Monday, May 21, 2018
Military News

Q&A: Pasco psychologist behind waterboarding calls for soul-searching on security

When CIA officials learned about a possible jihadi attack against the United States, they turned to a retired Air Force lieutenant colonel now living in Pasco County to help create new ways of interrogating top al-Qaida captives.

James Mitchell, 65, is a psychologist who had helped train military personnel to deal with intense interrogations by the enemy. Then he tried to persuade the Navy to stop using a portion of his program — the process of pouring water over the breathing passages, known as waterboarding — because it shook the confidence of trainees, actually eroding their ability to keep secrets.

But after describing the techniques to leaders at the CIA, Mitchell said he was asked to turn them on top jihadi captives, instead. One of them was Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, mastermind of the 9/11 terrorist attacks.

Approved by the George W. Bush administration, the techniques were banned under President Barack Obama and would later give rise to a five-year, $40 million congressional investigation that equated them to torture. Mitchell, who grew up in the Tampa area, was vilified and, with business partner Bruce Jessen, named in a lawsuit over the death of a detainee.

In November, Mitchell published his own account of these events, titled Enhanced Interrogation: Inside the Minds and Motives of Islamic Terrorists Trying to Destroy America.

This month, in a wide-ranging two-hour interview, Mitchell talked to the Tampa Bay Times about the interrogation program, his response to critics, and advice for President-elect Donald Trump — his choice for president. Here are excerpts.

What was your initial response when the CIA asked you to use waterboarding on captured al-Qaida leader Abu Zubayda in the summer of 2002?

I didn't want to do it.

Why not?

It was a tremendous responsibility. Imagine a situation where you are the person trying to stop the next attack. It is one thing to participate, but quite another to be the person actually in the arena.

Why did you ultimately decide to?

After doing analysis, there was nothing in my moral compass that requires that I put the temporary discomfort of a terrorist who could stop it anytime he wanted to by answering the questions ahead of the rights of Americans to go about their business without being blown up and killed.

What was it like to waterboard Zubayda?

It sucks. It was one of those things that was emotionally challenging to do. I didn't enjoy it. He didn't enjoy it, obviously. … So what was it like to do it? It was morally difficult. Every day, Bruce and I would say to ourselves, "Have we gotten to the point where we don't need to be doing this to get information from them?" Because we are still interested in stopping the attacks … still in the works. Every time we said we don't need to be doing these harsh interrogations anymore, (the CIA) would (say) … that there is going to be another attack and the blood of dead Americans will be on your hands.

You were allowed to pour water for as long as 40 seconds. But how long did each waterboarding instance usually last?

We discovered right away that we needed between three and 10 seconds on average. We wanted him to be able to breath. We were concerned it might harm him if we did it the way they wanted us to. They sent a lawyer to look at the tapes and on average, the amount of time of each pour was about eight seconds. A bunch were shorter and some were longer. We would do one 40-second pour toward the end and two 20-second pours.

You spent hours with Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, also known as KSM. What was he like?

Evil isn't always ugly. Sometimes evil is charming and KSM is the smartest person I have ever encountered in my life and in my career, I have encountered some very smart people. He is like a savant for doing attacks. And he is Sufi, so he has that mischievous Sufi air about his religion. If you treated him like a college professor, he was willing to talk to you. … Some things he was willing to take to his grave, like the location of bin Laden. He didn't know his exact location, but he knew how to find him. He would have taken that to his grave. Fortunately, he didn't have to. In lying to us, he signaled how we could find him.

Trump was quoted as saying his choice for defense secretary — retired Marine Gen. James Mattis — is opposed to torture. What's your message to Mattis?

I know he is a great guy. I know he is an incredible warrior. I know he's much smarter than I am with a lot more experience, but I would ask him, "What would you do sir, in a situation where you were captured by al-Qaida or ISIS? Would you give up information that would get Americans killed for a Miller Lite and a pack of Winstons because of something that was in the Army Field Manual (which prohibits harsh techniques)?" No.

What's your advice to Trump about enhanced interrogation techniques?

I think use somewhere between waterboarding and worse, and what is in the Army Field Manual. There needs to be some legal form of coercion — legal, legal — that can be used against that handful of people that really have the information to stop the next catastrophic attack.

What drives those seeking to destroy America?

Islamists are people who believe Sharia law needs to be imposed on the entire world. There are several different kinds of Islamists. There are those Islamists who think they can impose it by outbreeding you, by kind of cloaking themselves in our civil liberties and voting and slowly ratcheting up Sharia law inside the United States. Then there are others that believe the way to do it is through violence. My beef is with the people who want to do it through violence.

KSM beheaded Wall Street Journal reporter Danny Pearl in 2002. What did he say about that?

He described cutting Daniel Pearl's head off and dismembering him and then burying him in a hole that's not much bigger than a post hole. … The thing that made it creepy is that it was one of the ways these Islamists show they love their God and how powerful their God is by killing people who are helpless to stop it. . . . Well, that's the way that KSM was talking about killing Daniel Pearl. … And he would call him Daniel like they were intimate. Not like they were lovers, but like they shared an intimate moment.

What do you say to your critics?

There really are monsters out there. Not a lot of them, but there are a few of them, and you can't handle protecting yourself from those folks the same way you would handle protecting yourself from a common criminal. I think the American people have to have a debate, really, about how they want to protect themselves. The reason there has not been another 9/11 is because Bush didn't treat it like a law enforcement matter. If he had, there would be big smoking holes in Los Angeles and Chicago and Seattle, probably. … Barack Obama says ISIS and al-Qaida do not represent an existential threat to the United States. What that means is you can't kill enough Americans to bring down the government. But that's not the purpose of government. We're not supposed to stack Americans up like cord wood in front of the White House. The government is supposed to protect Americans.

Contact Howard Altman at [email protected] or (813) 225-3112. Follow @haltman.

     
   
Comments
Trump announces he will nominate acting VA Secretary Robert Wilkie to become department’s permanent leader

Trump announces he will nominate acting VA Secretary Robert Wilkie to become department’s permanent leader

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump announced Friday that he plans to nominate Department of Veterans Affairs Acting Secretary Robert Wilkie to become the department’s permanent leader, noting that the decision may come as a surprise to Wilkie."I’ll ...
Published: 05/18/18
McDonald’s giving away free food to military members today

McDonald’s giving away free food to military members today

TAMPA— All current and former military service members in central Florida can stop by their local McDonald’s and grab a free burger today.In celebration of Military Appreciation Month, McDonald’s is giving away a "Taste of Thanks." All veterans and c...
Published: 05/17/18
Howard Altman: MacDill chosen to sell new Army-like Air Force uniforms

Howard Altman: MacDill chosen to sell new Army-like Air Force uniforms

Home to headquarters including U.S. Central Command and U.S. Special Operations Command, MacDill Air Force Base is at the forefront of a lot of important military action.Now it is taking on a new role — as a prime Air Force clothier.The flying branch...
Published: 05/16/18
Updated: 05/17/18
MacDill reviewing transportation plans after crowds jam roads for AirFest 2018

MacDill reviewing transportation plans after crowds jam roads for AirFest 2018

TAMPA — Tampa Bay AirFest 2018 pulled in a whopping 150,000 people and more over three days last week, including practice on Friday.But that proved to be more people than the transportation plan could handle, delaying arrival by hours for some and pr...
Published: 05/17/18
Vital military training falls short, New Port Richey veteran says: How to re-enter civilian life

Vital military training falls short, New Port Richey veteran says: How to re-enter civilian life

When Green Beret Brian Anderson got ready to leave the Army in 2011, after eight years fighting in places like Afghanistan and Iraq, he followed the path taken by tens of thousands of service members each year.Anderson, now 36 and living in New Port ...
Published: 05/14/18
Clouds can’t dampen crowd’s enthusiasm at packed MacDill Airfest

Clouds can’t dampen crowd’s enthusiasm at packed MacDill Airfest

TAMPA — With his 4-year-old son Tyler on his shoulders, Ryan Wick watched the Navy’s Blue Angels aerial demonstration team scream over the MacDill Air Force Base flight line at about 400 miles an hour.An hour or so earlier, the two struck a similar p...
Published: 05/12/18
US jets intercept pair of Russian bombers off Alaskan coast

US jets intercept pair of Russian bombers off Alaskan coast

Two Russian long-range bombers were intercepted off the coast of Alaska by a pair of F-22 Raptor fighter jets on Friday, the military said.The Tu-95 bombers were flying in the Air Defense Identification Zone in the Bering Sea north of the Aleutian Is...
Published: 05/12/18
Agencies are told to step up use of special powers to hire military spouses

Agencies are told to step up use of special powers to hire military spouses

WASHINGTON - President Donald Trump has issued an order aimed at boosting hiring by federal agencies of spouses of military personnel, who often face career difficulties as a result of being relocated frequently.Military service "often impairs the sp...
Published: 05/12/18
WWII planes, their wings overlapping, take to the air at MacDill festival this weekend

WWII planes, their wings overlapping, take to the air at MacDill festival this weekend

TAMPA — As a formation of World War II trainers cruised 1,000 feet over Tampa Bay, a 60-year-pilot flew one of the single-engine propeller planes so close to another that their wings overlapped by three feet.The tight maneuver is old hat to Steve Sal...
Published: 05/10/18
Updated: 05/11/18
Watch: Times photographer takes a wild ride in MacDill Airfest plane

Watch: Times photographer takes a wild ride in MacDill Airfest plane

RIVERVIEW — Tampa Bay Times photographer Luis Santana helped take the controls of an Extra 300L aircraft that will be part of this weekend’s Tampa Bay AirFest 2018 at MacDill Air Force Base in Tampa. With Santana on board, pilot John Kla...
Published: 05/10/18