Monday, November 20, 2017
Perspective

PolitiFact: Did Confederate symbols gain prominence in the civil rights era?

RECOMMENDED READING


A major catalyst in the run up to the deadly clashes in Charlottesville, Va., was the city's decision to remove a statue of Confederate Gen. Robert E. Lee.

As the nation reeled from the violence, some political analysts sought to place Confederate symbolism in a broader historical context to help explain the turmoil around the Aug. 11-12 weekend.

"The idea of putting up (Confederate) monuments actually didn't happen right after the Civil War. It happened during the 1960s," MSNBC analyst Joy Reid said on NBC's Meet The Press on Aug. 13.

Reid went on to say that Confederate symbols were political statements aimed at African-Americans.

American history features two periods when Confederate symbolism spiked: around the turn of the 20th century and the civil rights movement of the 1950s and '60s. As a group, most Confederate statues went up in the earlier period.

Early 20th century

A sharp uptick in the construction of Confederate monuments took place from the late 1890s up to about 1920. That's according to a Southern Poverty Law Center study that took a nationwide inventory of the more than 1,500 Confederate symbols in public spaces.

This chart from the study shows the increased pace of construction around the turn of the 20th century, with blue dots signifying monuments on courthouse grounds, red dots indicating other sites (including monuments) and green dots representing schools.

Several cross-currents explain the explosion of Confederate symbolism in this period.

This was an era of generational change during which Civil War veterans, dying of old age, were venerated by their children and grandchildren, experts told us.

"Organizations like the United Daughters of the Confederacy and the Sons of Confederate Veterans came into being," said Charles S. Bullock, III, a professor of public and international affairs at the University of Georgia. "Civil War veterans were honored in parades. There is a Confederate Memorial Day which pre-dates the National Memorial Day."

But as a victorious North fixed its gaze on a prosperous future, the American South was mired in poverty that would persist for generations. The monuments were a way to look back to an idealized past.

"Tributes to the Confederacy — placing statues, naming streets and other public facilities — were part of the Lost Cause ideology that focused on an idyllic era of stately mansions, beautiful women and gallant Confederate officers," Bullock said.

But the monuments also implicitly symbolized slavery and white violence, the experts said.

"On the surface, they were memorials to the Confederacy and their heroes," said Karen L. Cox, a professor of history at the University of North Carolina-Charlotte. "Yet, they were also built during a period of racial violence and strong beliefs about Anglo-Saxon (i.e. white) supremacy."

"The fact that they were placed on the grounds of county and state courthouses was intentional," she added. "The message: white men are in charge."

The period between 1890-World War I saw whites reassert control over the South by enforcing Jim Crow laws, taking control of southern governments and systematically disenfranchising and disempowering African-Americans, said Jonathan Leib, a professor of geography and chair of the department of political science and geography at Old Dominion University.

Racial segregation also got a major endorsement at the federal level during this era. In 1896, the U.S. Supreme Court handed down its landmark decision in Plessy vs. Ferguson which upheld the constitutionality of state laws that racially segregated public facilities that were "separate but equal." (Nearly 60 years passed before the Court would declare such segregation "inherently unequal.")

"This was also a moment when the nation itself began to repair the wounds of the late war by agreeing on the inferiority of African Americans," said Khalil Gibran Muhammad, a professor of history, race and public policy at Harvard Kennedy School. "Racial segregation became the law and custom of the nation at precisely the moment when many of these monuments were built."

Another monument born roughly of this era, a statue of Robert E. Lee installed in Charlottesville in 1924, now figures as a present-day flashpoint.

Civil rights era

The second period when Confederate symbols exploded was the civil rights era.

But it was the Confederate flag — not monuments — that gained prominence during this time, as Reid later clarified in an email to PolitiFact and in a Aug. 15 appearance on MSNBC.

The flag became a symbol of opposition to desegregation.

"It was the choice to fly Confederate flags, more so than the building of new statues, on government property that became a popular show of resistance during the civil rights era," Muhammad said. He added the decision to fly the flag was a clear sign of protest against the federal government's growing enforcement of civil rights.

It was during this era when the Ku Klux Klan came to embrace the Confederate flag, notes the Southern Poverty Law Center.

Our ruling

Reid said, "the idea of putting up (Confederate) monuments actually didn't happen right after the Civil War. It happened during the 1960s." She added that Confederate symbols were political statements aimed at African-Americans.

Reid's comment that Confederate symbols are political statements aimed at African-Americans is backed up by history, say experts.

But she is wrong that Confederate monuments were built during the civil rights era. Roughly 75 percent were erected before then, according to a comprehensive study of Confederate symbolism. It was during the civil rights era that the Confederate flag gained prominence, which she later clarified.

We rate her statement Mostly False.

Read more rulings at PolitiFact.com.

Comments
Oh, Florida! We should all be thankful for the lady accused of shoplifting while dressed as a turkey

Oh, Florida! We should all be thankful for the lady accused of shoplifting while dressed as a turkey

he other day, I had a lovely chat with a lady who was arrested on charges of shoplifting ... while she was dressed as a turkey. I guess you could say that she’s been accused of doing the wrong kind of stuffing.The lady’s name is Irene Leonhard and sh...
Published: 11/16/17
Updated: 11/17/17
Perspective: How the ‘Shalane Flanagan Effect’ works

Perspective: How the ‘Shalane Flanagan Effect’ works

When Shalane Flanagan won the New York City Marathon this month, her victory was about more than just an athletic achievement. Of course, it’s a remarkable one: She’s the first American woman to win in 40 years, and she did so in a blistering 2 hours...
Published: 11/13/17
Updated: 11/17/17
Perspective: A link between alcohol and cancer? It’s not nearly as scary as it seems

Perspective: A link between alcohol and cancer? It’s not nearly as scary as it seems

By AARON E. CARROLLThe headline had some of my friends in a panic.Citing evidence, the American Society of Clinical Oncology warned that even light drinking could increase the risk of cancer.Once again, we’ve been told that something we eat or drink ...
Published: 11/13/17
Updated: 11/17/17
The bridge wobbles. So do you. That’s when the trouble starts.

The bridge wobbles. So do you. That’s when the trouble starts.

Only one countyOut of all America’s 3,141 counties, only one — Howard County, Iowa (population 9,332) — voted by more than 20 percentage points for Obama in 2012 and Trump in 2016, according to FiveThirtyEight.com.The three wealthiest people in the...
Published: 11/09/17
Updated: 11/17/17
PolitiFact: Explaining the Virginia election results

PolitiFact: Explaining the Virginia election results

As late as a few hours before the polls closed on Tuesday night, pundits were thinking Republican Ed Gillespie could pull off an upset in Virginia’s open-seat gubernatorial race.When the votes were tallied, however, they showed that Gillespie’s bid r...
Published: 11/09/17
Organic agriculture can help feed world, but only if we eat less meat and stop wasting food

Organic agriculture can help feed world, but only if we eat less meat and stop wasting food

Mammals were largely creatures of the night until the dinosaurs were killed off by an asteroid some 66 million years ago, a study finds. The findings, described in the journal Nature Ecology & Evolution, illuminate a pivotal transition in the history...
Published: 11/07/17
Updated: 11/17/17
PolitiFact: John Kelly, the Civil War and the slavery compromise that almost was

PolitiFact: John Kelly, the Civil War and the slavery compromise that almost was

he uproar that followed White House chief of staff John Kelly’s comment about the roots of the Civil War stands as Exhibit A of the potential problems that come when an official uses shorthand to talk about the country’s history of slavery. Here is t...
Updated one month ago
Was George Papadopoulos just a ‘volunteer’? PolitiFact reviews the evidence

Was George Papadopoulos just a ‘volunteer’? PolitiFact reviews the evidence

President Donald Trump and prominent allies have repeatedly referred to former campaign aide George Papadopoulos as a mere "volunteer" after news broke that he had pled guilty to lying to the FBI in its Russia investigation.Press Secretary Sarah Huck...
Updated one month ago

Wolves know how to work together

Nearly ½ of Americans told the Pew Research Center that they trust only "some" or "none" of their neighbors.More than ¼of the farmhands in the United States are immigrants working here illegally.The first ninepresidents of Princeton University owned...
Published: 10/31/17
Updated: 11/09/17
Perspective: National Book Award winner says it’s self-interest that leads to racist policies, and then racism

Perspective: National Book Award winner says it’s self-interest that leads to racist policies, and then racism

Ibram X. Kendi was not surprised to see Donald Trump elected president.Unlike many Americans of every political position, Kendi saw the 2016 election not as a shock but as a swing of a historical pendulum he has spent years studying and writing about...
Updated one month ago