Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Closed primaries cry out for voter reform

They won't have a voice in the decision.

Not really.

On Aug. 26, the Supervisor of Elections Office will tally the votes in the Republican primary race for Hillsborough County Commission District 4. The winner will be all but assured of taking control of the position for the next four years.

But more than 60 percent of the registered voters in that district won't have the chance to influence the outcome.

Even though they may be super voters — people who vote in every election — they won't get to cast a vote in this particular race. Even though they may care greatly about the decisions that impact their subdivisions, their neighborhoods and their communities, they will have no say on who will be their next county commissioner.

The Republican primary victor — either Rick Cochran, Janet Dougherty or Stacy White — will simply have to defeat write-in candidate Christopher Lawrence Weaver in the general election to take the office. That is a simple task. Write-in candidates never win.

But because of Weaver's entry into the race, the law closes the primary election to Democratic and independent voters. In District 4, that's 64,888 Democrats, 45,928 independents and another 7,302 voters under the category of "other," according to statistics from the county elections supervisor.

Talk about voter suppression.

As Tampa Bay Times staff writer Michael Van Sickler noted in a recent story, this isn't limited to one race or a single party.

In State House District 64, 44,670 Democrats and independents (59 percent) will get shut out of the race between Jamie Grant and Miriam Steinberg, thanks to write-in candidate Daniel Johnson Matthews

In State House District 61, 31,062 Republicans and independents (a little less than 35 percent) will be shut out of a race featuring four Democrats — Sharon Carter, Tatiana Denson, Ed Narain and Shawn Shaw — because another little-known candidate, Nicole Santiago, has launched a write-in campaign.

Don't call this a technicality. This is election strategy by crafty consultants who find near-anonymous citizens to enter the races and create closed primaries. Sadly, it's standard operating procedure in Florida politics. Strategists criticize a party for not closing a primary instead of questioning the entire process.

The answer isn't getting the parties to field candidates who have little chance of winning. The answer is open primaries. By allowing all interested voters to exercise their rights, candidates would have to craft campaigns with broader appeal. Once in office, they would have to build a record with broader appeal.

Is it possible that our nation grows more divided and our government gets more dysfunctional because between gerrymandered districts and this kind of election trickery we're electing candidates who only have to appeal to the extreme sides in each party?


There must be a better way. The closed primary approach cries out for election reform.

If members of the suffrage movement fought to give voting rights to women, if civil rights workers died so blacks couldn't be denied, if the men and women of our military fight to protect our freedoms, we can't allow a large voting bloc to be shut out because of partisan gamesmanship and political high jinks.

That's all I'm saying.

.by the numbers

Hillsborough County Commission, District 4

Number of registered voters: 192,928

Number of registered Republicans: 74,810

Number of registered Democrats: 64,888

Number of registered independents/others: 53,230

State House District 61

Number of registered voters: 89,233

Number of registered Democrats: 58,171

Number of registered Republicans: 10,326

Number of registered independents/others: 20,736

State House District 64

Number of registered voters: 75,687

Number of registered Republicans: 31,017

Number of registered Democrats: 23,527

Number of indpendents/others: 21,143

Closed primaries cry out for voter reform 06/26/14 [Last modified: Thursday, June 26, 2014 10:06am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. 'Deadliest Catch' captain talks reality TV, Snoop Dogg and Tampa Bay


    Keith Colburn is best known as captain of the Wizard on the Discovery Network series Deadliest Catch. Colburn and crew go to battle in the Bering Sea working one of the deadliest jobs in America. A seasoned veteran, Keith has filmed 11 seasons of the show and is still going strong with his relief captain …

    Captain Keith Colburn is seen in this undated photo courtesy of the Discovery Channel. Courtesy of the Discovery Channel
  2. Police: Video shows teens watching, laughing as man drowns


    COCOA — Authorities in Florida say a group of teens watched and laughed as a man drowned in a retention pond last week.

    Jamel Dunn drowned in a retention pond in the city of Cocoa on July 9. Cocoa police say they later discovered a group of teens recorded the 31-year-old's drowning on video. [Florida Today]
  3. As Rubio avoids public settings on health care, disabled Tampa man's story gets attention


    Michael Phillips was hunting demons Monday night when the news broke: The Senate health care bill was dying.

    Michael Phillips at home in Tampa with his mother, Karen Clay
  4. Shark Week 2017: Michael Phelps races a shark and other must-see specials


    It's that time of year again. No, not back to school month or geek convention season -- it's Shark Week.

    For almost 30 years, Discovery Channel has brought a full week of special programs on the toothy underwater predators through Shark Week.
  5. HomeTeam 100: Players 51-60


    TAMPA - Wharton defensive back AJ Hampton will help lead the Wildcats into the 2017 season. Taken 7-6-17 by Scott Purks