Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Justices question Florida use of IQ in death penalty cases

WASHINGTON — A majority of the Supreme Court seemed skeptical on Monday of how Florida uses IQ in death penalty cases.

Justice Anthony Kennedy, the court's frequent swing vote, joined more liberal justices in questioning Florida's rigid IQ score threshold for determining intellectual disability. Kennedy's positioning hinted at the possibility that the court might strike down the strict IQ rule used by Florida, Idaho, Kentucky and several other states with the death penalty.

The Supreme Court decided in Atkins vs. Virginia in 2002 that the execution of those variously called mentally retarded or intellectually disabled violates the Eighth Amendment's prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment.

The Atkins decision gave states substantial discretion and only general guidance. It said a finding of intellectual disability requires proof of three things: "subaverage intellectual functioning," meaning low IQ scores; a lack of fundamental social and practical skills; and the presence of both conditions before age 18. The court said IQ scores under "approximately 70" typically indicate intellectual disability.

Florida imposes a three-part test, which starts with a rigid requirement that the inmate score 70 or below on the IQ test. If the inmate scores below the cutoff number, the state also will assess for "deficits in adaptive behavior" and an onset before the age of 18.

Freddie Lee Hall, the 68-year-old convicted murderer whose case was before the Supreme Court on Monday, has been on the state's death row since 1978. Hall was convicted in the murders of a pregnant Sumter County woman and Hernando County sheriff's Deputy Lonnie Coburn. Hall and an accomplice, Mack Ruffin, were given life sentences for Coburn's death.

Hall had generally scored slightly above 70 on IQ tests.

Florida Solicitor General Allen Winsor said the state's approach was "a reasonable legislative judgment," one he said was followed in eight states.

But Kennedy and Justice Elena Kagan said the effect of Florida's rigid approach is to stop consideration of the other two factors in the analysis suggested in the Atkins decision.

Information from the New York Times was used in this report.

Justices question Florida use of IQ in death penalty cases 03/03/14 [Last modified: Tuesday, March 4, 2014 12:20am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

Copyright: For copyright information, please check with the distributor of this item, Tribune News Service.
    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Two boys in critical condition after Largo crash

    Accidents

    LARGO — A 7-year-old boy was thrown from a car in a head-on crash on Starkey Road, and both he and a 6-year-old boy were in critical condition Sunday night, according to the Florida Highway Patrol.

  2. Trump's new order bars almost all travel from seven countries

    National

    WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump on Sunday issued a new order banning almost all travel to the United States from seven countries, including most of the nations covered by his original travel ban, citing threats to national security posed by letting their citizens into the country.

    President Donald Trump speaks to reporters Sunday upon his return to the White House in Washington.
  3. Somehow, Rays' Chris Archer remains just shy of being an ace

    The Heater

    BALTIMORE — Chris Archer had another bad game Sunday.

    Chris Archer is sputtering to the finish line, his rough start on Sunday his fourth in his past five in which he hasn’t gotten past four innings.
  4. In Mexico City, hopes of finding quake survivors dwindle

    World

    MEXICO CITY — Five days after the deadly magnitude 7.1 earthquake, the hulking wreckage of what used to be a seven-story office building is one of the last hopes: one of just two sites left where searchers believe they may still find someone trapped alive in Mexico City.

    Rescue workers search for survivors inside a felled office building in the Roma Norte neighborhood of Mexico City on Saturday.
  5. GOP health bill in major peril as resistance hardens among key senators

    National

    WASHINGTON — The floundering Republican attempt to undo the Affordable Care Act met hardening resistance from key GOP senators Sunday that left it on the verge of collapse even as advocates vowed to keep pushing for a vote this week.

    Sen. Susan Collins, R-Maine, a moderate, said Sunday that it was “very difficult” to envision voting for this health-care bill.