Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Victim in DUI-manslaughter case deserved better, and so did the Marine charged with killing him

A DUI-manslaughter trial is about the saddest thing you can sit through.

Usually the victim was someone just driving along trying to get where he was going. The accused often has no record, just that colossally stupid moment when he slid behind the wheel and turned the key. Lives get ruined for nothing, and no number of prison years will make it right.

The DUI-manslaughter case against Scott Sciple, a Marine who saw intense combat but never got the mental help he needed in a warrior culture that discourages weakness, takes that kind of loss and sadness up a notch.

To be clear, it's hard to imagine a more innocent victim than Pedro Rivera, a father, husband and mother's favorite son killed last year. A mechanic, he was headed home after a late-night mercy mission to help a friend on the highway when Sciple came driving the wrong way on I-275. Police said he'd had three times the legal limit.

So it would be easy to dismiss Sciple as a man deserving any punishment a judge could come up with. But his case turns out to be about responsibility, too, to people who serve in our military, live through what we could not imagine and are marked by it.

As the Times' John Barry recently reported, Sciple was a war hero who served in Iraq and Afghanistan, survived four combat tours and was awarded three Purple Hearts and a Bronze Star for valor. He saw dead children and mass casualties and saved wounded fellow Marines. He kept going back. He was riddled with shrapnel and a rocket blast blew open his arm. And not all his wounds were visible.

He started acting strange, worrying friends, family and colleagues. But he told his father showing weakness could kill a Marine's career.

A Marine Corps report later found he was suffering post traumatic stress disorder and traumatic brain injury and had "dissociative episodes" in which he didn't remember what happened. But he had never gotten a neurological workup. He was seen as fit for duty and sent to MacDill Air Force Base. Less than 48 hours later, an innocent man was killed.

At his trial, the prosecution will likely talk about Sciple's personal responsibility that night, much of which he says he doesn't remember. His attorney, John Fitzgibbons, plans to ask for a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity. Under the law, he will argue Sciple had a mental infirmity that kept him from knowing what he was doing, or from knowing it was wrong. A not-guilty verdict would put him in treatment instead of prison.

And I would not want to be on that jury, looking into the faces of Rivera's family, and then at the combat veteran at the defense table, a man even the Marines say should have been treated, not sent here.

The Corps' straightforward and unflinchingly inward-looking 860-page report concludes Sciple was "incapable of making fully informed cognitive decisions" and suffered documented memory loss and blackouts. It talks of a flawed system that relies on traumatized combat vets to report on themselves even in a "Marine Corps warrior culture" that stigmatizes it. It talks change.

If any good can come from this, change is it. Change means powerful people in Washington pushing for better rules to evaluate and support the ones we send into battle, to keep this kind of tragedy from happening again.

Victim in DUI-manslaughter case deserved better, and so did the Marine charged with killing him 08/30/11 [Last modified: Tuesday, August 30, 2011 9:30pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Editorial: A proud moment for civic involvement in Hillsborough County


    It took private citizens less than 24 hours to do what their elected leaders in Hillsborough County could not for the past three months: Find the moral fortitude and the money to move a century-old Confederate war memorial from outside the county courthouse. Thursday's achievement was a lesson in leadership to county …

    The Hillsborough County Commission dithered for three months over moving the Memoria in Aeterna monument from the old county courthouse.
  2. Fort Myers woman arrested for doing cocaine off iPhone in parent pick-up line

    Bizarre News

    A Fort Myers woman was arrested Tuesday after police saw her snorting cocaine off her iPhone while in the parent pick-up line at a Lee County middle school.

    Christina Hester, 39, faces two different drug-related charges, according to police records. [Lee County Sheriff's Office]
  3. Tropical Storm Harvey forms in Atlantic


    UPDATE: At 5 p.m. the National Hurricane Center said a hurricane hunter plane had determined that Tropical Storm Harvey had formed with sustained winds of 40 mph.

    Three tropical waves are expected to strengthen as they move across the Atlantic Ocean. [Courtesy of the National Hurricane Center]
  4. Editorial: Pinellas should join lawsuit challenging new state law


    The Florida Legislature has been on a cynical, constitutionally dubious quest to render local school boards powerless. The most direct assault is a new state law that strips school boards of much of their authority when it comes to the creation and funding of charter schools. It's time for the Pinellas County School …

  5. Editorial: Fix funding unfairness in Florida foster care system


    Many of the children in Florida's foster care system already have been failed by their parents. The last thing these kids need is to be failed by bureaucracy, too, and yet that's exactly what appears to be happening because of a needlessly rigid funding formula set up by the Florida Legislature. Child welfare agencies …

    The Legislature may have had good intentions when it came up with the funding plan, but it’s obvious that there is some unfairness built into it. The funding may be complicated, but the goal is simple: Making sure every child in need gets the help he or she needs.