims about prison price-gouging decry $17 soup, $18 tampons

Advocates of Florida prisoners protested outside of the Florida Department of Corrections in Tallahassee on Tuesday, demanding answers to questions of alleged price-gouging in prisons across the state.Protesters from dozens of grass roots organizatio...
Updated: 10 hours ago

Hooper: Deal with sea-level rise or prepare to be inundated

When fans again flock to Tampa’s Bayshore Boulevard for the annual Gasparilla Festival on Saturday, I hope they ask a question: Will the floats need flotation devices in 2035?Erika Spanger-Siegfried, Astrid Caldas and Kate Cell, members of the Union ...
Updated: 12 hours ago
Add swagger to Lightning’s loss column

Add swagger to Lightning’s loss column

CHICAGO — It didn’t take the sound of a door slamming in the visitor’s dressing room Saturday night to sense this Lightning team is frustrated.Tampa Bay believed it had worked hard against the Wild — at least, harder than it did in Thursday’s letharg...
Updated: 6 hours ago

nationResearchers work to avoid another 1918 super-flu The descriptions are haunting. Some victims felt fine in the morning and were dead by night. Faces turned blue as patients coughed up blood. Stacked bodies outnumbered coffins. A century after on...
Updated: 7 hours ago

Hillsborough diver who died in Eagle’s Nest Cave was adventurous but experienced

Davin Brannon was a pilot, a spearfisherman, an avid cave and open-water diver and an experienced all-around adventurer, said those close to him ."I guess you could say he died doing what he loved," his cousin Pam Kirven said. "But I also know he’d n...
Updated: 7 hours ago
‘Three Billboards’ sweeps female-focused SAG Awards

‘Three Billboards’ sweeps female-focused SAG Awards

LOS ANGELES — The Western-inspired revenge tale Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri swept the female-focused and led Screen Actors Guild Awards Sunday with wins for best ensemble, best actress for Frances McDormand and best supporting actor for...
Updated: 7 hours ago
Shutdown opens week

Shutdown opens week

Associated PressWASHINGTON — The government shutdown will extend into the workweek as the Senate appeared to inch closer to ending a partisan stalemate late Sunday but fell short of agreement. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell and his Democratic...
Updated: 8 hours ago
Record number of inmates died in Florida prisons last year. And they died younger than past years.

Record number of inmates died in Florida prisons last year. And they died younger than past years.

More inmates died in Florida prisons last year than in any other year on record, leaving the state scrambling to identify causes and find solutions. The tally, 428 inmate deaths in 2017, was released late Friday by the Florida Department of Correctio...
Updated: 8 hours ago

Oxfam highlights sharp inequality as Davos elite gather

DAVOS, Switzerland — A CEO from one of the world’s top five global fashion brands has to work for just four days to earn what a garment worker in Bangladesh will earn in an entire lifetime, campaigning group Oxfam International said Monday. In advanc...
Updated: 8 hours ago