Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Pentagon survey finds repeal of 'don't ask, don't tell' wouldn't hurt military

WASHINGTON — The U.S. military could allow gays and lesbians to begin openly serving in the military immediately with minimal risk to military readiness even as it fights two wars, an eight-month Pentagon study released Tuesday concludes.

But the change should be implemented cautiously because resistance remains higher in combat units — a finding likely to fuel opposition to repealing "don't ask, don't tell" in Congress, where opponents recently have said they're most concerned about the impact repeal would have on military effectiveness.

A massive study of military opinion found that while 70 percent of troops said they thought serving with an openly gay person would have a positive or neutral impact, the opinion was startlingly different in combat units, where 48 percent of Army troops and 58 percent of Marines said the change would negatively affect their ability to fight.

"In my view, the concerns of combat troops as expressed in the survey do not present an insurmountable barrier to a successful repeal of 'don't ask, don't tell,' '' Secretary of Defense Robert Gates said Tuesday. "However, these findings lead me to conclude that an abundance of care and preparation is required if we are to avoid a disruptive — and potentially dangerous — impact on the performance of those serving at the tip of the spear in America's wars."

The report itself, while acknowledging those percentages, said that other data in the survey indicated that combat units were more accepting of gays based on their actual experience.

"Anecdotally, we also heard a number of service members tell us about a leader, co-worker, or fellow service member they greatly liked, trusted, or admired, who they later learned was gay; and how once that person's sexual orientation was revealed to them, it made little or no difference to the relationship," the report found.

The Defense Department offered some specific recommendations if Congress does repeal "don't ask, don't tell:"

• Issues of sexual conduct and fraternization can be dealt with using existing rules and regulations.

• No separate bathing or living facilities should be provided for gays.

• Expand some spousal benefits. For example, gay troops should be able to direct that their partner receive benefits related to life insurance, saving plans and hospital visitation rights, the report found.

• Gay troops kicked out of service under "don't ask, don't tell" should be allowed to reapply under the same criteria as others seeking re-entry into the armed forces.

• No special protections for sexual orientation needed. The report does not recommend that sexual orientation be placed alongside race, color, religion, sex and national origin as a class eligible for various diversity programs and for resolving complaints.

• No special arrangement made for those with religious or moral objections to serving alongside gays. The report notes that people of differing moral values and religious convictions already serve together.

The report's conclusions were quickly hailed by senators who support the repeal of "don't ask, don't tell," the policy that Congress created during the Clinton administration that requires gays and lesbians to hide their sexual orientation.

"Today's report confirms that ending 'don't ask, don't tell' can be implemented in a manner consistent with maintaining the strong, cohesive military force we have today," Sen. Carl Levin, a Michigan Democrat and chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee, said in a statement.

Senate Democrats plan to force a vote this month on the repeal, which has already passed the House. Republicans, led by Sen. John McCain of Arizona, have mostly opposed overturning the law, claiming that Obama's call for an end to the ban is politically driven and could harm military readiness while the country is at war. The Senate Armed Services Committee will hold hearings Thursday and Friday when the Pentagon's top leaders are scheduled to testify.

More than 400,000 active-duty and reserve troops were asked for their opinions on allowing gays to serve openly in the military, of whom 115,052 responded. In addition, the views of 150,000 spouses were sought, of whom 44,266 responded. Another 72,384 service members or spouses offered their views through an online "suggestion box," and more than 24,000 service members took part in 92 town hall meetings held at 51 bases around the world.

The survey found that across the services, between 50 percent and 55 percent of respondents said that repealing the ban on openly gay service members would have no effect on the military. It also found that only 12 percent of spouses said they would encourage their spouses to leave the service if "don't ask, don't tell" is repealed.

But fully a fifth of respondents in the Army and a higher percentage among Marines said knowledge that a unit member was gay would hurt training and their ability to work together.

Information from the Associated Press was included in this report.


Pentagon survey results

The Defense Department received 115,052 responses to the survey designed to gauge the impact of a repeal of "don't ask, don't tell'' on military readiness, military effectiveness, unit cohesion, recruiting, retention and family readiness. Here are some of the results.

70–76% of service members said repeal would have a positive, a mixed, or no effect on aspects of task cohesion.

67–78% of service members said repeal would have a positive, mixed, or no effect on aspects of social cohesion (trust). Overall, 33% of service members predicted a negative impact on trust; this number was 47% for the Marine Corps.

56% of service members with combat experience since Sept. 11, 2001, said repeal would have a positive, mixed, or no effect on their unit's effectiveness "in a field environment or out at sea;" 44% said it would have a negative effect. Nearly 60% of respondents in the Marine Corps and in Army combat arms said they believed there would be a negative impact on their unit's effectiveness in this context.

69.3% said they had worked in a unit with a co-worker they believed to be homosexual

If "don't ask, don't tell" is repealed and you are assigned to share a room, berth, or field tent with someone you believe to be a gay or lesbian service member, which are you most likely to do?

26.7% said they would take no action

24.2% would discuss how we expect each other to behave and conduct ourselves when sharing a room, berth, or field tent

28.1% would talk to leader to see if I have other options

Pentagon survey finds repeal of 'don't ask, don't tell' wouldn't hurt military 11/30/10 [Last modified: Monday, November 7, 2011 1:25pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

Copyright: For copyright information, please check with the distributor of this item, Tribune News Service.

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. What you need to know for Thursday, Oct. 19


    Catching you up on overnight happenings, and what you need to know today

    White nationalist Richard Spencer is scheduled to speak at the University of Florida tonight and the school is on high alert for tensions. [Associated Press]
  2. Bowen: Park land deal raises Penny for Pasco questions


    The Penny for Pasco is unambiguous.

    At least it is supposed to be.

    There was no equivocating in 2004 when Penny for Pasco supporters detailed how the sales tax proceeds would be spent: schools, transportation, public safety and environmental lands. No money for parks. No money for recreation.

    Pasco County is considering a loan from its Environmental Lands Acquisition and Mangement Program to buy land for a park in the Villages of Pasadena Hills in east-central Pasco. Shown here is the Jumping Gully Preserve in Spring Hil, acquired by ELAMP in 2009 and 2011.
[Douglas R. Clifford, Times]
  3. Another Tampa Bay agency loses tax credits worth millions in dispute over application error


    LARGO — Another Tampa Bay housing agency has lost out on a multi-million dollar tax credit award because of problems with its application.

    A duplex in Rainbow Village, a public housing complex in Largo. The Pinellas County Housing Authority is planning to build new affordable-housing in the complex but was recently disqualified from a state tax credit award because of an issue with its application.
  4. Live blog: Many unknowns as Richard Spencer speaks in Gainesville today


    GAINESVILLE — A small army of law enforcement officers, many of them from cities and counties around the state, have converged on the University of Florida in preparation for today's speaking appearance by white nationalist Richard Spencer.

    Florida Highway Patrol cruisers jammed the parking lot Wednesday at the Hilton University of Florida Conference Center in Gainesville, part of a big show of force by law enforcement ahead of Thursday's appearance by white nationalist Richard Spencer. [KATHRYN VARN | Times]
  5. As Clearwater Marine Aquarium expands, it asks the city for help


    CLEARWATER — When Clearwater Marine Aquarium CEO David Yates saw an architect's initial design for the facility's massive expansion project, he told them to start all over.

    Clearwater Marine Aquarium Veterinarian Shelly Marquardt (left), Brian Eversole, Senior Sea Turtle and Aquatic Biologist (middle) and Devon Francke, Supervisor of Sea Turtle Rehab, are about to give a rescued juvenile green sea turtle, suffering from a lot of the Fibropapillomatosis tumors, fluids at the Clearwater Marine Aquarium Wednesday afternoon. Eventually when the turtle is healthy enough the tumors will be removed with a laser and after it is rehabilitated it will be released back into the wild.  -  The Clearwater Marine Aquarium is launching a $66 million renovation to expand its facilities to take in injured animals and space to host visitors. The aquarium is asking the city for a $5 million grant Thursday to help in the project. American attitudes toward captive animals are changing. Sea World is slipping after scrutiny on the ethics of captive marine life. But CEO David Yates says CMA is different, continuing its mission of rehab and release, it's goal is to promote education, not exploitation. JIM DAMASKE   |   Times