Sunday, June 24, 2018
Perspective

Lecturing other nations won't fix climate change

In 984 A.D. the Vikings established a remote settlement in Greenland. The chiefs over-used the land and its resources to support for themselves a luxury lifestyle. When this most western outpost of European society collapsed 500 years later, "the chiefs had preserved for themselves the privilege of being the last to starve."

From "Collapse" by Jarred Diamond

Last week Secretary of State John Kerry in a speech delivered in Indonesia called climate change "the world's most fearsome weapon of mass destruction." He urged Indonesia, and other developing nations, to limit their rapid growth in greenhouse gas emissions.

The developing nations, like Indonesia, have been unwilling at the U.N.-sponsored international conferences on climate change to agree to cut their rapid growth in emissions because of their essential need to reduce the large proportion of their population living in extreme poverty.

However, if they continue to increase emissions at current rates, they will crash the capacity of the planet to support a growing world population of more than 7 billion, bringing the developed nations down with them.

But the stark reality is that no developing nation will reduce greenhouse gas emissions unless the United States and other developed nations first take meaningful steps to assist them in alleviating extreme poverty.

The developing nations have nothing to lose by waiting. We have everything to lose by lecturing them to do more.

The developed nations grew their prosperity by deferring the costs of protecting the capacity of the planet to support human life. As the worst offender, the United States has the largest historical ecological deficit of any nation.

On a per capita basis we, of all the developed nations, are the weapon of mass destruction.

At the U.N. international conferences, we have refused to pay "backwards" for the harm already done in proportion to what we are asking the developing countries to pay "forward" as future prevention. That is what the developing nations have asked for as a basis for reaching an international agreement. By standing firm, all we will gain for ourselves is the privilege of being the last society to collapse.

Edward Renner is a professor in the Honors College of the University of South Florida. He may be contacted at [email protected] The environmental data is from the Global Footprint Network data base: www.footprintnetwork.org. He wrote this exclusively for the Tampa Bay Times.

Comments
Does North Korea’s negotiating history mean it can’t be trusted?

Does North Korea’s negotiating history mean it can’t be trusted?

The stakes could hardly be higher for President Donald Trump’s Singapore summit with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un.Given Pyongyang’s strides toward developing a nuclear-tipped missile capable of reaching the United States, an arms control deal loom...
Published: 06/11/18
PolitiFact: Fact-checking the death toll estimates from Hurricane Maria in Puerto Rico

PolitiFact: Fact-checking the death toll estimates from Hurricane Maria in Puerto Rico

Many news reports latched on to the number 4,645 in a new Harvard University study about the death toll in Puerto Rico from Hurricane Maria — more than 70 times above the government’s official count.While the number grabbed headlines, it requires exp...
Updated one month ago