Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy) | Tampa Bay Times
Sorting out the truth in politics

PolitiFact: Fact-checking claims on immigration (w/video)

The surge of unaccompanied children at the U.S. border, primarily coming from Honduras, Guatemala and El Salvador, has overwhelmed border security officials and pushed the limits of the U.S. legal system.

That's got elected officials talking about the underlying causes of the influx, as well as what should be done to address it.

PolitiFact has been fact-checking claims on immigration as the debate rages. While a few statements we've checked were verifiable, we also found a number of inaccurate statements. Here's a summary of our recent findings.

Why Central Americans are treated differently

Part of the reason for the large number of children being held at the border is that children from Central American countries can't be sent back as quickly as children from Mexico. There's a legal reason for that, said Rep. Henry Cuellar, D-Texas, on CNN's State of the Union on July 6.

"If you're a Mexican, you get sent back. Mother, kids, adults, you're sent back, but if you're from a noncontiguous country like the Central American countries, then the law says that you are going to be held, (and) Health and Human Services, they're going to place you. That's the law that we need to change right now."

The law he's talking about is the William Wilberforce Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act of 2008. President George W. Bush signed the law after it received bipartisan support in both the House and the Senate, as a measure to combat human trafficking worldwide.

The law lays out one procedure for child immigrants from contiguous countries, like Mexico and Canada. These children are processed for immediate return to their home country. In all other cases, the children are placed under the responsibility of the Secretary of Health and Human Services. These children are placed with family or in other residences while they await their immigration court date. Long story short, they get to stay in the United States.

The law seems to assume that alien children from noncontiguous countries were likely to be the victims of human trafficking, and it guarantees them access to legal counsel and child advocates.

Cuellar and other lawmakers intend to change the law, but Cuellar's description of it as it stands now is accurate. We rated his statement True.

How many children don't show up for hearings later?

A substantial chunk of the $3.7 billion President Barack Obama has requested from Congress for the border would be for increasing the courts' ability to handle the caseload of newly arrived children.

But Sen. Jeff Flake, R-Ariz., said in a July 8 interview on the PBS NewsHour that many children simply never show up for court hearings.

"When these kids are handed off from the Border Patrol, (the government's) role is to actually place those children in the care of a guardian or a family member. And then what the record shows is that they're told to appear later in court, where their case will be adjudicated. But 90 percent of them, 90 percent, do not then show up in court later."

Our research showed that the rate has ranged between 20 percent and 40 percent in recent years, settling in at about 30 percent in 2012, the most recent full year for which data are available. A more recent estimate for children specifically, made by the director of the office responsible for handling such cases, is that the current no-show rate for children is 46 percent.

That's still quite high, but it's only half what Flake said. We rated his claim False.

Projections for future border crossers

Homeland Security Secretary Jeh Johnson said the Obama administration's goal was to stop additional immigration and "stem the tide." Johnson repeatedly refused to say whether most of these unaccompanied minors would be deported during a July 6 interview on Meet the Press.

This led U.S. Rep. Raul Labrador, R-Idaho, to accuse Johnson of "making things up."

"He's saying that he's going to be able to stem it, and it's not going to reach 90,000 or between 60,000 and 90,000 children," Labrador said. "That's not going to happen. The administration's own estimates are that it's going to be about 60,000 to 90,000 this year, that it's going to increase to 150,000 to 200,000 next year. These are their own estimates."

The source for Labrador's numbers was a May 2014 internal memo from Deputy Border Patrol Chief Ronald Vitiello. According to news reports, the memo said that "90,000 minors would be apprehended this year and 142,000 next year."

When the internal memo became public in June, an agency official said it was "an internal, incomplete working document, neither signed nor made official."

A preliminary budget request from the Obama administration assumed increases would continue, but it did not state a particular figure for the number of children and noted that the money needed would change depending on the shifting situation on the ground.

On balance, we rated Labrador's statement Half True.

Charges of 'amnesty'

U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, observed Central American children held at Lackland Air Force Base in Texas. He said border crossings were surging because Obama has offered "amnesty."

"That's the message that's being heard. And the reason these children are coming in staggering numbers is because the president has been promising amnesty," Cruz said.

Cruz was referring to a 2012 Obama administration decision not to deport certain youths living in the country illegally and to the president's repeated praise of a stalled proposal (the Dream Act) that, if passed into law, would give children living here without legal authorization opportunities to seek legal residency and citizenship. But that policy applies only to young people who came to the United States before June 2007.

Experts told us that a more pressing factor was the 2008 law, the one that allowed unaccompanied children entering from countries other than Canada and Mexico to stay here long enough to seek asylum. Additionally, children are fleeing violence in Guatemala, El Salvador and Honduras.

Overall, we rated Cruz's statement False.

PolitiFact Texas editor W. Gardner Selby contributed to this report. Read more at

Los Angeles Times

PolitiFact: Fact-checking claims on immigration (w/video) 07/11/14 [Last modified: Monday, July 14, 2014 6:02pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Trump reveals that he didn't record Comey after all


    WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump declared Thursday he never made and doesn't have recordings of his private conversations with ousted former FBI director James Comey, ending a monthlong guessing game that he started with a cryptic tweet and that ensnared his administration in yet more controversy.

    President Donald Trump said Thursday that he didn’t record his conversations with James Comey.
  2. Lightning fans, don't get attached to your first-round draft picks

    Lightning Strikes

    CHICAGO — When Lightning GM Steve Yzerman announces his first-round pick tonight in the amateur draft at No. 14, he'll invite the prospect onto the stage for the once-in-a-lifetime photo opportunity.

    Tampa Bay Lightning left wing Jonathan Drouin (27) eludes  Montreal Canadiens left wing Phillip Danault (24) during the second period of Wednesday???‚??„?s (12/28/16) game between the Tampa Bay Lightning and the Montreal Canadiens at the Amalie Arena in Tampa.
  3. Investigation Discovery TV show profiles 2011 Landy Martinez murder case


    The murder of a St. Petersburg man will be featured this week on a new true crime series Murder Calls on Investigation Discovery.

    Jose Adame sits in a Pinellas County courtroom during his 2016 trial and conviction for first-degree murder. Adame was convicted of first-degree murder last year for torturing and then executing his boyfriend as he pleaded for his life in 2011. Now it will be featured in a new true crime series Murder Calls on Investigation Discovery. The episode will air on June 26 at 9 p.m. [DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD   |   Times]
  4. Uhuru mayoral candidate Jesse Nevel protests exclusion from debate


    ST. PETERSBURG — Jesse Nevel, the International People’s Democratic Uhuru Movement candidate for mayor, on Thursday demanded that he be allowed to participate in a July 25 televised debate between incumbent Mayor Rick Kriseman and challenger Rick Baker.

    Mayoral candidate Jesse Nevel holds a news conference outside the headquarters of the Tampa Bay Times on Thursday to protest his exclusion from the mayoral debate. Nevel is a member of the International People’s Democratic Uhuru Movement.
  5. Lightning GM Steve Yzerman also has top-9 wing on his wish list

    Lightning Strikes

    CHICAGO — Much has been made about the Lightning's interest in bolstering its blue line, even after last week's acquisition of defense prospect Mikhail Sergachev.

    Tampa Bay Lightning general manager Steve Yzerman gestures as he speaks to the media about recent trades during a news conference before an NHL hockey game against the Carolina Hurricanes Wednesday, March 1, 2017, in Tampa, Fla. The Lightning, over the past few days, have traded goaltender Ben Bishop to the Los Angeles Kings, forward Brian Boyle to the Toronto Maple Leafs, and forward Valtteri Filppula to the Philadelphia Flyers. (AP Photo/Chris O'Meara) TPA101