Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Lawsuit accuses U.S. Rep. Vern Buchanan of shenanigans at Pasco car lot

U.S. Rep. Vern Buchanan is one of the richest men in Congress thanks in part to his car dealerships.

But those businesses have also made the Sarasota Republican the target of lawsuits in his own county. Ex-employees allege that his dealerships fabricated tax returns, falsified incomes to get loan applications approved and "powerbooked" — faked options to pump up the sales price.

Now those same allegations have been made against Buchanan's dealership in Pasco County: Suncoast Ford Mitsubishi on U.S. 19 in Port Richey.

The congressman's dealership bilked customers, employees and even Ford Motor Co. in a relentless drive to sell cars, according to the suit filed Aug. 13 in Pinellas-Pasco Circuit Court.

The lawsuit was filed by Tallahassee attorney Douglas Lyons. He's the attorney in the other six lawsuits against Buchanan dealerships and said he is planning to file five more similar suits, including one more in Pasco County.

"There were just a lot of things that took place that were not legal and ethical," said Scott Russ, 43, a former employee and the plaintiff in the Pasco suit. He's seeking unspecified lost wages and damages.

Russ said he was the Port Richey dealership's finance director for two years until August 2006. That's when Russ said he was fired because he never took part in the alleged scheme.

Buchanan's business partner denied anything illicit took place at any of the dealerships.

"They're absolutely false statements," Darrin Chrisman, the operating partner of Buchanan's Sarasota Ford dealership, said of the lawsuit's allegations.

• • •

According to the Pasco lawsuit, "the business plan at the dealership is set up in order to deceive consumers (and) defeat the law. Not only were the consumers ripped off but the employees were also ripped off."

The dealership padded the bottom line of the owners, the suit said, but left customers without the extras they paid for, left lenders with falsified documents and left employees without the commissions that they had earned.

In the suit Russ said he was "cheated" out of $5,000 to $6,000 in commissions each month — totaling more than $100,000.

"When complaints came in the standard practice was to deny any culpability on the part of the dealership," the suit said. "When faced with a lawsuit the dealership would destroy incriminating documents in the shredder."

Russ said in August 2005 a salesman cursed and threatened him for stopping a questionable sale. A Pasco sheriff's report showed the dealership reported the incident to deputies.

• • •

Chrisman, the congressman's business partner, said Buchanan is a major shareholder in the dealerships but is not an active partner in the businesses.

Buchanan is in his first term as the U.S. representative from District 13, serving Sarasota, Manatee, Hardee and DeSoto counties. Democrat Christine Jennings disputed his 2006 win for months. She's running against him again, and again controversy has found Buchanan.

The lawsuits filed in Sarasota County make allegations not included in the Pasco suit: that employees were told to contribute to Buchanan's congressional campaign. The employees said the dealership then reimbursed them for their contributions.

That would be illegal, and on Tuesday the Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington filed a complaint with the Federal Election Commission against the congressman for "serious violations of campaign finance law."

Russ said he and other employees at the Port Richey dealership were leaned on by management to donate to the campaign. "I was pressured many times," Russ said, but he never donated.

He recalled that management once called a meeting of employees to exhort them to contribute.

"We were in some kind of contest," Russ said. … "We needed to beat the other stores in contributions."

Buchanan has denied these allegations in the past. So did his campaign when contacted this week by the St. Petersburg Times.

"It's the campaign's policy that all contributions fully comply with FEC regulations," said campaign spokeswoman Sally Tibbetts. "No one on the campaign has advised anyone to make improper donations, and those allegations are an issue between the businesses and their employees."

Times researcher Shirl Kennedy contributed to this report. Jamal Thalji can be reached at or (727) 869-6236.

Lawsuit accuses U.S. Rep. Vern Buchanan of shenanigans at Pasco car lot 08/21/08 [Last modified: Wednesday, August 27, 2008 4:59pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Tampa Bay homes values continue to rise along with sales prices

    Real Estate

    For the second month in a row, Tampa Bay had one of the highest year -over-year increases in home values in May, Zillow reported today.

    For the second month in a row, Tampa Bay had one of the highest year -over-year increases in home values in May, Zillow reported Thursday.
[Times file photo]
  2. Busy start has Florida Hospital Center Ice dreaming big


    WESLEY CHAPEL — Opening day brought 600 doctors, administrators and their families from Florida Hospital. Soon after that, the facility hosted its first junior league game and a collegiate showdown. A few weeks later, 200 kids, ages 4 to 9, participated in national Learn to Play Hockey Day.

    Alex Senushkin and his grandson, Styopa Kulshyn, 3, of Lakeland, skate at the Florida Hospital Center Ice rink in Wesley Chapel.
[CHARLIE KAIJO   |   Times]

  3. Charlie Crist calls for national day of civility


    WASHINGTON – A week after a gunman opened fire on a group of Republicans, Rep. Charlie Crist this morning called for the establishment of a national day of civility, saying “the need for action could not be more urgent.”

    A note from Rep. Charlie Crist
  4. NBA draft: Jonathan Isaac could make FSU history tonight


    Florida State forward Jonathan Isaac will probably hear his name called early in tonight's NBA draft.

  5. Qatar Airways seeks to buy a stake in American Airlines


    NEW YORK — State-owned Qatar Airways is attempting to buy a 10 percent stake in American Airlines, triggering U.S. antitrust oversight of deals that size.

    In this file photo, a new Qatar Airways Airbus A350 approaches the gate at the airport in Frankfurt, Germany. Qatar Airways is attempting to buy a 10 percent stake in American Airlines, triggering U.S. antitrust oversight over deals of such size. 
[AP file photo]