Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Federal jury: Bay Pines discriminated against four employees

TAMPA — The employees at the Bay Pines VA Medical Center said their bosses made their work lives miserable after they filed employment discrimination claims at the St. Petersburg hospital.

They often felt helpless as they watched their professional reputations attacked by supervisors who denied them choice assignments with higher pay and gave them poor job evaluations.

They are helpless no more.

A federal jury Thursday awarded the four women, including three doctors, $3.73 million in damages after deciding that the administration at Bay Pines, the nation's fourth-busiest veterans hospital, violated the law by retaliating against them.

The VA's liability for damages awarded for emotional pain and anguish is capped at $300,000 per plaintiff under federal law, so the verdict is expected to be reduced by a judge to $1.33 million.

The jury's decision came after a three-week trial that cast an unflattering spotlight on work conditions at the hospital, where the plaintiffs say a climate of fear exists among employees afraid to speak out.

The female plaintiffs said supervisors opened a concerted campaign to discredit them and push them out of their jobs after they filed employment discrimination claims on a variety of issues.

Those complaints included allegations that administrators discriminated against women by denying them good job assignments and that older doctors were being unfairly attacked by administrators.

The women said they were thankful the jury vindicated them.

"We were just standing up for what is right," said Dr. Claudia Cote, 48, the lead plaintiff. "Now, hopefully, all other physicians will be able to be more forceful" in expressing opinions about patient care "and operate without the fear of retaliation. This is good for our patients."

Attorney Joe Magri said he will suggest to members of Congress and the VA that an investigation be opened into illegal retaliation by Bay Pines administrators against those who file Equal Employment Opportunity claims for workplace discrimination.

"The evidence showed that the retaliation went to the highest levels of the Bay Pines administration," said Magri, who tried the case with co-counsel Ward Meythaler. "The appropriate regulatory agencies need to look into what's going on there and why it's going on."

Magri said he represents other Bay Pines employees who allege similar retaliation in cases at various stages in the legal system.

A VA spokeswoman said the agency has not yet decided whether to appeal the verdict.

Bay Pines officials declined to comment beyond a short written statement saying the hospital "makes every attempt to promote a workplace free of discrimination where employees can focus on our important mission of caring for America's veterans."

The verdict broke down like this:

Cote was awarded $2 million for emotional pain and anguish and $80,000 in economic losses. Dr. Sally Zachariah, 56, was awarded $1 million and $90,000, respectively; Dr. Diane Gowski, 48, was awarded $250,000 and $16,000; and Roxanne Lainhart-Bronner, 38, was awarded $300,000 for emotional pain.

Lainhart-Bronner was punished by her superiors after speaking out against the retaliation taking place against the others, Magri said.

Magri told jurors that the leaders of Bay Pines, including director Wallace Hopkins and Dr. George Van Buskirk, the medical chief of staff, cracked down on employees who filed EEO complaints despite a federal law that forbids retaliation.

As a result, EEO complaints were reduced by a "huge" number in the last several years, Magri said. Court records indicate Bay Pines achieved at least a 50 percent reduction, though actual figures are not available.

The women testified that employees knew that if they filed a complaint they were putting their jobs on the line. The plaintiffs' EEO claims never went to a hearing and were dropped before trial.

Magri said that retaliation was demonstrated by a 2007 memo written by a Bay Pines program support assistant — not one of the plaintiffs — who was warned against filing a discrimination complaint.

The assistant said her supervisor told her, according to the memo, "If I were you, I wouldn't file an EEO complaint. Trust me, you don't want to file. If you file an EEO complaint, you're only going to make it harder for yourself."

All four of the plaintiffs still work at Bay Pines, and all of them said they are committed to caring for veterans and intend to stay.

They said life at the hospital has been difficult during litigation. Often, they said, co-workers are reluctant to even talk to them for fear administrators will target them, too.

"We may still need protection," Gowski said. "I think we'll still have the fear. But we know the spotlight is on Bay Pines. So I think there's going to be less direct retaliation."

Cote said she doesn't fear going back to work next week after winning a large verdict against her employer.

"We're going back with our heads held high," she said.

William R. Levesque can be reached at or (813) 269-5306.

Federal jury: Bay Pines discriminated against four employees 07/02/09 [Last modified: Thursday, July 2, 2009 10:55pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. For starters: Rays at Orioles, facing another old friend in Jeremy Hellickson


    The Rays take on the Orioles again tonight and will face another old friend for the first time, as RHP Jeremy Hellickson will take the mound for the home team.

    Hellickson was drafted by the Rays in 2005 and pitched for them from 2010-14, then was traded to Arizona. He has since bounced to the Phillies and …

  2. Pinellas construction licensing board needs to be fixed. But how?

    Local Government

    LARGO –– Everyone agrees that the Pinellas County Construction Licensing Board needs to be reformed. But no one agrees on how to do it.

    Rodney Fischer, former executive director of the Pinellas County Construction Licensing Board Rodney, at a February meeting. His management of the agency was criticized by an inspector general's report. [SCOTT KEELER   |   Times]

  3. Charles Bradley, acclaimed Florida soul singer, dies at 68


    Acclaimed Florida R&B powerhouse Charles Bradley, whose raw, pained voice earned him the nickname the Screaming Eagle of Soul, has died of cancer at 68, his representatives announced Saturday.

    Charles Bradley performed at the 2016 Gasparilla Music Festival.
  4. Kriseman and Baker cash race continues as campaigns officially reset


    The mayoral campaign, mostly operating in stealth mode during the two weeks of Hurricane Irma's build-up, arrival and recovery, has entered its stretch run, a compressed schedule of ten days before ballots are mailed to tens of thousands of voters in the Sunshine City.

    Mayor Rick Kriseman and former mayor Rick Baker are emerging from Hurricane Irma mode and getting back into campaign form
  5. Bucs have chance to beat Vikings in their third stadium


    Here's a cool sign that the Bucs are getting up there as an NFL franchise: If Tampa Bay can win Sunday at U.S. Bank Stadium, it will mark the first time the Bucs have posted road wins against the same NFL opponent in three different stadiums.

    TIMES ARCHIVES (2012) | Bucs RB Doug Martin runs during Tampa Bay's 36-17 win at the Vikings in 2012, in what was then called Mall of America Field. If Tampa Bay wins Sunday, it will mark the first time they have road wins against the same NFL opponent in three different stadiums.