Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Newsmaker: Brig. Gen. Jeffrey Sinclair

The general who had a three-year affair

A sordid account involving illicit sex in uniform will be aired this week in an austere courtroom at Fort Bragg, N.C., and the results could tip the scales in a debate in Congress over the future of the military justice system.

The defendant, Brig. Gen. Jeffrey Sinclair, is accused of carrying on a three-year affair in Afghanistan with a junior officer and sexually assaulting her on two occasions, among other crimes. He is only the third Army general to face court-martial in more than a half-century.

But after two years of investigation and preparation, the prosecution is in disarray. The Army's lead counsel, Lt. Col. William Helixon, abruptly stepped down last month after confiding to superiors and the general's defense team that he had qualms about the case.

Meanwhile, the general's lover-turned-accuser — an Army captain 17 years his junior — faces questions about her credibility. Although she has testified that Sinclair twice forced her to perform oral sex against her will, she has been unable to recall the dates and has given conflicting accounts to investigators and colleagues.

At an evidentiary hearing in 2012, she said Sinclair threatened to kill her and her family if she told anyone about their relationship. Two other officers testified that they provided nude photos to Sinclair, part of other charges involving his conduct with five women.

Sinclair's defense team argues text messages show that a loving relationship between the general and the now 34-year-old Army captain fractured when she became jealous of his interactions with his wife and another female soldier.

Sinclair is scheduled to return to the dock Thursday. He has pleaded not guilty to all charges. The Army has set aside most of the month for the court-martial.

The Army's handling of the case is being watched closely in Washington, where the Senate is scheduled to soon consider a bill that would strip military commanders of their long-standing authority to prosecute sexual assaults and other major crimes. The bill, introduced by Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand, D-N.Y., would give uniformed prosecutors the power to decide whether to press charges. Leaders at the Pentagon have lobbied fiercely against the bill, arguing that commanders need to retain legal authority to enforce order and discipline in their units.

The prosecution of Sinclair has been seen as a test case of the Army's willingness to hold senior leaders accountable for sex crimes.

In the past, advocates for victims of sex crimes in the military have argued that commanders have been too quick to dismiss their accounts of rape and abuse and too reluctant to press charges against fellow officers. Sinclair's lawyers assert that the opposite is true in his case. They said the evidence against him is flimsy but that senior Army leaders are afraid they will be portrayed as covering up for one of their own if they drop the most serious charges.

"In a sense, I understand the fear that they have, and that it is driving their lack of doing the right thing, but that is not how the system is supposed to work," said Richard Scheff, a civilian attorney who is representing Sinclair. "It's supposed to be driven by evidence and by what is fair and just, not fear."

In court filings, Scheff has said that Helixon, the former lead prosecutor, bluntly told him in a Feb. 9 phone conversation that he had come to the conclusion that the sexual assault charges against the general should be dropped, but senior Army leaders had insisted the case go forward because of "politics and outside pressures."

For Sinclair's wife, Rebecca, there is an overlooked issue in the case — the toll of a decade of war on military couples, many of whom have found themselves in a repeated pattern of deployments, homecomings and moves.

"I'm not excusing my husband's infidelity,'' she told the Associated Press in 2012. "I'm just trying to understand it, and I'm trying to get conversations started so that people can look behind and see the bigger issue."

She will not attend the trial. "It's a painful thing for her," said Scheff, her husband's attorney.

Contributing: Chicago Tribune

The general who had a three-year affair 03/04/14 [Last modified: Tuesday, March 4, 2014 6:54pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

Copyright: For copyright information, please check with the distributor of this item, Washington Post.

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Photo of the Day for September 21, 2017 - A Gorgeous sunset on the gulf

    Human Interest

    Today's Photo of the Day comes from Evan Kaplan of New Port Richey, FL.

  2. State shuts down Hollywood nursing home where 9 died in scorching heat

    State Roundup

    HOLLYWOOD — The Hollywood Hills nursing home that became a sweltering deathtrap for nine seniors after Hurricane Irma was shut down Wednesday.

    Dawn Schonwetter stops to look at a memorial of flowers and messages left on the sidewalk of the Rehabilitation Center at Hollywood Hills on Saturday, Sept. 16, 2017. Nine residents of the nursing home died in the wake of Irma, including one who was added to the death toll on Tuesday. [AL DIAZ | Miami Herald]
  3. Tampa woman identified in fatal I-4 crash that sent car into canal in Plant City


    The Florida Highway Patrol has identified a Tampa woman killed in a crash on Wednesday morning in Plant City.

  4. Police identify woman they say beat and stole from a 69-year-old in St. Petersburg


    ST. PETERSBURG — Tips from the public have led police to identify the woman they say followed and beat up a 69-year-old woman at her home as 34-year-old Leslie Broadfoot.

    Police have identified Leslie Broadfoot, 34, as the woman they say beat up a 69-year-old after saying she would help her unload hurricane supplies from her car. (St. Petersburg police)
  5. Gradebook podcast: The 'Is Hurricane Irma finally over?' edition


    Schools across Florida began preparing for Hurricane Irma long before it ever arrived, its veering path creating anxiety for just about every Floridian at one point or another. Cafeteria workers, teachers, custodians, bus drivers, administrators and others jumped into action, often putting civic duty ahead of personal …

    The Hillsborough County school district created a video celebrating its employees as heroes of Hurricane Irma.