Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Cutting back is not the answer

At first, most developed economies responded to the global financial crisis in 2008 and '09 with stimulus. They increased government spending and cut taxes. John Maynard Keynes provided the playbook: In slack times, the government needs to fill in for diminished private demand.

But 2010 is shaping up to be a year of parsimony. To win support for an international bailout, Greece enacted a tough package of budget cuts and tax increases. Spain's left-wing government at the end of May slashed civil-servant pay by 5 percent and froze pensions — even though one in five Spaniards is out of work. German Chancellor Angela Merkel unveiled a $144 billion package that would raise taxes on airline flights and cut defense spending and public works. "We can't have everything we want if we are to shape the future," Merkel said.

In the United States, even though unemployment remains high, the House scaled back a proposed jobs bill out of concern for the deficit. President Barack Obama called for federal agencies to identify cuts of up to 5 percent in 2012. States and cities are slashing budgets and raising taxes. Worldwide, what New York Times columnist Paul Krugman has called "the pain caucus" is in the ascendancy.

Countries are joining the caucus for different reasons. Many, especially slow-growing, highly indebted countries in southern Europe, see austerity as a way to avoid the fate of Greece. Others are reacting to fears of stimulus-induced inflation. In fact, signs of inflation are scarce.

"To say that we need policies now to fight a global outbreak of inflation is like arguing that we need policies now to guard against the imminent alarming spread of the North Polar ice cap," says University of California-Berkeley economist Brad DeLong. Yet important economies remain hypersensitive to the merest trace of inflation. Germany is taking tough steps because it wants to set an example for the European monetary union, but also because it is paralyzed by the ghost of the 1920s' hyperinflation, which paved the way for Hitler.

In the United States, the same internal debate that roiled the Clinton White House in 1993 — when advisers Robert Rubin and Robert Reich tangled over the relative merits of deficit reduction and stimulus — is being replayed. In 1993 the Rubinites won, arguing that Democrats needed to demonstrate a commitment to deficit reduction to avoid being tarred as tax-and-spenders.

The Obama administration has made a different calculation: Higher short-term deficits are a greater political risk than slower growth and higher unemployment. But the debate fails to recognize the anti-stimulus provided by states and cities, which are prohibited from running deficits. The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities calculated that 33 states made tax changes in 2008 or '09 that would increase annual revenues by $31.7 billion. Meanwhile, state and local governments slashed 22,000 jobs in May. "The actions that states are taking because of the recession and their balanced-budget requirements are slowing the economy," said Nicholas Johnson, director of the state fiscal project at CBPP.

It's difficult to contract your way to growth. The world's large economies need to run higher deficits in the short term to promote growth and close the gaps later. St. Augustine famously pleaded: "Grant me chastity and continence, but not yet." Policymakers might rethink Augustine. Give us austerity and deficit reduction — but not yet.

Cutting back is not the answer 06/19/10 [Last modified: Friday, June 18, 2010 5:24pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Withlacoochee River reaches crest, begins to fall


    After reaching its fifth-highest crest ever, the Withlacoochee River has begun to recede.

    An aerial view shows flooding in the Talisman Estates area along the Withlacoochee River in Hernando County.
  2. Hulk Hogan talks Tampa Bay, depression and politics on Fox News' 'Objectified'


    For better or worse, Terry "Hulk Hogan" Bollea is our guy.

    Hulk Hogan shows Harvey Levin his wrestling boots on Fox News' "Objectified."
  3. Pumpkin pileup: Fiery crash causes mess, closes portion of I-75 in Pasco


    Drivers on Interstate 75 in Pasco County should expect continued delays on Friday as road crews work to clean up a mess of debris — and pumpkins — left behind after a fiery semitrailer truck crash in the early morning hours.

    Road crews clean up a mess of crash debris - and pumpkins - left behind after a fiery semitrailer truck crash on Interstate 75 in Pasco County on Sept. 22, 2017. [Florida Highway Patrol]
  4. Cannon Fodder podcast: Key matchups in Bucs-Vikings game


    In our latest Bucs Cannon Fodder podcast, Greg Auman breaks down five key matchups that will help decide Sunday's Bucs game against the Minnesota Vikings.

    Defensive lineman Chris Baker is a question mark heading into Sunday's game against the Vikings.
  5. Rick and Tom podcast: Will Bucs go 2-0? Are Gators on upset alert?


    It's football friday as Rick Stroud and Tom Jones break down the Bucs' game in Minnesota, including the improved offensive line.

    Ali Marpet moved from guard to center on an improved Bucs offensive line.