Tuesday, November 13, 2018
Politics

Romano: Conservative or liberal, speakers should be heard on college campuses

Letís get this out of the way first:

A Senate bill thatís supposed to promote free speech on university campuses is kind of dopey. At least the way itís currently written.

The bill (SB 1234) would make universities susceptible to lawsuits if a speaker on campus was shouted down by protesters. In effect, it makes universities the enforcers for First Amendment rights.

Considering that the recent climate in Tallahassee has tilted toward less regulation and less spending, it seems curious that a Senate committee would look favorably on a bill that invites more regulation and potentially expensive lawsuits for state schools.

Not to mention, the bill could possibly have the opposite effect of its intent since universities might be inclined to steer clear of controversial speakers because of the potential hassles involved.

Now, having said all of that:

The billís supporters have a point.

The First Amendment has taken a beating lately, and college campuses have provided a lot of the pitchforks and torches. And that seems antithetical to the mission of higher learning.

Just because you do not agree with the views of a speaker does not mean you have the right to silence them. Thatís pretty much the entire basis of this nationís principles.

If you believe in freedom, if you believe in equality, then you must also believe in the rights of someone you adamantly oppose to express their beliefs without fear of being exiled or shouted down.

And yet, time after time, weíre seeing that on college campuses.

In the past few months, the president of the University of North Texas tried unsuccessfully to stop a speech by Donald Trump Jr. The Catholic University of America in Washington, D.C., disinvited a Jesuit priest who has urged the Catholic church to engage in dialogue with the LGBT community. A speech by a conservative state lawmaker at Texas Southern University was canceled after protesters showed up. A question-and-answer session with California Attorney General Xavier Becerra at Whittier College was canceled when hecklers in "Make America Great Againíí hats loudly interrupted the program.

And a speech by white nationalist Richard Spencer was disrupted by protesters at the University of Florida in October. I will argue all day long that Spencer is a small-minded twit, but I will also argue that the people who interrupted his speech have no claim to the moral high ground.

"Free speech only works when peopleís rights are respected regardless of their viewpoints,íí said Joe Cohn, the legislative and policy director for the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE).

Cohnís organization, which includes funding from some major conservative groups, has successfully gotten similar legislation passed in other states and generally supports the Florida bill.

The problem is the Florida bill goes further than others.

Instead of just mandating that universities cannot limit First Amendment activity to designated "free speech zonesíí ó and even the left-leaning ACLU agrees with FIRE on that idea ó the bill proposed by Sen. Dennis Baxley, R-Ocala, also wants campuses to be responsible for controlling protesters.

The problem with that idea is not political, but practical.

The Spencer speech, for instance, drew thousands of people in opposition. Gainesville and UF police did a marvelous job of keeping the peace, but were hard-pressed to stop protesters from interrupting Spencer. And it would have been a nightmare to figure out how many protesters were UF students, and how many were simply outraged citizens.

This doesnít mean universities should abdicate their role in promoting a safe and open discourse on campus, but the Legislature does not need to dangle an economic sword over their heads either.

Sadly, but predictably, the bill passed a Senate committee on Tuesday along partisan lines. Cohn agrees the billís language could use some tweaking and is hopeful of bridging that gap in the coming days.

Meanwhile, you might want to consider what happened at UCLA recently and consider the problems universities are facing in these polarized times.

The school put together a panel of experts to discuss a pressing issue, but the event was interrupted by protesters and had to be moved to a different venue.

The topic?

A discussion on free speech.

Comments
Palm Beach County gets recount extension from judge

Palm Beach County gets recount extension from judge

The online docket suggests a Tallahassee judge entered an order Tuesday afternoon ďsuspending certain deadlines.Ē The judge, Karen Gievers, also allowed Sen. Bill Nelson, who is locked in a tight race for his Senate seat with Gov. Rick Scott , to intervene in the case.
Updated: 4 hours ago
Will Gov. Rick Scott certify an election that he claims is fraudulent? He wonít say.

Will Gov. Rick Scott certify an election that he claims is fraudulent? He wonít say.

The Elections Canvassing Commission is set to meet Tuesday. Sen. Bill Nelson is saying he should recuse himself from it.
Updated: 4 hours ago
Bill Nelson and Democrats file three new election lawsuits

Bill Nelson and Democrats file three new election lawsuits

The legal workload is rapidly multiplying for judges in federal court in Tallahassee.
Updated: 5 hours ago
Broward finally begins its recount as new lawsuits seek to extend deadline

Broward finally begins its recount as new lawsuits seek to extend deadline

As Broward County began to recount ballots from the midterm elections, candidates filed new lawsuits seeking to extend the deadline for the process
Updated: 5 hours ago
Rick Scottís campaign sues Hillsborough County Supervisor of Elections

Rick Scottís campaign sues Hillsborough County Supervisor of Elections

The campaign is alleging that election observers were forced to watch recounts from another room.
Updated: 6 hours ago
A woman went to Mexico for a cheap nose job. Now she's in a coma and might never wake up.

A woman went to Mexico for a cheap nose job. Now she's in a coma and might never wake up.

A Texas woman decided to get a nose job in Mexico instead of the United States because it was much cheaper -- just $138.But now she is on life support after the procedure went terribly wrong. Her family has been told that they can either remove her f...
Updated: 6 hours ago
A wrong-way driver slammed into her on the Howard Frankland Bridge. She's alive and grateful.

A wrong-way driver slammed into her on the Howard Frankland Bridge. She's alive and grateful.

Andrea Rusch, a 24-year-old bartender at Ferg's Sports Bar and Grill in St. Petersburg, has undergone three surgeries but is expected to be discharged from St. Joseph's Hospital this week.
Updated: 9 hours ago
'Game of Thrones' returns in April 2019 - here's what we know so far about the final season

'Game of Thrones' returns in April 2019 - here's what we know so far about the final season

We finally know exactly when to expect winter to come.HBO announced Tuesday that their hugely popular series "Game of Thrones" will premiere in April 2019 for what will be its eighth and final season.But before you get excited about a new t...
Updated: 9 hours ago
Pilots saw a 'very bright' UFO streaking over Ireland. If it wasn't aliens, what was it?

Pilots saw a 'very bright' UFO streaking over Ireland. If it wasn't aliens, what was it?

By Cleve R. Wootson Jr.Washington PostThe confused person on the radio was not someone typically associated with dodgy reports of extraterrestrial interaction. There were no claims that large-eyed green men crossed the cosmos to turn livestock inside...
Updated: 10 hours ago
Brenda Snipes says Ďit is time to move oní

Brenda Snipes says Ďit is time to move oní

Her current term runs through 2020.
Updated: 10 hours ago