Tuesday, November 21, 2017
Military News

VA rule changes eliminated thousands of veterans from waiting lists

RECOMMENDED READING


The computer scheduling program created in 2002 was supposed to allow the Department of Veterans Affairs to identify veterans who had waited the longest for medical care.

Officials called it the Electronic Wait List, or EWL. VA employees were told to put new patients with severe medical disabilities linked to their military service on the list after they had waited more than 30 days for an appointment. That way, these veterans could be identified for faster medical care.

Eventually, most new VA patients, service-connected disability or not, went on the waiting list after 30 days.

But about 2010, the VA allowed its hospitals to lengthen to 120 days the time veterans must wait without an appointment before they are put on the waiting list, potentially cutting thousands of veterans across the nation from the list, according to a Tampa Bay Times review of VA records and interviews.

The time frame is now 90 days.

Some critics say the changes were a deliberate ploy by VA leaders to make this much-watched measure of hospital performance look better than it actually was.

"This looks to me like just one more of the VA's gaming strategies that have been identified in the last year," said Anthony Hardie, a Bradenton resident who is on the board of directors of Veterans for Common Sense, a nonprofit advocacy group. "It looks like VA leaders simply gave up on trying to fix the problem."

The EWL has been the focus of attention in recent months, as the agency's inspector general reported 57,000 veterans were on the list nationally, while another 64,000 VA-enrolled veterans without appointments were never placed on the EWL at all.

Officials at the VA hospital in Phoenix, where a whistle-blower said 40 patients died while awaiting care, have been accused of keeping a secret waiting list to disguise the facility's poor performance in eliminating a patient backlog. And around the nation, the IG reports, VA employees used unauthorized scheduling tricks to hide delays in patient care.

What sets the changes to the Electronic Waiting List apart is that they were sanctioned by the VA and were not part of a scheme by rogue employees or hospitals.

VA officials say the agency lengthened the time frame for inclusion on the EWL to provide clarity and uniformity to the lists used by VA facilities across the nation.

They insist it was not a gaming strategy. But at the same time, they acknowledge the VA is trying to "rethink" past practices.

"If there is one message I'd want your readers to get,'' said Dr. Carolyn Clancy, a VA assistant undersecretary of health for quality, safety and value, "is that it is a new day" at the VA.

• • •

Dropping veterans who had not waited the full 120 days from the waiting list had an immediate and expected impact: The VA's EWLs looked much improved.

At the James A. Haley VA Medical Center in Tampa, the waiting list dropped from 4,981 veterans to 1,800 after it started cutting patients from the list, Haley officials said in 2012. Last month, Haley's 120-day EWL stood at 173, an audit by the VA's inspector general shows.

At the C.W. Bill Young VA Medical Center in Seminole, the EWL dropped from 1,408 in December 2010 to 269 in April 2012. Last month, the EWL stood at 103.

VA leaders have always placed a premium on measuring performance and patient care. The EWL was created because the agency did not have a standard measure of how long new patients — those who had not been seen by the VA in the last two years — waited for an appointment.

In a 2002 memo, Laura Miller, then a VA deputy undersecretary, said agency hospitals had created "ad hoc" waiting lists and that "waiting times for new enrollees seeking care are anecdotally reported to be long."

"We will attempt to formalize an 'electronic waiting list' … to more consistently and accurately reflect demand across (the VA) and reduce the risk to enrollees lost to follow-up due to clerical error," the memo said.

The EWL was considered a critical tool. It's a much-watched measure of hospital performance. It helps facility leaders allocate resources. It ensures veterans are not lost in the VA's intimidating bureaucracy.

It was one of several factors that impact executive bonuses.

One sign of the EWL's importance is a 2012 memo by regional VA officials to Florida veterans hospitals that told employees to check their waiting lists for veterans placed on them in error. "It is important that we have an accurate measure … as it affects the perception of access," the memo said.

Critics have argued EWLs and tools like them are too easily manipulated.

"This is a typical practice of VA hospitals that are not making their numbers," Gordon Erspamer, a San Francisco attorney who has represented several veteran advocacy groups, told the Times in 2012. If the VA is late providing care, he said, "The VA redefines the meaning of late."

Today, while still using the EWL to target patients who have waited the longest for care, the VA no longer makes it a measure of performance. It is hoped this will reduce pressure to manipulate numbers.

In some ways, the EWL is almost irrelevant, said Dr. Mike Davies, executive director of the VA's access and clinic administration program.

He said the agency can see how long a patient has been waiting for care even if they aren't on the list. "So there's transparency for the waiting times for every single appointment," he said.

VA leaders have long known some hospitals used "workarounds" to make their books look better.

"Workarounds," a 2010 memo by VA leadership noted, "may mask the symptoms of poor access and, although they may aid in meeting performance measures, they do not serve our veterans."

William R. Levesque can be reached at [email protected] or (813) 226-3432.

Comments
Sex assault reports declining at MacDill despite increase militarywide

Sex assault reports declining at MacDill despite increase militarywide

TAMPA — The number of sexual assaults reported to officials at MacDill Air Force Base has decreased dramatically during the past three years even as reports across the military have increased slightly, new Pentagon statistics show.Officials at MacDil...
Published: 11/20/17
Cyber firm accesses CentCom cloud information, gives command low security score

Cyber firm accesses CentCom cloud information, gives command low security score

Every day, military and civilian personnel stationed at the MacDill Air Force Base headquarters of U.S. Central Command use the Internet to reach out to foreign audiences in an effort to combat Islamic State propaganda.To help measure the success of ...
Published: 11/17/17
VA’s quiet plan to widen private care with TRICARE stirs concern

VA’s quiet plan to widen private care with TRICARE stirs concern

WASHINGTON — As part of its effort to expand private health care, the Department of Veterans Affairs has been developing plans to merge its health system with the Pentagon’s, a cost-saving measure that veterans groups say could threaten the viability...
Published: 11/17/17
Howard Altman: Missing records confound veterans on base exchange website

Howard Altman: Missing records confound veterans on base exchange website

In the more than three decades that I have been toiling at various paragraph factories, few stories have elicited as much response as the one I wrote about the new program to allow all honorably discharged veterans to shop at military base exchanges ...
Published: 11/17/17
She was an artist who answered a Craigslist ad. Next thing she knew she was best friends with a 93-year-old Pearl Harbor survivor

She was an artist who answered a Craigslist ad. Next thing she knew she was best friends with a 93-year-old Pearl Harbor survivor

University of Miami architecture student Emi Kopke still cannot believe her luck. She answered a Craiglist ad asking for an artist to do hand drawings for a special project. The self-taught artist sent in 15 of her hand drawings — including some of b...
Published: 11/11/17
As fewer serve, burden of war falls heavier on families with tradition of service

As fewer serve, burden of war falls heavier on families with tradition of service

When Lauren Price’s youngest son went off to fight in Iraq in 2008, she handed him a going-away present few parents could offer."I gave him my Iraqi cell phone," said Price, 52, a Navy veteran from New Port Richey who served in the same region of Ira...
Published: 11/10/17
Howard Altman: Army settles flap over who will wear the Green Beret

Howard Altman: Army settles flap over who will wear the Green Beret

I have a hard time picturing Army Chief of Staff Gen. Mark Milley, a no-nonsense guy with plenty on his plate, taking time out of his busy day sorting through color swatches.But thanks to one of two recent victories in the battle for Army tradition, ...
Published: 11/09/17
Updated: 11/10/17

Target of racist graffiti wrote it, Air Force Academy says

The discovery of racist graffiti galvanized the Air Force Academy in September, and the superintendent of the Colorado campus turned that into a teaching moment with a speech about diversity and tolerance that found more than a million viewers on the...
Published: 11/08/17
Online expansion opens military exchange to another 240,000 shoppers in Tampa Bay area

Online expansion opens military exchange to another 240,000 shoppers in Tampa Bay area

TAMPA — Military exchanges like the one at MacDill Air Force Base have long offered big savings to active-duty troops, military retirees and their families.Starting Saturday, Veterans Day, deals like 25 percent off on watches, 30 percent off smokers ...
Published: 11/06/17
Updated: 11/10/17
Bowe Bergdahl, the former hostage who pleaded guilty to desertion, avoids prison

Bowe Bergdahl, the former hostage who pleaded guilty to desertion, avoids prison

FORT BRAGG, N.C. — Bowe Bergdahl, the Army sergeant who walked off his post in Afghanistan and triggered a search that wounded some of his comrades, will serve no prison time, a military judge ruled Friday at the end of the politically divisive case...
Updated one month ago