Tuesday, June 19, 2018
Military News

For crews on Air Force KC-135 tankers, parachutes are not an option

TAMPA — The crew parachutes came out of the U.S. Air Force KC-135 flying members of Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev's entourage during his 1959 visit to the United States.

It would have been awful public relations, after all, if an emergency forced the U.S. crew to bail out while leaving Soviet passengers behind to die in a crash.

The crew didn't care, pilot Bill Lusk said, because they knew parachutes are about as useful in a KC-135 as they are on a submarine.

"It just becomes an absurdity to provide parachutes that have a 99.9 percent chance of never being useful," said Lusk, 80, of Las Vegas. "You don't bail out of a KC-135."

The question of parachutes in KC-135 aerial refueling aircraft — 16 of the jets fly out of MacDill Air Force Base — is in the news again due to a recent report and its findings from a May 2013 crash involving a Stratotanker en route to Afghanistan. Three KC-135 crew members died in the crash in Kyrgyzstan, in the foothills of the Himalayas.

The crash of the KC-135 was the first since the Air Force ordered parachutes out of all those aircraft in 2008 to save fuel and because the jets have an outstanding safety record, Air Mobility Command officials say.

Retired KC-135 pilots said the Air Force did so with good reason. Namely, the parachutes are almost useless unless a KC-135 is flying straight and level, and only then if the crew has enough time to open a floor hatch behind the cockpit and jump out.

KC-135s have no ejection seats.

"If you're not right-side up, it's impossible to bail out," said retired KC-135 pilot Bill Fisher, 82, of Norman, Okla., who flew the airplane from 1958 to 1972.

Fisher said he never had to evacuate. "Just to be honest, the airplane was so safe that you never really were ever faced with a time when you really needed parachutes," he said.

The accident report said almost nothing about parachutes beyond two lines:

Crew "egress was not possible. The KC-135 is not equipped with parachutes, ejection seats, or any other means of in-flight egress."

In an April 14 story, Time magazine weighed in on the issue in a story headlined, "Disaster in the Sky: Old Planes, Inexperienced Pilots — and No More Parachutes."

The Time story opened, "Putting young, inexperienced pilots into a 50-year-old Air Force plane seems like a risky idea. Even riskier? Getting rid of crew's parachutes to save money."

The accident investigation concluded the KC-135 crash was caused by a "Dutch Roll," which rocks the aircraft side to side, and pitches the nose up and down in a continuous cycle. If unchecked, such rolls can worsen until the forces on the aircraft exceed its design limits.

In the case of the KC-135 that crashed last year, the tail broke free of the aircraft.

The report blamed the crash on the relatively inexperienced pilots not recognizing they were in a Dutch Roll that was triggered by a malfunctioning flight control system.

Their in-flight manual may have confused the issue, the report said, because of poor organization, making it difficult for pilots to access instructions that warned against some of the very maneuvers they used to try to correct the aircraft's roll.

The report also noted that flight simulators cannot adequately replicate the Dutch Roll, and investigators said pilots receive little instruction on the roll during flight training.

Air Force Lt. Col. John Thomas, a spokesman for the Air Mobility Command, said the KC-135 that crashed fell into a near vertical dive after the tail separated. He said the g-forces probably rendered the crew unconscious.

The two pilots were working to regain full control of the KC-135 right up to the moment the tail fell off, so even if they had parachutes, they would have still gone down with their plane, Thomas said.

"There was no indication from the data voice recorder they knew their plane was about to break up," Thomas said.

The accident board, he said, concluded parachutes would have made no difference.

The Air Force initially said it knew of no instances of a successful KC-135 bail out. But Time quoted one former KC-135 pilot whose crew bailed out in 1969 after the plane ran out of fuel.

And Fisher, the retired KC-135 pilot from Oklahoma, said one of his pilot friends had a navigator and boom operator safely bailed out of a KC-135 after an engine caught fire. The two pilots stayed with the plane and landed it without incident.

In both instances, the aircraft were flying straight and level.

Not everybody is certain keeping parachutes out of the KC-135 is a good idea.

"Deploying air crews to a combat zone without parachutes is an unconscionable risk," Alan Diehl, a former civilian Air Force safety investigator, told Time.

The Air Force's top acquisition goal is to replace its aging fleet of KC-135s, saying it fears a safety issue will one day ground the entire fleet. Boeing is building a new tanker, the KC-46, but phasing it in will take decades.

"Nobody wants to die casually," said Lusk, the retired KC-135 pilot. "And if you've got a parachute, maybe there is a chance if something very, very bad happens, you can escape with your life. But it's kind of moot point."

Times researchers John Martin and Caryn Baird contributed to this report.

Comments
Nazi or not? Tattoo sparks Twitter storm over wounded New Port Richey veteran

Nazi or not? Tattoo sparks Twitter storm over wounded New Port Richey veteran

The federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency is pushing back against a social media post implying that a combat-wounded New Port Richey veteran has a Nazi symbol tattooed on his arm.In a tweet Monday afternoon, ICE officials denied the vete...
Updated: 9 hours ago
Fifty years after he disappeared over Laos, remains of Northeast High grad return home

Fifty years after he disappeared over Laos, remains of Northeast High grad return home

ST. PETERSBURG — In November 1969, at a hotel in Bangkok, Thailand, Air Force Capt. James White and his wife Sharon enjoyed their last night out together, dining on hotel room service with family friends Neil and Janet Armstrong.It was four months af...
Published: 06/18/18
Where’s the new VA clinic going? Not in the city of New Port Richey

Where’s the new VA clinic going? Not in the city of New Port Richey

NEW PORT RICHEY — The federal government’s search for a home for its new Veterans Administration community outpatient clinic is focusing on the Little Road corridor in west Pasco.Three locations in the running for the VA clinic are identified in the ...
Published: 06/18/18
Chicago soldier killed in Korea finally being laid to rest

Chicago soldier killed in Korea finally being laid to rest

CHICAGO — Not long after her father went missing during the Korean War, Carol Elkin spotted then-Gen. Dwight Eisenhower in downtown Chicago and did what any kid might do when coming face to face with the nation’s most famous soldier: She ...
Published: 06/17/18
Howard Altman: New Port Richey veteran out front in campaign for burn-pit benefits

Howard Altman: New Port Richey veteran out front in campaign for burn-pit benefits

Last week, the halls of Congress became the latest battleground in a campaign by tens of thousands of veterans seeking acknowledgment of the health problems they suffer from exposure to open-air refuse burn pits in Iraq, Afghanistan and elsewhere.Nav...
Published: 06/14/18
Airman with top-secret clearance, who disappeared in 1983, is discovered living in California

Airman with top-secret clearance, who disappeared in 1983, is discovered living in California

Before he mysteriously disappeared and landed on the Air Force Most Wanted list, Capt. William Howard Hughes Jr. phoned home to tell his mother and father that he was going to the Netherlands.It was July 17, 1983, and the Air Force was sending Hughes...
Published: 06/12/18

Marine Corps weighs wooing older members for new cyber force

SAN DIEGO — The head of the Marine Corps says it’s time the U.S. military branch known for its fierce, young warriors becomes a little more mature. The Marine Corps is considering offering bonuses and other perks to entice older, more experienced Mar...
Published: 06/08/18
Updated: 06/09/18
Military members stationed overseas fret as flying pets home gets harder

Military members stationed overseas fret as flying pets home gets harder

Missy Lee, a civilian who works for the U.S. Army, paid Delta Air Lines $5,000 to transport her two white shepherds as cargo on the same flight she took when moving to Japan in 2014.In the years since, the industry of shipping pets overseas has drast...
Published: 06/07/18
Howard Altman: Calls to veterans hotline jump after program expands statewide

Howard Altman: Calls to veterans hotline jump after program expands statewide

During the first three months of its expanded, statewide hotline for veterans, the Crisis Center of Tampa Bay estimates about 2,000 former service members called in seeking help because they were considering suicide.That’s a powerful testament to the...
Published: 06/06/18
Updated: 06/13/18
How to spot neo-Nazis in the military? Brandon Russell case shows how hard it is

How to spot neo-Nazis in the military? Brandon Russell case shows how hard it is

When Brandon Russell joined the Florida Army National Guard in January 2016, the service noted the radiation-warning symbol tattooed on his right shoulder.No one saw it as suspicious. Seventeen months later, it figured into the slaying of two young m...
Updated one month ago