Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Obama proposes new limits on NSA phone collections

WASHINGTON — President Barack Obama made a forceful call Friday to narrow the government's access to millions of Americans' phone records as part of an overhaul of surveillance activities that have raised concerns about official overreach.

The president said he no longer wants the National Security Agency to maintain a database of such records. But he left the creation of a new system to subordinates and lawmakers, many of whom are divided on the need for reform.

In a speech at the Justice Department, Obama ordered several immediate steps to limit the NSA program that collects domestic phone records, as well as other surveillance practices, which were exposed last year by former intelligence contractor Edward Snowden.

Obama directed that from now on, the government must obtain a court order for each phone number it wants to query in its database of records. Analysts will only be able to review phone calls that are two steps removed from a number associated with a terrorist organization instead of three. And he ordered a halt to eavesdropping on dozens of foreign leaders and governments who are friends or allies.

The changes mark the first significant constraints imposed by the Obama administration on surveillance programs that expanded dramatically in the decade after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks. But many of the changes could take months if not longer to implement, and already critics from diverse camps are warning that what he has called for may be unworkable.

Obama is retaining the vast majority of intelligence programs and capabilities that came to light over the past six months in a deluge of reports based on leaked documents. Even the most controversial capability — the government's access to bulk telephone records, known as metadata — may well be preserved, although with tighter controls and with the records in the hands of some outside entity.

The database holds phone numbers and call lengths and times, but not actual phone call content.

Obama recognized that others have raised alternatives, such as the moving custodianship of the records to the phone companies or an independent third party — and that such plans face significant hurdles.

He gave subordinates including Attorney General Eric Holder until March 28 to develop a plan to "transition" the bulk data out of the possession of the government. Existing authorities for the phone records program are set to expire on that date.

Reaction to Obama's call to end the phone records collection was mixed and underscored the political challenge he faces.

The chairmen of the House and Senate Intelligence Committees issued a joint statement focusing on Obama's remarks that "underscored the importance of using telephone metadata to rapidly identify possible terrorist plots." Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., and Rep. Mike Rogers, R-Mich., added that they have reviewed the existing NSA bulk collection program and "found it to be legal and effective," indicating they would oppose efforts to end it.

But many civil liberties groups said Obama failed to advance real reform by leaving open the door to third-party storage of records and data retention mandates.

"He doesn't commit to ending the bulk data collection of telephone records," said Anthony Romero, executive director of the American Civil Liberties Union. "He gets close to understanding the concerns, but he backs away from the real reform, which is to end the bulk data collection. He gets to the finish line, but he doesn't cross it."

Romero said he was trying to bridge irreconcilable positions: "Clearly this is a president who wants to agree with the criticism of the bulk data collection and retention, and yet wishes to retain that power notwithstanding the serious concerns," he said. "And you can't have it both ways."

John McLaughlin, a former CIA deputy director, said Obama "was trying to find a midway here." Obama's dilemma, he said, is responding to dual challenges: the perception that the program might one day be abused, and the reality that al-Qaida and its affiliates are growing stronger. "So as president, he's got to think, 'I don't want to take any chances here.' "

Unless there is a compelling national security purpose, Obama said, "we will not monitor the communications of heads of state and government of our close friends and allies." Friendly leaders "deserve to know that if I want to learn what they think about an issue, I will pick up the phone and call them, rather than turning to surveillance," he said.

As he made the case for reforms, Obama also cautioned that "we cannot unilaterally disarm our intelligence agencies." And he criticized foreign intelligence services that "feign surprise" over disclosures of U.S. surveillance while "constantly probing our government and private sector networks and accelerating programs to listen to our conversations, intercept our emails or compromise our systems."

He noted that some countries that "have loudly criticized the NSA privately acknowledge that America has special responsibilities as the world's only superpower . . . and that they themselves have relied on the information we obtain to protect their own people."

Expressing frustration at those who "assume the worst motives by our government," Obama said at another point in his speech: "No one expects China to have an open debate about their surveillance programs, or Russia to take privacy concerns of citizens in other places into account."

But he said the United States is held to a higher standard "precisely because we have been at the forefront in defending personal privacy and human dignity."

What won't change in the spy program

Obama left in place significant elements of the broad surveillance net assembled by the National Security Agency, and left the implementation of many of his changes up to Congress and the intelligence agencies themselves. Obama did not take up a recommendation to have the members of the surveillance court selected by appeals court judges rather than exclusively by the chief justice of the Supreme Court.

Measured criticism for Edward Snowden

Obama made only passing reference to Edward Snowden, the former NSA contractor who leaked documents detailing U.S. surveillance practices. "The sensational way in which these disclosures have come out has often shed more heat than light,'' Obama said, "while revealing methods to our adversaries that could impact our operations in ways that we may not fully understand for years to come."

Obama proposes new limits on NSA phone collections 01/17/14 [Last modified: Friday, January 17, 2014 11:56pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Man, I miss Planet Simeon


    Who needs a total eclipse of the sun when Simeon Rice, former Bucs sack king and cosmic force, is in town?

  2. Florida education news: HB 7069, solar eclipse, courtesy bus rides and more


    DISCORD: Employees of the Pinellas Classroom Teachers Association accuse the union of "less than fair and equitable" working conditions.

  3. Marina at Hudson Beach poised to become 24-unit condominium-hotel


    HUDSON — One of the mainstay businesses at Hudson Beach is poised for redevelopment into a 24-unit condominium-hotel.

  4. Eclipse forecast: Partly cloudy but little rain across Tampa Bay


    Eclipse Day in Tampa Bay should carry typical summertime conditions, meaning some popup clouds could obscure the historic event.