Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

What Egypt looks like from a cave

Senior members of Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood Saad el-Katatni, right, Mohamed Morsi, center, and Essam el-Erian hold a news conference on the situation in Egypt in Cairo.

Associated Press

Senior members of Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood Saad el-Katatni, right, Mohamed Morsi, center, and Essam el-Erian hold a news conference on the situation in Egypt in Cairo.

The fall of Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak has excited Arabs around the world, giving them hope that democracy can at last flourish in their home countries. The videos of brave and jubilant demonstrators in Cairo's Tahrir Square also probably animate another possible viewer — Osama bin Laden — but in a completely different way.

The master terrorist and his followers are likely to see the earthquake in Egypt as a grave threat to their legitimacy but, at the same time, an opportunity to exploit.

Egypt has always had a special place in the hearts of al-Qaida members. Several of the organization's key leaders and operatives first bloodied themselves in the struggle against the Mubarak regime before finding a home with bin Laden. Bin Laden's deputy, Ayman Zawahiri, led one group, Egyptian Islamic Jihad, which, along with its more important cousin the Islamic Group, staged a bloody uprising in the early 1990s. Calling Mubarak an apostate as well as a despot, the jihadists struck at Coptic Christians, secular Egyptians and foreign tourists as well as regime and security force targets. By the end of the decade, the Mubarak regime had brutally repressed the jihadists and co-opted less radical elements of Egypt's Islamist scene — measures greatly aided by the jihadists' brutal attacks, which alienated most Egyptians. A rump of these fighters joined with bin Laden, taking advantage of the Saudi leader's money and accepting his worldview that the United States, not the government of Egypt, was the primary enemy.

The doctrinal disputes that arose in Egypt, such as the acceptable level of civilian casualties from terrorist attacks and how much deviation from "true" Muslim behavior is acceptable before one becomes an apostate, still roil jihadists today. And the condemnation of al-Qaida by former leaders of the Islamic Group and Egyptian Islamic Jihad has caused great consternation among bin Laden's followers.

With Mubarak out, al-Qaida faces some immediate challenges. The first comes from the Muslim Brotherhood, the Arab world's oldest Islamist organization and a strong force in Egyptian politics today. This may surprise many: Several leading al-Qaida members entered Islamist politics through the Brotherhood; the Brotherhood has at times used violence, such as its unsuccessful 1978-82 war against the Syrian regime, which is also loathed by al-Qaida; and Brotherhood martyrs such as theologian Sayyid Qutb, whom the Egyptian regime hanged in 1966, are revered ideologues for people like Zawahiri.

Yet the relationship between the Brotherhood and the jihadists is notable for the scorn and contempt both sides feel for the other. In his book The Bitter Harvest, Zawahiri excoriates the Brotherhood for renouncing the use of violence against the Mubarak regime and for polluting itself by participating in more mainstream politics. The Palestinian group Hamas, itself a Muslim Brotherhood spinoff, has tried to crush al-Qaida-like groups in Gaza and, in turn, has found itself blasted by the al-Qaida core.

A second challenge comes from the demands of the majority of the demonstrators, who came to Tahrir Square and other rallying points not in the name of Islam but in opposition to tyranny. These protesters' demands fit better with reformers of all stripes around the world: an end to dictatorship, an end to corruption, and a government that reflects the will of the people.

Al-Qaida, however, is virulently antidemocratic; its ideologues fear that governments of the people place man's will above God's and that they might produce anti-Islamic laws (say, permitting the drinking of alcohol). Even more important, al-Qaida feeds on the frustration many Muslims have about their own corrupt and brutal governments. Peaceful revolution in Egypt undermines their message that change will only come through violence.

Yet bin Laden may see opportunities as well as risks. In any successor regime, the hated security services will be purged, and the same men who harassed peaceful dissidents also kept the jihadists down. So pressure against the few jihadists who remain and any who might return may ease.

The transition from Mubarak may be peaceful, but chaos and bloodshed often follow the road that peaceful protesters first walk. Al-Qaida thrives on chaos. In Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan and Somalia it has exploited local issues and worked with local groups to advance its cause. Should Egypt descend into violence, al-Qaida may find a similar niche.

The Muslim Brotherhood's new role also may offer al-Qaida opportunities. If the Brotherhood joins in a transitional government and does not fall prey to its more radical tendencies regarding Israel and Islamicizing Egyptian society (something U.S. policy should strive to accomplish), then the hardliners within its ranks will criticize it for selling out, offering al-Qaida a means to woo them.

But should the Brotherhood lose out in a power struggle or fall prey to repression from the army or a new regime, there will be a new generation of embittered young Islamists who may find al-Qaida's more radical message more convincing than calls for renewed participation in a system that cheated them.

To close off opportunities for al-Qaida and other radical voices, managing the transition from Mubarak to a new government is vital. In the end, the greatest threat to bin Laden and his allies will come from a stable, democratic Egypt that offers its citizens and other Muslims proof that peaceful political activity, not jihad, is how they can better their lives.

Daniel Byman is a professor in the security studies program at Georgetown University and the research director of the Saban Center at the Brookings Institution. His book A High Price: The Triumphs and Failures of Israeli Counterterrorism will be released in April.

What Egypt looks like from a cave 02/12/11 [Last modified: Saturday, February 12, 2011 3:30am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Actor John Heard dies at age 72


    John Heard, who played so many roles in the '80s but was probably best known as the dad in the Home Alone movies, has died, according to media reports. He was 72.

  2. Linkin Park cancel tour, including Tampa concert, after death of singer Chester Bennington


    This news is not a surprise, but it is now official: Linkin Park has canceled their upcoming North American tour following this week's death of singer Chester Bennington.

    Linkin Park's Chester Bennington
  3. Nurse backs Kriseman in St. Pete mayor's race


    Council member Karl Nurse has endorsed Mayor Rick Kriseman.

    St. Petersburg mayor Rick Kriseman, left, is seen with Karl Nurse in the combination of two images.
  4. Spring Hill woman, 24, dies when car hits tree in Pasco County


    LAND O' LAKES — A 24-year-old woman died early Saturday morning after her Hyundai Elantra hit a tree, according to the Florida Highway Patrol.

  5. Florida Insiders: We'll find out soon whether Adam Putnam has a glass jaw


    This month's Florida Insider Poll questions: Who would be the strongest Democratic/Republican nominee for governor? Whom do you expect will win the Democratic/Republican gubernatorial nomination? Which party …

    Florida Insider polls are unscientific surveys of Florida political operatives, money-raisers, lobbyists, political scientists, recovering journalists, activists, and the like