Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

U.S. House committee investigating Haley VA's use of covert camera

TAMPA — The U.S. House Veterans Affairs Committee has opened an investigation into the use of a video camera disguised as a smoke detector in a veteran's room at the James A. Haley VA Medical Center.

Rep. Jeff Miller, chairman of the committee, said the use of the camera in the room of severely brain-damaged veteran Joseph Carnegie, 80, outraged him. The covert camera was first reported in a July 10 story by the Tampa Bay Times.

News of the investigation comes as Haley officials, still defending the use of the camera, confirmed for the first time Tuesday the device was the only one of its type in use at the hospital. They said it will not be used again.

"There should never be a need for covert, Big Brother tactics" in a Department of Veterans Affairs hospital, Miller, R-Pensacola, said in an email response to questions.

Miller said the VA's lack of transparency was a concern to him.

"This is unacceptable. VA must be transparent to the media and Congress, but more important, to our veterans. That is what is most troublesome about this incident. It breaks the sacred trust between the VA and veterans and their families.

"Without that trust, veterans will begin to feel dismissed by their government, and that is the last thing I want to see happen … There is a huge accountability issue here. No one seems to want to take responsibility for clearly irresponsible acts."

A Haley spokeswoman said the VA had sent a response to the committee. The agency did not respond to a request to provide a copy to the Times.

But in a statement to the Times, Haley officials again defended their use of the camera, saying such equipment is routine among hospitals to ensure patient safety.

The camera in Carnegie's room, installed after his family threatened Haley with a medical malpractice suit, was removed last week. The family first demanded it be taken down six weeks ago.

The camera is marketed by its manufacturer, Vonnic, as a "Smoke Detector Covert Camera."

Haley spokeswoman Carolyn Clark said it will not be used again at the hospital, though the VA has avoided calling the camera's use a mistake.

"There are currently zero cameras of this type installed, in use or in stock for use at Tampa VA," Clark said.

Carnegie's family said they noticed the odd-looking smoke detector in June when it was installed overnight while the family was away from the room.

Upon closer examination, Mike Coleman, Carnegie's son-in-law, said he spotted a camera lens. The VA later confirmed to the Times they had installed the camera. The agency said it was to monitor Carnegie's fragile health.

The family said Haley officials failed to tell them they were installing the camera. Haley's deputy director, Roy Hawkins Jr., confirmed to the Times the camera had been installed without telling Carnegie's family. Hawkins later denied making such a statement.

Hawkins also denied in an interview that the hospital recorded the video feed from the camera.

But Haley officials later confirmed the hospital was recording the video feed.

Clark said Tuesday that Hawkins did not deliberately release inaccurate information. She said he did not know the camera was capable of recording.

Carnegie's daughter, Natalie, said the family viewed the device as an unacceptable invasion of privacy. She said her family welcomed any investigation.

Of the camera's discovery by Carnegie's family, Rep. Miller said, "I can only imagine how traumatic and disturbing that must have been to them, especially when their first concern is their loved one and his health."

William R. Levesque can be reached at or (813) 226-3432.

U.S. House committee investigating Haley VA's use of covert camera 07/31/12 [Last modified: Tuesday, July 31, 2012 11:24pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Federal study says humans harmed by dispersant used during Deepwater Horizon


    A first-of-its-kind scientific study has determined that the dispersant BP sprayed at the oil gushing from the Deepwater Horizon rig in 2010 harmed human health.

  2. Across Tampa Bay, local commercial banks and credit unions appear healthy


    In another sign of economic vitality, Florida's home-grown banking industry demonstrated strong bench strength in the latest quarterly analysis by Bauer Financial. The vast majority of commercial banks with headquarters in Florida received five "stars" from Bauer, which is the highest ranking of health on its 0-to-5 …

    Several years ago, First Home Bank in Seminole faced regulators breathing down its neck for inaedquate controls and financial weakness. Under CEO 
Anthony N. Leo, the bank has rebounded. It received a top-rated "5" star rating from Bauer Financial in the latest quarter. Most area banks are doing better these days. [SCOTT KEELER      |     TIMES]
  3. Two linemen lose their wedding rings in Tampa Bay. So far one has been found and returned.

    Human Interest

    Two linemen who spent days restoring power in the Tampa Bay area had the same unfortunate mishap: They lost their wedding rings.

    Facebook helped Michael White find the wedding ring he lost while helping restore power in Tampa Bay.
  4. Need is now for new mental health center at Bay Pines, veterans say


    ST. PETERSBURG — Veteran Ellsworth "Tony" Williams says the Bay Pines VA Healthcare System's new mental health center will help fill an immediate need.

    The new mental health center at the Bay Pines VA Healthcare System stands four stories tall and was built at a cost of $92 million. It will centralize services that before were scattered. [HOWARD ALTMAN   |   Staff]
  5. GOP health bill all but dead; McCain again deals the blow


    WASHINGTON — Sen. John McCain declared his opposition Friday to the GOP's last-ditch effort to repeal and replace "Obamacare," dealing a likely death blow to the legislation and, perhaps, to the Republican Party's years of vows to kill the program.

    Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., speaks to reporters on Capitol Hill in Washington in July.  McCain says he won't vote for the Republican bill repealing the Obama health care law. His statement likely deals a fatal blow to the last-gasp GOP measure in a Senate showdown expected next week. [Associated Press]