Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Court appears conflicted over DNA sampling issue

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court justices sounded closely split Tuesday on what one of them called the most important criminal procedure case in decades — a challenge to whether police may routinely take DNA samples from suspects and put the results in a national database.

"Why isn't this the fingerprinting of the 21st century?" asked Justice Samuel Alito. DNA is even more accurate than fingerprinting and has a great potential to solve horrible crimes, he said.

But his fellow conservative, Justice Antonin Scalia, took up the other side, arguing that the court has not allowed police to freely search people or homes in hopes of finding evidence of other possible crimes.

"If you stick a swab in his mouth, that's a search," Scalia said. "The purpose is to catch bad guys. But sometimes, the Fourth Amendment stands in the way."

Meanwhile, liberal Justice Stephen Breyer said DNA testing seemed entirely reasonable. It's "not intrusive," he said, referring to the mouth swab. And it's more accurate and reliable than fingerprinting, he said.

Others worried about going too far. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg asked if police could stop someone suspicious on the street and ask to take a DNA swab.

"Why not do it for every person who comes in for a driver's license?" asked Justice Elena Kagan, posing another hypothetical.

State attorneys from all 50 states have joined the Obama administration in urging the court to approve DNA testing of people who are arrested but not convicted of serious crimes. All states now authorize testing the DNA of people who are convicted of felony crimes.

Meanwhile, 28 states have gone further and begun taking DNA samples from people who are arrested for a serious crime.

But last year, Maryland's highest court ruled it was an unconstitutional search to take a DNA swab from a man arrested for assault. The suspect, Alonzo King, was later convicted of an unsolved rape based on a DNA match and was sentenced to life in prison. The court will issue a decision in Maryland vs. King in several months.

Other cases before the high court

• The Supreme Court on Tuesday threw out a broad lawsuit that challenged the constitutionality of the government's program of secret wiretapping of international phone calls and emails, ruling that none of the plaintiffs has "standing" to sue because they cannot prove their messages were intercepted. The 5-4 ruling is the latest of many that has shielded the government's antiterrorism programs from being challenged in court.

• The Supreme Court hears arguments today in a challenge to a key provision of the historic 1965 Voting Rights Act. The provision requires all or parts of 16 states with a history of racial discrimination, mostly in the South, to get approval from the Justice Department or federal court in Washington before making any changes in how they hold elections, such as moving a polling place. Shelby County, Ala., is challenging that plank.

Court appears conflicted over DNA sampling issue 02/26/13 [Last modified: Wednesday, February 27, 2013 1:08am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

Copyright: For copyright information, please check with the distributor of this item, Associated Press.
    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. 10 National Monuments the Interior Department Wants to Shrink or Modify

    Nation

    Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke has proposed that President Donald Trump make changes to 10 national monuments, including Bears Ears in southern Utah, according to a memo addressed to the White House.

  2. A botched surgery left a barber with erectile dysfunction. Decades later, he took revenge.

    The old man booked his appointment under an alias.

    In this July 27, 2017 file photo, Stanwood Fred Elkus, accused of shooting and killing his doctor at the doctor's office in Newport Beach in 2013, is wheeled into Orange County Superior Court in Santa Ana, Calif.
  3. Irma's death toll in Florida rises to 42, but will grow

    News

    TALLAHASSEE —Deadly carbon monoxide fumes have killed 11 people in Florida as Hurricane Irma's death toll rose to 42 on Tuesday, state officials reported.

    A resident walks by a pile of debris caused by a storm surge during Hurricane Irma in Everglades City. The isolated Everglades City community of about 400 people suffered some of Florida's worst storm surges, up to 9 feet (2.7 meters), when Hurricane Irma slammed the region eight days ago, leaving the insides of homes a sodden mess and caking the streets with mud. The storm affected nearly every part of the state, and, so far, the death toll stands at 42. [AP Photo | Alan Diaz]
  4. After Irma, Tampa Bay synagogues get ready for Rosh Hashana

    Religion

    As the holiest days of the Jewish calendar approached, so did Hurricane Irma.

    Congregants open the ark which holds several torah scrolls during Selichot services at Congregation B'nai Israel of St. Petersburg on Saturday, September 16, 2017. The Jewish new year, Rosh Hashana begins at sundown on Wednesday night.
  5. For ex-Rays/now Cubs manager Joe Maddon, the legacy is in the jeans

    Blogs

    Joe Maddon has plenty of memories of his time at the Trop during nine years of managing the Rays. "Too many to count,'' he said.