Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

PolitiFact Florida | Tampa Bay Times
Sorting out the truth in state politics

PolitiFact Florida: Scott failing to deliver on tough immigration promises

Rick Scott promised voters in 2010 that he would bring an Arizona-style immigration law to Florida.

The pledge — repeated over and over in television and radio advertisements — helped Scott both win over conservatives who didn't know the first-time candidate and expose his Republican primary opponent Bill McCollum as an immigration flip-flopper.

But with two legislative sessions in the books, Scott hasn't just failed to pass an Arizona law, parts of which were overturned by the U.S. Supreme Court on Monday.

He has stopped talking about it.

PolitiFact Florida is tracking 57 of Scott's promises on the Scott-O-Meter, including promises to implement Arizona-style legislation and a requirement that Florida businesses use a federal database to make sure their employees are in the country legally.

Both are rated Promise Broken.

"He got the majority of the vote for running on those promises," said Bill Landes, a Lake Wales tea party supporter and chairman of the Florida Minutemen Organization. "And now for him to do an about-face, it's like a heart-wrenching stab in the back for the citizens who helped elect him."

The Legislature in 2011 attempted but failed to pass a requirement that businesses use the federal E-Verify system to check the immigration status of their workers.

Lawmakers never seriously considered the idea in 2012, and Scott all but said he opposed a statewide requirement recently, saying he didn't want to put Florida businesses at a disadvantage.

An Arizona-style law, meanwhile, has never been voted on by the full Legislature.

Scott was not specific about immigration policies when asked for his reaction to the Supreme Court decision.

"I haven't seen that decision," Scott said. "I still believe the federal government ought to secure our borders. They ought to have a national immigration policy and take responsibility for this. I think the states have had to respond because the federal government hasn't.

"We need to have an immigration policy that Americans understand, and those who want to come to our country understand. And we shouldn't be putting our Florida businesses or American business at an economic disadvantage because we don't have a well-defined work visa plan that makes sense."

Advocates for immigrants say Scott is following a national trend of states stepping back from harsh enforcement measures.

"Responsible, pragmatic Republicans in a lot of states are seeing what happened in states that went with all-out enforcement," said Tamar Jacoby, president of ImmigrationWorks USA.

Floridians for Immigration Enforcement, an activist group that endorsed Scott based on his strong pledges to crack down on illegal immigration, isn't happy with the governor's changing rhetoric.

"He never campaigned on this phony-baloney guest worker program," said David Caulkett, vice president and founder. "That wasn't part of his campaign." (Scott has earned a Promise Kept on the Scott-O-Meter for opposing "amnesty" for illegal immigrants.)

Caulkett said he believes that Scott was swayed from his hard-and-fast campaign position by business interests, and he doubts that Scott will press the issue while in office.

It's a far cry from the 2010 campaign, when Scott hammered McCollum for his evolving stance on the Arizona law.

McCollum initially called the law "far out." Then he said he liked it with an amendment that aimed to prevent racial profiling, though he said Florida didn't need it. In July 2010, McCollum joined seven states opposing the federal government's lawsuit against the Arizona law. Weeks before the primary, McCollum touted a draft of the law that he wanted applied in Florida.

Scott toned down the immigration talk in the general election against Democrat Alex Sink.

Now he hardly talks about it at all.

Katie Sanders can be reached at

Promise: Bring Arizona's immigration law to Florida

Promise: Require all Florida employers to use E-Verify system

Promise: Bring Arizona's immigration law to Florida

Promise: Require all Florida employers to use E-Verify system

PolitiFact Florida: Scott failing to deliver on tough immigration promises 06/26/12 [Last modified: Tuesday, June 26, 2012 11:08pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. University student accused of making bomb threat on Snapchat


    DELAND — A Florida university student is accused of making threats on Snapchat to "bomb" or "gas" the campus.

    Stetson University freshman Griffin Powell, 18, is accused of making threats on Snapchat to "bomb" or "gas" the campus in DeLand.

  2. Tiki Barber will join his brother, Ronde, on Fox broadcast for Bucs-Giants


    FOX announced Monday night that former Bucs cornerback Ronde Barber will have a familiar face joining him as a guest analyst for the Oct. 1 Bucs-Giants game in Tampa: his twin brother Tiki, who will join …

    Tiki Barber, right, will join his brother, Ronde, left, as a guest analyst on the Oct. 1 Bucs-Giants broadcast on FOX. [Times files (2006)]
  3. Cannons will fire again when Bucs return to Raymond James Stadium


    As good as the Bucs looked in their season-opening 29-7 win against the Bears on Sunday, fans couldn't help but notice that the success didn't sound the same at Raymond James Stadium.

     Ron Gutschmidt is perched on top of the Buccaneer pirate ship ready to activate the ship's cannons with the press of a button after a Buccaneer touchdown. [LUIS SANTANA | Times]
  4. Rick and Tom podcast: How should Joe Maddon be remembered tonight?

    The Heater

    Rick Stroud and Tom Jones talk about Joe Maddon's return to Tropicana Field for the first time since he left the Rays in 2014 in the latest edition of our Rick and Tom podcast. They discuss the mixed emotions …

    Joe Maddon returns to Tropicana Field tonight for the first time since he left the Rays in 2014. [Getty Images]
  5. Watch live: President Trump's speech to the U.N. General Assembly


    UNITED NATIONS — U.S. President Donald Trump and French leader Emmanuel Macron are expected to take the spotlight at the annual gathering of world leaders at the United Nations — but it's the tough global challenges from the nuclear threat in North Korea and the plight of Myanmar's minority Muslims to the …

    President Donald Trump shakes hands with French President Emmanuel Macron during a meeting at the Palace Hotel during the United Nations General Assembly, Monday, Sept. 18, 2017, in New York. [Associated Press]