Saturday, December 16, 2017
Perspective

Perspective: Records requests hijack scientists' time

There are so many things I'd prefer to spend money on than taxpayer-funded witch hunts. Like the search to alleviate human suffering rooted in starvation and malnutrition, for example.

Yet the University of Florida sometimes must pay attention to such seemingly perverse priorities. It's not because some of our scientists work to harness technology as a way to feed the world. It's because they try to explain the benefits of that technology to the world outside academia.

Kevin Folta, a plant biologist with UF's Institute of Food and Agricultural Sciences, has become the target of multiple intrusive public records requests, including from "Food Babe" Vani Hari, after he answered questions on a corporate-funded website called GMOanswers.com about the use of molecular science to improve crops.

What we've previously learned from episodes such as Climategate is that scientists' emails can be cherry-picked and used out of context to confuse the public about issues around which there is solid scientific consensus. In Folta's case, the emails are being used to unfairly paint a public servant in science as a corporate stooge. U.S. Right to Know, the anti-GMO activist group that obtained the records, has also driven the narrative of their interpretation.

It's gone all the way to the front page of the Sunday New York Times, which unfairly characterized Folta's relationship with Monsanto. The newspaper presents a picture of corporations enlisting university faculty as their lobbyists. In reality, Monsanto donated $25,000 to the University of Florida, not to Folta, to cover travel expenses for his volunteer work speaking about the science of agricultural biotechnology.

Yet for this, Folta is suffering attacks on his reputation. The implication is that ties to industry discredit a scientist's work.

But this is the way the land-grant university system is supposed to work. Part of our mission is to partner with others — be they corporations, nonprofits, or government agencies — to discover, test and commercialize inventions. It's also our mission to share science and innovation broadly with the public.

As a publicly funded university, we value transparency. As a result of the activists' request, we released in writing what Folta has consistently disclosed in his talks around the nation — that Monsanto helped fund his outreach program.

We believe the attacks to be unjustified, but we moved the money from Folta's university expense account to a campus food pantry. Our ability to continue engaging in credible science is more valuable than any travel money a company could provide to us.

To put the travel money into context, Folta is currently working under a $500,000 federal grant to research how light can be used as a nonchemical means to improve shelf life in crops such as strawberries. What he learns could increase Florida farmers' earnings and improve public health if nutritious foods are more available and attractive.

The expense and energy that goes into responding to paper chases is aggravating, but much more concerning is the prospect that other Kevin Foltas of the scientific community are sitting silent because they do not want to be subjected to such harassment.

Joy Rumble, an assistant professor of agricultural communication at UF/IFAS (which I head), told the audience at a campus biotechnology literacy day organized by Folta that this phenomenon is known as the spiral of silence.

People tend to not publicly share their beliefs if they feel they're in the minority, the theory goes, for fear of isolation or even reprisals. That silence, in turn, feeds greater fear among dissenters as the status quo dominates the public discussion.

In a society in which the might of a megaphone too often trumps the power of ideas, that can mean truth loses. It's not an abstract concept to Rumble. She, too, answered a question or two on GMOanswers.com. She, too, was targeted by a public records request, prompting us to once again summon the IT department and the legal office.

The Union of Concerned Scientists, a group long recognized for its hard skeptical stance on agricultural biotechnology, goes so far as to put the label "bullying" on the kinds of public records requests faced by Folta and Rumble.

In "Freedom to Bully: How Laws Intended to Free Information Are Used to Harass Researchers," the organization decries the use of broad records requests that can hijack researchers' time, divert university money and chill researchers' interest in communicating with the public they serve.

So when Folta gets death threats, as he did after a recent visit to Hawaii to talk about the science of GMOs, when he's dogged by Internet trolls who append misinformation to his commentary on websites, when we have to go on a paper chase for activists looking for nonexisting evidence of a purchased point of view, that's more than a nuisance.

It contributes to the locking in our UF labs of potential solutions to worldwide problems. It slows the adoption of technologies that can improve lives. A Pew Research Center survey released early this year found that 88 percent of scientists say GMO foods are safe, while only 37 percent of the general public says so. That's a huge gap, and Folta is trying to bridge it — for farmers, for the needy, for the environment and for consumers.

Anyone who cares about the future of food needs to speak up. Share the message that public policy on biotechnology must be based on science, not sentience. Only then can we reverse the spiral of silence, allow reason and data to dominate the discussion, and unlock the labs to give us a shot at sustainably feeding a population that increases while our resources don't.

Jack Payne is the University of Florida's senior vice president for agriculture and natural resources and leader of the Institute of Food and Agricultural Sciences. He wrote this exclusively for the Tampa Bay Times.

Comments

President Trump isnít watching too much TV; itís just the wrong kind.

By JAMES PONIEWOZIKBecause President Donald Trump has said he is a reader ó big-league reader, reads documents, the best documents ó I hope that he is reading this, and not, say, watching a Fox & Friends recording on the gigantic flat-screen TV that ...
Published: 12/12/17
Updated: 12/14/17
PolitiFact: What you need to know about net neutrality

PolitiFact: What you need to know about net neutrality

The Federal Communications Commissionís vote to scrap Obama-era internet restrictions creates the potential for broadband providers like Frontier and Spectrum to divide their networks into fast lanes and slow lanes, throttle rivalsí video-streaming s...
Published: 12/12/17
Updated: 12/14/17

Perspective: Sexual harassment training doesnít work, but some things do.

Many people are familiar with typical corporate training to prevent sexual harassment: clicking through a PowerPoint, checking a box that you read the employee handbook or attending a mandatory seminar at which someone lectures about harassment while...
Published: 12/12/17
Updated: 12/14/17

12Thatís how many cans of Diet Coke President Donald Trump drinks each day, according to the New York Times.3 timesThatís how much likelier farmed salmon are to be partially deaf than their wild relatives. Scientists at the University of Melbourne de...
Published: 12/12/17
Updated: 12/14/17
Perspective: The year Santa Claus didnít come

Perspective: The year Santa Claus didnít come

The doctor studied the glob of puss oozing from the patchwork of scabs along my one-year-old sonís left index finger."Itís definitely infected. And you have no idea when or how it happened?"He didnít say it, but hereís what I heard next in my head: "...
Published: 12/11/17
Updated: 12/15/17
Perspective: An economist explains how to sort facts from fictions

Perspective: An economist explains how to sort facts from fictions

In public debates about economic policy, it can be hard to separate real insights from political posturing. But a few simple rules of thumb can help.Start with information you can count on. Crucial economic statistics ó like the unemployment rate, in...
Published: 12/11/17
Updated: 12/14/17
News media offers consistently warped portrayals of black families, study finds

News media offers consistently warped portrayals of black families, study finds

If all you knew about black families was what national news outlets reported, you are likely to think African Americans are overwhelmingly poor, reliant on welfare, absentee fathers and criminals, despite what government data show, according to the r...
Published: 12/06/17
Updated: 12/14/17
Perspective: Is the GOP tax plan an unprecedented windfall for the wealthy? We look at 50 years of data to find out.

Perspective: Is the GOP tax plan an unprecedented windfall for the wealthy? We look at 50 years of data to find out.

The Democrats say President Donald Trumpís tax cuts are a massive giveaway to the rich, the most unequal overhaul of the U.S. tax system in modern history. Republicans argue they are a huge middle class tax cut ó "a great, big, beautiful Christmas pr...
Published: 12/05/17
Updated: 12/07/17

Perspective: Guilt can be good for your kid

Guilt can be a complicated element in the parent-child equation; we feel guilty, they feel guilty, we may make them feel guilty and then feel guilty about that. But certain kinds of guilt are a healthy part of child development.Tina Malti, a professo...
Published: 12/04/17
Updated: 12/07/17
Perspective: Why trying new things is so hard to do

Perspective: Why trying new things is so hard to do

By SENDHIL MULLAINATHANI drink a lot of Diet Coke: 2 liters a day, almost six cansí worth. Iím not proud of the habit, but I really like the taste of Diet Coke.As a frugal economist, Iím well aware that switching to a generic brand would save me mone...
Published: 12/03/17
Updated: 12/07/17