Monday, November 19, 2018
Politics

Romano: Anti-tax bills are ticking political bombs that could blow up our future

You may or may not have noticed, but money has gotten a little tight in Tallahassee.

The hurricanes of last summer were a kick in the budget. President Donald Trump’s recently unveiled infrastructure plan could shift a tremendous financial burden to the state level. Gov. Rick Scott’s school safety plan announced last week means finding another $500 million lying around.

And all of that is on top of the normal scrimping and saving for higher education, health care and a prison system that seems to be teetering on the edge of economic calamity.

So, of course, the proper response is more anti-tax legislation.

Look, I hate paying taxes as much as the next guy. And I have no doubt that too much of our tax money is wasted on bureaucracy and non-essential spending at the state and local levels.

Even as unexpected costs take huge chunks out of the state budget, the first response should always be to look for ways to tighten government spending.

So do we need to raise taxes to meet our bills today?

No.

Might we need to raise taxes at some point in the future?

Yes.

And that’s a problem with legislation that has already passed the House and is scheduled to be considered by the Senate this week.

Lawmakers want to make sure that future legislators cannot raise taxes with something as un-American as a majority vote in the House and Senate. They want to put a constitutional amendment on the November ballot that would require a supermajority vote in the Legislature to raise taxes in the future.

On their way out of office, term-limited leaders are essentially trying to stack the deck against the next generation of politicians.

Now if you lean toward the don’t-tread-on-me point of view, this probably sounds like a good idea. Keep the rascals at bay, and that sort of thing. But if you worry that politics could get in the way of the state providing funds for education, public safety, water supplies, environment and roadways, then this proposed change to the state Constitution sounds a little reckless.

Or, if you prefer, it just sounds like grandstanding.

Scott, who is considering a U.S. Senate run later this year, is in favor of it. House Speaker Richard Corcoran, who is considering a gubernatorial run, is in favor of it. In both cases, it would provide an effective sound bite, even if the ramifications are far more complex.

The version of the amendment passed last month by the House would require a two-thirds vote, which is an extremely high standard to reach, and it would include state fees as well as taxes. The Senate is now discussing a three-fifths vote, and proposes to remove fees from the equation.

Either way, it’s probably worth asking whether this is wise. Or even necessary.

It’s not as if Florida has overburdened taxpayers historically, which probably explains our poor reputation for education. When compared to other states, CNN Money says, Florida is 44th when it comes to the amount of taxes charged to residents. WalletHub says 45th. Forbes says 34th. The point being, no one thinks we’re hammering people with taxes.

So instead of building politicians’ resumes by changing the Constitution, perhaps we should focus more on how to better manage money and fix our budget problems before they get too large.

Comments
Florida Dems hire investigator to look into altered mail ballot ‘cure’ forms

Florida Dems hire investigator to look into altered mail ballot ‘cure’ forms

The move came after reports showed that Democrats planned to send out forms with an incorrect deadline on them to voters whose mail ballots needed fixing.
Updated: 1 hour ago
With victory, Rick Scott joins an exclusive club of Florida politicians

With victory, Rick Scott joins an exclusive club of Florida politicians

Scott becomes the fifth person in Florida to win election for both governor and the U.S. Senate.
Updated: 2 hours ago
Florida recount 2018: Still confused? Read this.

Florida recount 2018: Still confused? Read this.

A handy Q and A to frequent questions about Florida's election recount, which ended Sunday.
Updated: 7 hours ago
PolitiFact Florida: Donald Trump Jr. tweets misleading 2012 headline about Florida noncitizen voters

PolitiFact Florida: Donald Trump Jr. tweets misleading 2012 headline about Florida noncitizen voters

The tweet is not accurate. It’s based on a cherry-picked number.
Updated: 7 hours ago
Oldsmar election draws crowded field

Oldsmar election draws crowded field

Council member Eric Seidel's run for mayor draws three candidates for his open seat.
Published: 11/19/18
Adam Smith column:  Anybody out there feel full confidence in Florida’s election system?

Adam Smith column: Anybody out there feel full confidence in Florida’s election system?

Even before the nearly tied elections, the system's bugs hit home as Smith tried to vote
Updated: 3 hours ago
Brenda Snipes resigns from Broward elections office

Brenda Snipes resigns from Broward elections office

Snipes’ resignation came only hours after her staff ended a brutal two-week stretch of recounts.
Updated: 3 hours ago
Bill Nelson concedes U.S. Senate race to Rick Scott after recount

Bill Nelson concedes U.S. Senate race to Rick Scott after recount

Scott ultimately beat Nelson by 10,033 votes — or about 0.12 percent of the nearly 8.2 million votes cast in the race.
Published: 11/18/18
Palm Beach will be recounting votes through Thanksgiving, maybe Christmas

Palm Beach will be recounting votes through Thanksgiving, maybe Christmas

Even by Florida standards, where the mid-terms have dragged on for nearly two weeks after Election Day, Palm Beach has distinguished itself
Published: 11/18/18
How Nikki Fried won the only statewide office for Democrats

How Nikki Fried won the only statewide office for Democrats

Fried is not just the winner of the cabinet seat, but she also is now the highest-ranking Democrat in the state and the first woman elected to the job.
Published: 11/18/18