Saturday, March 24, 2018

Perspective: How chastity can lead to good sex

As a colleague and I crossed the parking lot at the Port Richey bureau of the Tampa Bay Times, he pointed at the bumper sticker on my car's rear windshield.

He read it aloud: "Chastity is for lovers."

He furrowed his brow and tilted his head, perplexed by what he had read.

"How can chastity be for lovers if it means you can't have sex?" he asked.

What I said surprised him:

It doesn't.

I am a single, 29-year-old virgin, abstinent because as a Roman Catholic Christian, I practice a virtue called chastity. My colleague's misconception of it is classic. He didn't know what too few people do: that chastity isn't abstinence.

Abstinence has only one requirement: no sex. But chastity requires a person to define sex as a sacred, physical sign of the vows husbands and wives made at the altar where they were married, designed to express a married couple's union, and for procreation.

Chastity provides depth where abstinence lacks it. It requires us to abstain from sex outside marriage, but unlike abstinence, it also explains why. Chastity clarifies that we are not supposed to abstain from sex outside marriage because sex is bad (it isn't), or because it will soil us (it won't), but because of what sex is: an expression of the unity achieved by the sacrament of matrimony.

All people who practice chastity must govern their appetites instead of being governed by them. But chastity otherwise implies something different for each of us, depending on our states of life. Chaste single people save sex (or sex from now on) for marriage. We believe marriage is designed to result in the destruction of self-absorption, and that we are designed to create a pleasurable sexual relationship with the person we marry, not to marry somebody because the sex is "good." Chaste married people agree neither to use nor abuse each other, and to treat sex as a mutual gift of self, not as mutually advantageous selfishness.

Stories about Christian kids, or kids of other religions, who turned into adults who saved sex for marriage and wish they hadn't, fuel derision for the religious belief systems that influenced their decisions to save sex. But their regrets don't out premarital abstinence as a bad idea. They expose an actual bad idea: teaching abstinence without also teaching chastity.

Some people who abstain from sex until marriage have traumatic wedding nights, or hate sex, or get divorced. But they do not have traumatic wedding nights, or hate sex, or get divorced because they abstained — abstinence doesn't cause dysfunction. Part of what causes this kind of dysfunction is the promotion of abstinence outside chastity, a virtue that necessitates good sex ed and marriage prep.

Abstinence just challenges us not to have sex. Chastity challenges us to live lives in which desire is subservient to reason, which equips us to love as Jesus does: selflessly.

Children who turn into adults who don't know the difference but were raised in Christian churches have been robbed. The adults who told them to abstain from sex without also discussing chastity, sex or relationships have been irresponsible. "The problem isn't the church's teaching," said Dae Sheridan, a licensed mental health counselor and board certified clinical sexologist. "The problem is ignoring basic tenets of sexuality education."

On their wedding night, Samantha Pugsley and her husband fumbled around in the dark. For her, sex hurt. Afterward, she cried in the bathroom. "If I could go back, I would not wait," she wrote in an essay last year called "It Happened to Me: I Waited Until My Wedding Night to Lose My Virginity and I Regret It."

She wrote that she abstained from sex until marriage because she had signed a pledge when she was 10 that said she would, because if she maintained her virginity until after her wedding, as she had learned at church, "my marriage would be blessed by God."

But at first, she hated sex. Waiting until marriage had not resulted in the happily-ever-after the adults at her church told her it would. A couple years into her marriage, she wrote, she admitted that to her husband.

"My feminist husband was horrified that I'd let him touch me when I didn't want him to. He made me promise I'd never do anything I didn't want to do ever again," wrote Pugsley, who is still married. "It was the first step on a long journey to healing."

Churches like the one Pugsley attended as a kid build walls between kids and sex instead of telling kids the truth about it — that it is possible to create a unique, pleasurable sexual relationship after a wedding; that sex's goodness is far more fundamental than how fast it gratifies you; that it's okay if sexual compatibility isn't intuitive or effortless, because sex isn't static.

"Prepare for the fact that if you don't know how your bodies are going to work together, there's going to be some trial and error," said Sheridan, the counselor. "Most people have to discover each other and communicate."

Kids can't know that if all their parents or preachers ever tell them is "don't do it."

"I didn't know how to transition," Pugsley said. "I couldn't figure out how sex went from bad to good (after a wedding). It still felt bad."

But sex isn't bad. And it's time, by teaching chastity, to make sure that kids become adults who know that.

Arleen Spenceley, author of the book "Chastity Is For Lovers: Single, Happy, and (Still) a Virgin," is a staff writer for the Pasco and Hernando sections of the Tampa Bay Times. Contact her at [email protected] Follow @ArleenSpenceley.


Perspective: The real scandal isnít Cambridge Analytica. Itís Facebookís whole business model.

The plot was made for front-page headlines and cable-news chyrons: A scientist-turned-political-operative reportedly hoodwinked Facebook users into giving up personal data on both themselves and all their friends for research purposes, then used it t...
Published: 03/20/18
Updated: 03/23/18

Perspective: Be a skeptic, not a cynic

Editorís note: This is adapted from a speech to 600 middle and high school students and teachers participating in a Model U.N. program at St. Petersburg College, Clearwater campus, this month.Itís time to be more than a spectator. Your involvement ca...
Published: 03/19/18
Updated: 03/23/18

Just 17%of the subjects of biographies on Wikipedia are women.39is the median age at first marriage for men in Norway (itís 38 for women), according to a recent estimate cited in the Atlantic. Thatís six to eight years higher than the median age at f...
Published: 03/19/18
Updated: 03/23/18
Perspective: 50 years later, it feels familiar: how America fractured in 1968

Perspective: 50 years later, it feels familiar: how America fractured in 1968

Even from the distance of a half century, 1968 feels familiar. From January to December, people demonstrated against racial injustice and economic inequality. Abroad, the United States military slogged through a seemingly interminable war. And after ...
Published: 03/19/18
Updated: 03/22/18

A Little Perspective: The woman in the photo ... and kidsí drawings of scientists

She was the only woman in a photo of 38 scientists from a 1971 conference. She was also the only one not named, but Twitter sleuths banded together this month to identify her.It began with an illustratorís investigation into the archives of marine le...
Published: 03/19/18
Updated: 03/22/18

Perspective: For black men, growing up rich may not help

Black boys raised in America, even in the wealthiest families and living in some of the most well-to-do neighborhoods, still earn less in adulthood than white boys with similar backgrounds, according to a sweeping new study that traced the lives of m...
Published: 03/18/18
Updated: 03/23/18

Perspective: For two months, I got my news from print newspapers. Hereís what I learned.

I first got news of the school shooting in Parkland via an alert on my watch. Even though I had turned off news notifications months ago, the biggest news still somehow finds a way to slip through.But for much of the next 24 hours after that alert, I...
Published: 03/08/18
Updated: 03/16/18
Perspective: The struggle to conceive with frozen eggs

Perspective: The struggle to conceive with frozen eggs

MANHATTAN BEACH, Calif.Brigitte Adams caused a sensation four years ago when she appeared on the cover of Bloomberg Businessweek under the headline, "Freeze your eggs, Free your career." She was single and blond, a Vassar graduate who spoke fluent It...
Published: 03/08/18
Updated: 03/16/18
Seven years after the Fukushima  nuclear disaster, Japanese town rebounds from zero

Seven years after the Fukushima nuclear disaster, Japanese town rebounds from zero

NARAHA, Japan ó One hour from the evacuation zone, at a rest stop in the mountains, it hits you. A blue sign on the wall, with birds that look like flying oranges and a message for travelers."Cheer up, Fukushima."Back on the Joban Expressway, rolling...
Updated one month ago

Perspective: Searching for common sense on guns and kids

ím a gun owner, a university professor, an attorney and ó most critically ó a father of three. We can find a pragmatic, working common ground on gun policy and not let the terms of the debate be set either by the relatively small number of unbridled ...
Published: 03/07/18
Updated: 03/09/18