Saturday, March 24, 2018

'Lone Survivor': fact and fiction in movie, book (w/video)

Editor's note: Much has been made of the accuracy of Lone Survivor, which has been widely praised for its realism and even named "one of the most realistic war movies of all time." To provide much of its authenticity, writer-director Peter Berg worked closely with Marcus Luttrell, the Navy SEAL played by Mark Wahlberg in the film, and the author of the memoir of the same name. However, while the movie recreates many of the realities of war in painstaking detail, it also diverges significantly from the real-life Operation Red Wings, which was far larger than a four-man SEAL reconnaissance looking for a man named Ahmad Shah. In an article on, Michael and Eric Cummings detail many of the creative liberties the movie takes and, in turn, are critical of much of the memoir itself. For example, the final battle depicted in the film never happened. At their blog, the Cummings brothers also dismiss the thought — not in the movie but in the book — that there was a vote on whether to release or to kill the goatherds who had discovered them and compromised the recon, in which three of the four SEALs would die. The article has been adapted and reprinted with their permission.

Here are some examples of where the movie Lone Survivor diverges from what really happened in Afghanistan.


Lone Survivor opens with voiceover as a dying Marcus Luttrell is airlifted back to a military base. As the plane lands, Marcus Luttrell literally dies. Here's how the screenplay reads:

Surgical pack working franticly (sic) to save Luttrell.


Pushing in on the flatline. Alarm screaming. Tight on Luttrell's eyes starting to glaze over. Dying.

According to Luttrell's memoir, however, he was not in mortal danger. After the Army Rangers rescue Luttrell, the Army Rangers "radioed into base that I had been found, that I was stable and unlikely to die." They also stop and have tea with the locals, which you wouldn't do with a dying man.


After the battle, according to the book, Luttrell is found by a local man named Sarawa, who also tends to his wounds:

I saw the leader walk up to me. He smiled and said his name was Sarawa.

In the film, a local man named Gulab rescues him:

A 30-year-old male GULAB, the leader, strong rugged handsome, steps forward. Hands up in peace.

GULAB: Not Taliban.

According to Luttrell's 60 Minutes interview, "That's when an Afghan man appeared. Luttrell later learned his name was Mohammad Gulab." Luttrell might have changed this detail to protect Gulab from retribution, but Gulab is mentioned by name later in the memoir. (Though there's a difference there, too: In the film, Gulab stays behind after Luttrell leaves. In the book, he joins Luttrell on the helicopter ride.)


In the film, Shah's lieutenant, Taraq, comes to the village, grabs Luttrell, and drags him out to a log to behead him, raising a machete in the air. Luttrell is saved at the last minute by the local villagers, who fire off their AK-47s to threaten the attackers.

None of this happened. In the book, members of the Taliban enter Luttrell's room and begin beating him. ("I didn't give that much of a s---," Luttrell writes. "I can suck this kind of crap up, like I've been trained. Anyway, they didn't have a decent punch among them.") The village elder then enters the room, and commands the Taliban to leave. The whole ordeal takes about six hours, Luttrell explains, and his life is never in danger.


In the film, Luttrell removes a bullet from his leg. According to the screenplay, Gulab helps:

Gruesome bullet-removing sequence. Blood. Screaming digging scraping out bullets and shrapnel from Luttrell's back and legs. Gulab digs with a knife. Pours water on the wounds. The little boy holds Luttrell's hands and whispers to him.

According to the book, none of this happened. As soon as they reach the village, the locals give him medical aid. And there's no bullet to be found:

(Sarawa) carefully cleaned the wounds to my leg, confirming what I had suspected, that there was no bullet lodged in my left thigh. Indeed, he located the bullet's exit hole.


In the film, an old man heads over a mountain to alert the military to Luttrell's location. In the book, the village elder walks to Asadabad to alert the military to Luttrell's presence, but that's not how the military actually found him. Instead, Luttrell uses a radio air-dropped by the military:

Before we left, I asked them how the hell they'd found me. And it turned out to be my emergency beacon in the window of the little rock house in the mountain.

60 Minutes tells a similar story: "He was finally rescued by U.S. forces who had been scouring the mountains."


Lone Survivor (film) ends with the village of Kandish fending off a Taliban attack in a gigantic firefight, which ends when American planes and helicopters come to the rescue. The screenplay has Gulab shot and Luttrell shot again, and Gulab's house is destroyed by an RPG.

None of this happened. Gulab's house wasn't destroyed, nor did the Taliban fire shots into the village. Neither Gulab nor Luttrell were shot, and Luttrell didn't stab an attacker with a knife.

The most important reason why the Taliban didn't attack? They couldn't afford to lose the support of the villagers. Luttrell makes this very clear in the memoir:

They wanted me, but they would never kill another hundred Afghan people, including women and children, in order to get me. … I'd been (in Sabray) for five nights now, ... and the Taliban had crossed the boundaries of Sabray only twice.

Later, Ahmad Shah and his men actually find Luttrell and Gulab on a flat field on the edge of the village. Do they attack? No. Why?

The presence of Gulab made it a complete standoff, and (Shah) was not about to call in his guys to shoot the oldest son of Sabray's village elder.


In the film, the military comes to the rescue of Luttrell in a roar of gunships and men descending from helicopters. In the book, the Rangers find Luttrell in the forest as he and Gulab walk back to the village after Gulab spoke with Ahmad Shah. (This is when they settle down for tea.)


The SEALs on the hill that day were overwhelmed by an enemy force with superior numbers and superior firepower that held the high ground. But there is a considerable difference between an 8- or 10-man, squad-sized enemy force and a 200-man, infantry-company-sized enemy force. The Korengal and Shuryak valleys — the geographic region of Operation Red Wings — are sparsely populated and could not support an enemy force of 200 people.

Increasing the size of the enemy that day makes for a much better story. As the story told in Lone Survivor became more popular, the size of the enemy force that day seems to have increased with each telling. Here are the various descriptions of the number of enemy fighters that attacked:

Ed Darack's Victory Point: 8-10 fighters with a machine gun.

Luttrell's after-action report: 20-30 fighters.

Lt. Michael P. Murphy's Medal of Honor citation: 30-40 fighters.

Lt. Murphy's Medal of Honor Summary of Action: over 50 fighters.

Marcus Luttrell on the Today Show: 80-100 members of the Taliban.

Lone Survivor (memoir): 140-200 fighters.

Marcus Luttrell speeches after Lone Survivor: 200 fighters.

Lone Survivor (screenplay): At least 50 fighters. ("A solid line of at least 50 Taliban in firing positions on top of the hill above them.")


Ahmad Shah was an insurgent leader in Afghanistan, which is why the Marines in the Pech launched Operation Red Wings. But there is a big difference between a local Afghan insurgent leader and "one of Osama bin Laden's closest associates," as he's described in Luttrell's memoir, or "a high-level al-Qaida operative," as he's described in the production notes and on the film's official site. According to Victory Point author Ed Darack, Ahmad Shah was not a member of al-Qaida and had never met Osama bin Laden prior to Operation Red Wings.


In the film, Matthew Axelson (played by Ben Foster) claims that Shah killed 20 Marines in the week before Operation Red Wings. (This claim is in both trailers.) As shows, the United States did not lose 20 Marines in the week before Operation Red Wings. Only two U.S. soldiers or Marines died in Kunar province in 2005 before Operation Red Wings. In the week before Operation Red Wings, only 2 soldiers died in the entire country. Up to that point, only five Marines had died in combat since the war started.


Both the film and the book more or less ignore the role of Marines in conceiving, planning, and leading Operation Red Wings. The Marines brought in SEALs to gain access to aviation support.

Michael Cummings left the U.S. Army in 2011 after deployments to Afghanistan and Iraq. His work has been featured by the New York Times, the Washington Post, and Foreign He is currently pursuing his MBA at UCLA's Anderson School of Management. With his brother, he runs On Violence, a blog on military and foreign affairs. Eric Cummings is a writer living in Los Angeles. His work has been featured in the Los Angeles Times and other publications. With his brother, he runs On Violence, a blog on military and foreign affairs.

© 2014 Slate


Perspective: The real scandal isnít Cambridge Analytica. Itís Facebookís whole business model.

The plot was made for front-page headlines and cable-news chyrons: A scientist-turned-political-operative reportedly hoodwinked Facebook users into giving up personal data on both themselves and all their friends for research purposes, then used it t...
Published: 03/20/18
Updated: 03/23/18

Perspective: Be a skeptic, not a cynic

Editorís note: This is adapted from a speech to 600 middle and high school students and teachers participating in a Model U.N. program at St. Petersburg College, Clearwater campus, this month.Itís time to be more than a spectator. Your involvement ca...
Published: 03/19/18
Updated: 03/23/18

Just 17%of the subjects of biographies on Wikipedia are women.39is the median age at first marriage for men in Norway (itís 38 for women), according to a recent estimate cited in the Atlantic. Thatís six to eight years higher than the median age at f...
Published: 03/19/18
Updated: 03/23/18
Perspective: 50 years later, it feels familiar: how America fractured in 1968

Perspective: 50 years later, it feels familiar: how America fractured in 1968

Even from the distance of a half century, 1968 feels familiar. From January to December, people demonstrated against racial injustice and economic inequality. Abroad, the United States military slogged through a seemingly interminable war. And after ...
Published: 03/19/18
Updated: 03/22/18

A Little Perspective: The woman in the photo ... and kidsí drawings of scientists

She was the only woman in a photo of 38 scientists from a 1971 conference. She was also the only one not named, but Twitter sleuths banded together this month to identify her.It began with an illustratorís investigation into the archives of marine le...
Published: 03/19/18
Updated: 03/22/18

Perspective: For black men, growing up rich may not help

Black boys raised in America, even in the wealthiest families and living in some of the most well-to-do neighborhoods, still earn less in adulthood than white boys with similar backgrounds, according to a sweeping new study that traced the lives of m...
Published: 03/18/18
Updated: 03/23/18

Perspective: For two months, I got my news from print newspapers. Hereís what I learned.

I first got news of the school shooting in Parkland via an alert on my watch. Even though I had turned off news notifications months ago, the biggest news still somehow finds a way to slip through.But for much of the next 24 hours after that alert, I...
Published: 03/08/18
Updated: 03/16/18
Perspective: The struggle to conceive with frozen eggs

Perspective: The struggle to conceive with frozen eggs

MANHATTAN BEACH, Calif.Brigitte Adams caused a sensation four years ago when she appeared on the cover of Bloomberg Businessweek under the headline, "Freeze your eggs, Free your career." She was single and blond, a Vassar graduate who spoke fluent It...
Published: 03/08/18
Updated: 03/16/18
Seven years after the Fukushima  nuclear disaster, Japanese town rebounds from zero

Seven years after the Fukushima nuclear disaster, Japanese town rebounds from zero

NARAHA, Japan ó One hour from the evacuation zone, at a rest stop in the mountains, it hits you. A blue sign on the wall, with birds that look like flying oranges and a message for travelers."Cheer up, Fukushima."Back on the Joban Expressway, rolling...
Updated one month ago

Perspective: Searching for common sense on guns and kids

ím a gun owner, a university professor, an attorney and ó most critically ó a father of three. We can find a pragmatic, working common ground on gun policy and not let the terms of the debate be set either by the relatively small number of unbridled ...
Published: 03/07/18
Updated: 03/09/18