Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

One law, many views. How do we fix 'stand your ground'?

With three children under the age of 13 in his home, a father has a message for the task force that will begin reviewing the state's public safety laws today.

"Nobody in this house will be a victim in the middle of the night,'' he says. "If you break into my home, someone else will carry you out.

"I love the idea that the law allows us to protect ourselves.''

• • •

With a son recently shot to death during a traffic confrontation gone horribly wrong, a father is hopeful that the governor's task force will take a long, hard look at the state's "stand your ground'' law in Tallahassee today.

"There are so many unclear areas with this law that allow the person left alive to claim they were standing their ground,'' he says. "They could have been poking, prodding, provoking and pushing another person to their limit.

"And then they claim self-defense when they kill them.''

• • •

Which argument do you prefer?

The one from the father protecting his small children or the one from the father grieving for his adult son?

This is the challenge facing the governor's task force today — dissecting a law that was created in the name of public safety but has the potential to escalate violence.

No matter where your loyalties lie, there is no perfect solution. Even if you disagree with the law, it is still hard to argue against the concept of self-defense. And if you are a staunch supporter of "stand your ground,'' you have to admit loopholes do exist.

The question is, what to do with an imperfect law? Wipe it off the books? Tighten the loopholes? Leave it alone?

An independent task force created by state Sen. Chris Smith, D-Fort Lauderdale, recommended an overhaul of the law Monday, but the group of legislators, lawyers and law enforcement officials could not agree on whether it should be repealed.

The basic problem — and the heart of the Trayvon Martin/George Zimmerman case — is figuring out when an aggressor becomes a victim and vice versa.

A week ago, state Rep. Jim Frishe, R-St. Petersburg, was certain the law did not apply for Zimmerman because evidence suggested he instigated the confrontation by following Martin. Frishe, who supports the law, now concedes that Zimmerman might have a defense if he proves he tried to withdraw from the confrontation after initially provoking it.

It is part of the conundrum of a law known as "stand your ground'' that you are permitted to be the aggressor as long as you later retreat.

"There are some hoops you have to jump through if you start out as the aggressor,'' Frishe said. "I think that's why Zimmerman was charged.''

And so we're back to our original premise. Do you side with the father who says the law has merit or the one who believes it is ripe for abuse?

And does it matter that Kevin Lindsay is the father in both cases?

His son Brandon Baker confronted a driver who was tailgating him in Palm Harbor and was pepper sprayed and shot after allegedly punching the other driver through an open window.

"It's a bittersweet law, an odd coupling of ideas,'' Lindsay said. "I agree with the philosophy, but it needs to be picked apart and fixed.''

John Romano can be reached at

One law, many views. How do we fix 'stand your ground'? 04/30/12 [Last modified: Tuesday, May 1, 2012 7:10am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Pinellas County receives $30 million for beach renourishment

    Local Government

    CLEARWATER –– While Pinellas beaches continually rank among the best in America, they need help to stay that way.

    The Army Corps of Engineers has allocated $30 million to help with beach renourishment at several Pinellas locations, including including Sand Key, Treasure Island and Upham Beach. This photo from 2014 shows how waves from high tides caused beach erosion at Sunset Beach near Mansions by the Sea condominium complex SCOTT KEELER   |   Times

  2. Straz Center parking squeeze infuriates patrons, motivates search for solutions


    TAMPA — When the David A. Straz Jr. Center for the Performing Arts opened 30 years ago, it welcomed just 30,000 patrons its first year.

    Fireworks shoot into the sky over the David A. Straz Jr. Center For The Performing Arts. [SCOTT MCINTYRE, Times]
  3. Video shows naked man who stole swan sculpture in Lakeland, deputies say


    The Polk County Sheriff's Office is searching for a large swan sculpture that was stolen from a Lakeland cold storage facility last weekend, possibly by a naked man.

    The Polk County Sheriff's Office says this naked man stole a large black and white swan sculpture, upper right, from a Lakeland storage facility last weekend. Surveillance video showed the man walking into Lakeland Cold Storage. [Polk County Sheriff's Office]
  4. Fennelly: Dirk Koetter's apology no way to keep this fidget spinning


    TAMPA — It all began with a fidget spinner.

    This tweet from the Bucs, mocking the Falcons' 28-3 lead they lost in the Super Bowl against the Falcons, prompted a public apology from head coach Dirk Koetter, who called it "unprofessional and not smart."
  5. Jeb money trickles into Putnam's bid for governor


    Money from a Jeb Bush super PAC has made its way into Florida’s 2018 governors race.
    A year ago, Bush’s Right to Rise PAC put $1,171 in money