Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

State Sen. Alan Hays' case of foot-in-mouth disease

State Sen. Alan Hays is a retired dentist, so it's surprising to see him stick his foot in his mouth.

But Hays wandered into a political minefield with recent comments about Hispanics and redistricting.

At the end of a 2½-hour meeting last week, the Republican spoke about the likelihood of a new Hispanic-majority seat in Congress representing Orange and Osceola counties, south of where he lives in Umatilla.

"Before we design a district anywhere in the state of Florida for Hispanic voters, we need to ascertain that they are citizens of the United States," Hays said. "We all know there are many Hispanic-speaking people in Florida that are not legal, and I just don't think that it's right that we try to draw a district that encompasses people that really have no business voting anyhow."

His comments brought denunciations from two Hispanic House members, Democrats Luis Garcia of Miami Beach and Janet Cruz of Tampa, who accused Hays of being prejudiced against Hispanics.

Reached Monday, Hays declined to say anything more about the subject, not wanting to add more fuel to the fire.

This is not the first time Hays' mouth has landed him in trouble.

In a tense 2009 legislative floor debate on property insurance, he wagged a finger at then-Rep. Adam Hasner and said, "That's bullcrap!" It was great blog fodder.

In 2007, on the subject of an anti-bullying law, a group of students said Hays told them gay students needed psychological treatment.

On redistricting, Hays surely was speaking for some of his constituents. But he should have known better for three reasons.

First, many Hispanic newcomers to Osceola during the past decade are Puerto Ricans who are U.S. citizens by birth. That county is now 45 percent Hispanic, and Orange County is 19 percent Hispanic.

Second, the mandate for creation of political districts of equal population includes noncitizens. The census requires counting all "whole persons," including children, homeless people, nursing home patients and prison inmates. People who can't vote are still entitled to political representation.

Third, Hays and other Republican lawmakers voted last spring to rewrite the election laws, citing the need to stop election fraud (which rarely occurs).

The law is under attack by opponents in the courts and parts are under review by federal judges.

Hays stood on the Senate floor in April and said the state needed to pass the bill to eliminate "activities that might be fraudulent to occur in our system of voting."

It's true that people are not required to show proof of citizenship to become Florida voters. They affirm under oath that they are citizens, and the state double-checks that.

Hays' district includes part of Seminole County, where Supervisor of Elections Mike Ertel says the chance of a noncitizen getting a voter card is slim because the main form of ID that Florida uses to verify identity is a driver's license, which requires proof of citizenship.

Asked if noncitizens try to break the law, Ertel said: "We have not seen any."

Maybe Sen. Hays should have a little more faith in the people who run elections in Florida.

Steve Bousquet can be contacted at or (850) 224-7263.

State Sen. Alan Hays' case of foot-in-mouth disease 10/24/11 [Last modified: Tuesday, October 25, 2011 11:18am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. 'I ain't fit to live': Police say Mississippi gunman kills 8


    BROOKHAVEN, Miss. — A man who got into an argument with his estranged wife and her family over his children was arrested Sunday in a house-to-house shooting rampage in rural Mississippi that left eight people dead, including his mother-in-law and a sheriff's deputy.

    People embrace Sunday outside the Bogue Chitto, Miss., house where eight people were killed during a shooting rampage Saturday in Lincoln County, Miss.
  2. Kushner's Russia ties questioned as Trump cites media 'lies'


    WASHINGTON — Congressional Democrats on Sunday demanded to hear directly from top White House adviser Jared Kushner over allegations of proposed secret back-channel communications with Russia, saying the security clearance of President Donald Trump's son-in-law may need to be revoked.

  3. Muslims thankful for support after rant, deadly attack


    PORTLAND, Ore. — Muslims in Portland, Ore., thanked the community for its support and said they were raising money for the families of two men who were killed when they came to the defense of two young women — one wearing a hijab — who were targeted by an anti-Muslim rant.

    Jeremy Christian is accused of killing 2 men who stepped in as he berated two women.
  4. Following Trump's trip, Merkel says Europe can't rely on U.S. anymore


    LONDON — German Chancellor Angela Merkel on Sunday declared a new chapter in U.S.-European relations after contentious meetings with President Donald Trump last week, saying that Europe "really must take our fate into our own hands."

    German Chancellor Angela Merkel, shown speaking with President Trump last week, says Europe “must take our fate into our own hands.”
  5. Seven children, 1 to 10, seriously injured when driver loses control on I-4


    TAMPA — Seven young passengers 1 to 10 years old were seriously injured when the driver of a Chevrolet Suburban lost control, causing the vehicle to flip and hit a fence on Interstate 4 just east of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard, the Florida Highway Patrol said.