Tuesday, December 12, 2017
Military News

What does a 'win' in Afghanistan look like? Tampa stakeholders have differing views

Few communities in the United States have as much at stake as Tampa in what happens next with Afghanistan.

Two major commands at MacDill Air Force Base are deeply involved in the long-running war there. Air Force refueling wings help fighters and bombers hit enemy positions. Two busy veterans hospitals care for the injured. And the area is home to many Gold Star families whose loved ones were casualties of the fighting.

Like the nation as a whole, people touched by the war here had mixed reactions to the plan announced Monday by President Donald Trump for the future of America's involvement in Afghanistan. Not enough force, in the view of some questioned by the Times. Maybe it's time to withdraw, a mother who lost her son reluctantly suggested.

Trump called for increasing pressure on Pakistan, boosting India-Afghan trade, pushing decisionmaking down to battlefield commanders, an end to so-called nation building, and increased reliance on the Afghans in winning the fight.

In his speech, Trump also emphasized finally "winning" the war — a concept that looks different to each of those interviewed. Here are highlights.

• • •

Scott Neil, 49, of St. Petersburg is a retired Green Beret master sergeant and was among the first American troops in Afghanistan, in 2001.

"More of the same from those that didn't win anything in the first place," he said of the speech.

Though Trump avoided specifics, it was widely reported that Congress has been told about 4,000 additional troops will be headed to Afghanistan on top of the 8,400 there now.

"That only equals about 400 trigger pullers," Neil said. "That's not enough of those that need to do what it takes. … We are stretched and we will be forced to stretch more."

Putting more pressure on Pakistan, long a haven for jihadi training, support and supply, makes a lot of sense, Neil said. But not just military pressure.

"In Iraq, it took an interagency effort with all partner nations to defeat money laundering, finance — all the things we have not been effective with," he said.

Indo-Afghan trade makes sense, as well, Neil said.

"India has 900,000 customers for Afghan products — but not through access to their market through Pakistan," he said. "Solve that and solve cash flow."

To Neil, "winning is what the original mission success was in the early days — unseating al-Qaida from sanctuaries and Taliban-controlled areas and removing those Taliban members that had those deep al-Qaida relationships from power."

• • •

Scott Mann, 49, is a retired Green Beret lieutenant colonel from Riverview who helped create the Village Stability Operations program, helping Afghans handle their own security.

"I was glad to see the president call out Pakistan and is looking to hold them accountable," Mann said.

"I am less enthused in the language I am hearing that he is going to press the attack, and decimate (jihadi groups). If we are only going to focus on surgical strikes, it is a repurposed Obama drone strategy.

"If there is anything we learned after 16 years, it is that 80 percent of the physical and human terrain in that country is outside the reach of the central government. … What we should be looking at is more of bottom-up local strategy, like the Green Berets have done in places like the Philippines and Colombia."

Mann said he is glad Trump avoided timetables. Winning, Mann said, means "denial of safe haven for (jihadis) and for civil society to handle its own affairs."

• • •

Mike Nicholson, 28, is a medically retired Marine sergeant who lost three limbs in Afghanistan in July 2011.

"I think it's an incredibly difficult situation and it's going to take more than a small troop surge to accomplish a desirable outcome," Nicholson said.

"I wholeheartedly support giving military leaders freedom to operate and to make decisions based on conditions on the ground. If we can eliminate the terror groups … and give the Afghan people economic options to make their country productive, I think that would have a huge impact on the region."

Nicholson defines winning as "not having 40 percent of the country being controlled by terrorists. The Afghan government has to rein in the corruption or we're going to continue fighting an uphill battle. We can wipe out the Taliban and (ISIS in Afghanistan) but that means nothing if there's not a stable government to lead the country in the aftermath."

• • •

Thea Kurz, 56, of Ruskin is the mother of Army Sgt. 1st Class Matthew I. Leggett, who was 39 when he was killed in Kabul in August 2014. Leggett was the most-recent Tampa-area resident killed in Afghanistan.

"I have always supported the military because of my son," Kurz said. "I understand there will always be battles, because that's the way us humans are. My only concern is that America gets involved in things we should not be in or that it is not going to work.

"I understand that the president and government don't want to admit that the situation over there is a nightmare for the troops. It is good that local commanders will have more direct authority. But the damage that is being done to our troops and morale of our troops, to parents and families — at a point maybe it is time to start pulling out, rather than continue to fight, just to prove to the world that we are the best."

Kurz said she does not believe winning in Afghanistan is possible.

"We did not win in Vietnam and I don't think we can change the culture and beliefs of the Afghan people."

Contact Howard Altman at [email protected] or (813) 225-3112. Follow @haltman.

     
Comments
Saturday’s sonic booms likely from F-15 fighters, NORAD says

Saturday’s sonic booms likely from F-15 fighters, NORAD says

Those sonic booms heard across the state Saturday afternoon were likely from two F-15 fighter jets protecting President Donald Trump during his visit to Florida, according to the North American Aerospace Defense Command.The jets, which belong to the ...
Published: 12/11/17
Transgender people can enlist in military Jan. 1

Transgender people can enlist in military Jan. 1

WASHINGTON — The Pentagon is allowing transgender people to enlist in the military beginning Jan. 1, despite President Donald Trump’s opposition. The new policy reflects growing legal pressure on the issue, and the difficult hurdles the federal gover...
Published: 12/11/17
Gold Shield Foundation honors Bondi

Gold Shield Foundation honors Bondi

TAMPA — Florida Attorney General Pam Bondi was honored by the Gold Shield Foundation, which assists families of first responders killed in the line of duty.At a luncheon Thursday, Bondi received the Philip A. McNiff "Lifetime of Service" award, named...
Published: 12/08/17
Local vets remember Pearl Harbor

Local vets remember Pearl Harbor

TAMPA — On the morning of Dec. 7, 1941, Ed Socha and Bill Monfort were several hundred miles away from each other, sharing a horrible moment of reckoning.Socha, 96, was at Pearl Harbor, aboard the USS Oklahoma. Bill Monfort was a radio operator aboar...
Published: 12/07/17

Talking subs, ships and the controversial F-35 with the Navy’s newest assistant secretary

TAMPA — James "Hondo" Geurts, a familiar face at MacDill Air Force Base, was sworn in as the Navy’s newest assistant secretary last week ."I’ll be responsible for acquisition for the Navy and Marine Corps," said Geurts, sitting in a chair on the brid...
Published: 12/07/17
A storage unit opened, and a family’s World War II service and secrets were revealed

A storage unit opened, and a family’s World War II service and secrets were revealed

MESA, Ariz. — The storage unit’s corrugated metal door slid upward, revealing 100 square feet of mostly empty space. Not very promising, thought Joe Alosi, a businessman who bid on units, sight unseen, when tenants stopped paying the rent. Several pl...
Published: 12/06/17
Updated: 12/08/17
Navy’s newest assistant secretary talks ships, subs and jet fighters

Navy’s newest assistant secretary talks ships, subs and jet fighters

TAMPA — Saturday afternoon, just three days before his swearing in as the next Navy assistant secretary for acquisition, research and development, James "Hondo’ Geurts talked about how his old job prepared him for the new one."I’ll be responsible for...
Published: 12/05/17
Stealth jets, other aircraft fly in U.S., South Korean drills

Stealth jets, other aircraft fly in U.S., South Korean drills

Associated PressSEOUL, South Korea — Hundreds of aircraft including two dozen stealth jets began training Monday as the United States and South Korea launched a massive combined air force exercise. The war games come a week after North Korea test-fir...
Published: 12/04/17

Altman: County’s Veterans Park to commemorate Pearl Harbor with memorial, new center

Every year, Americans pay homage to those killed on Dec. 7, 1941, when the Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor.This year, in Hillsborough County, the commemorations will take on additional meaning.Hillsborough County and local veterans welcome two major a...
Published: 11/30/17
Updated: 12/04/17
Two sailors from Florida, one from Louisiana die in Navy crash

Two sailors from Florida, one from Louisiana die in Navy crash

MIAMI — The U.S. Navy says two sailors from Florida and another from Louisiana died in an aircraft crash in the Philippine Sea. In a news release, the Navy’s 7th Fleet said the families of Lt. Steven Combs and Airman apprentice Bryan Grosso of Florid...
Updated one month ago