Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

The truth of attack ads

TALLAHASSEE — One Republican consultant calls the political attack ads between Republican Rick Scott and Democrat Alex Sink the best political show on television. Viewers call those same ads annoying, while campaigns call them crucial.

But the aggressive verbal air war between the candidates for governor waged on Florida's cable channels says more about the candidates than their campaign strategies. It also reveals a bit of decisionmaking style.

"A campaign is a reflection of the candidate," said Darrell West, a political scientist at the Brookings Institution and author of Air Wars: Television Advertising in Election Campaigns. "If somebody is shading the truth during the campaign, there's a good chance they'll do the same thing in public office."

In the past week, the race for governor got uglier as each side unleashed two of the harshest ads yet aimed at taking down the other — and a new poll shows the ads are working.

Scott's ads are more aggressive, "but he is the lesser known candidate and has to be more aggressive," said Frank Luntz, a Virginia-based Republican media consultant.

Of the six ads Scott has launched since the primary, four attempt to damage Sink by reviving old accusations ripped from newspapers or new allegations discovered by his opposition research machine.

Two of Scott's ads analyzed by PolitiFact Florida, a fact-checking project of the St. Petersburg Times and Miami Herald, were rated Barely True. Only one of Sink's ads has been analyzed so far and PolitiFact Florida rated it Mostly True.

Brian Burgess, a media consultant for Scott's campaign, said the campaign stands by the truthfulness of its ads. "We find sources that can factually verify what we say in an ad," he said. "The challenge is to boil a complex story into a 30-second TV ad, and that is not easy to do."

Scott has released four attack ads since the primary, including two last week that focused on Sink's role as a member of the three-person State Board of Administration. They attempt to paint a picture of her, the state's chief financial officer, as a failed fiscal watchdog.

Sink has released eight ads since the primary. Four attempt to both slam Scott and explain Sink. They open with Sink talking to the camera with a claim against Scott — such as questioning his integrity or asking why he "thinks running for governor is all about President Obama" — and then Sink uses the statement to contrast her record with his.

Sink's latest two ads highlight Scott's refusal to testify in a deposition after his former hospital company, Columbia/HCA, paid a record $1.7 billion federal fine.

Only Sink appears on camera when she's throwing stones. Scott leaves the mudslinging to others, relying on an announcer to lob charges that Sink "was in charge of Florida's investments" when it lost money in the stock market.

Sink, by contrast, has been less direct with her allegations and less willing to unleash new charges. Until this week, she strung together newspaper and television accounts of Scott's company federal fine and this week brought more firepower: testimonials of law enforcement and prosecutors who claim Scott can't be trusted.

Both candidates walk a delicate line as they weave their message into Florida's airwaves. They must avoid coming across as too negative and make sure they don't damage their own carefully crafted images. Because Sink has run for statewide office only once before and this is Scott's first campaign, both have had to introduce themselves to voters while bashing their opponent.

"Voters are smarter than many political professionals give them credit for; voters generally have good radar for separating fact from fiction," said Rich Davis, Sink's media consultant. But it's also true, he said, that "voters retain negative information more readily than positive."

It's a balance that Luntz — the Republican consultant — believes both Sink and Scott have done better than any other candidates in the nation.

"Alex Sink is running the best advertising campaign of any Democratic gubernatorial candidate in the country," he said. "Her ads are apolitical — she's running against the establishment and you can't really tell if she's a Democrat or a Republican."

Luntz also has high praise for Scott, saying, "He owes his entire nomination to his effective ads" and he continues an effective media campaign.

The negative ads have served their intended purpose for Scott. In a Mason-Dixon poll of likely voters conducted Oct. 4-6, Sink's unfavorable rating increased 10 percentage points in the past week. Polls this week will show how effective Sink's ads have been against Scott.

"When you have negatives like Rick Scott has, the only way you win is to raise the negatives on your opponent and then hope the higher Republican turnout will throw you over the top," said Brad Coker, Mason-Dixon's pollster.

West of the Brookings Institution said because voters now get their information from all kinds of media — not just newspapers and television — "there seems to be less accountability in the process, and it's harder to tell truth from fiction."

But Coker warns: "There is a point of diminishing returns. When people say: 'God, I'm tired of seeing this commercial.' "

The truth of attack ads 10/09/10 [Last modified: Saturday, October 9, 2010 8:11pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Can the Bad Boys Mowers Gasparilla Bowl thrive in competitive sports market?

    Business

    ST. PETERSBURG — It's a funky name: the Bad Boys Mowers Gasparilla Bowl. But the new sponsors for the former St. Petersburg Bowl might need more than an eye-catching name to create a thriving, profitable contest.

    NC State head coach Dave Doeren clutches the championship trophy after winning the Bitcoin Bowl at Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg in 2014. Bowl organizers are changing the name of the game to the Bad Boy Mowers Gasparilla Bowl.
[

MONICA HERNDON | TIMES]
  2. Dirk Koetter says Bucs used team meeting to discuss social issues

    Bucs

    Four days before their preseason home opener against the Cleveland Browns, which had 12 players not stand for the national anthem prior to their last game, the Bucs used their team meeting to discuss social issues that might have led to that demonstration, coach Dirk Koetter said.

    "The main thing is we have to respect everybody's opinion," Dirk Koetter said, "because everybody is not going to agree." [AP photo]
  3. Rookie tight end Antony Auclair making case to stick with Bucs

    Bucs

    Don't let his modest preseason stats fool you: Antony Auclair, the undrafted rookie tight end from Canada is making a strong case to stick around on the Bucs' 53-man roster this season.

    Bucs tight end Antony Auclair (82) collides with a defender following a catch during training camp. [CHARLIE KAIJO   |   Times]
  4. Who is that 'Blacks for Trump' guy standing behind the president at his Phoenix rally

    National

    At a number of political rallies over the last two years, a character calling himself "Michael the Black Man" has appeared in the crowd directly behind Donald Trump, impossible to miss and possibly planted.

    Michael the Black Man, variously known as Michael Symonette, Maurice Woodside and Mikael Israel, holds up a sign as President Donald Trump speaks to a crowd at the Phoenix Convention Center during a rally on Tuesday in Phoenix, Arizona.  [Ralph Freso | Getty Images]
  5. Off-duty Manatee County deputy saves couple from burning car

    Public Safety

    MANATEE COUNTY — Neil and Claudia Cook are lucky to be alive after an off-duty deputy spotted them trapped in their smoking car and rescued them just before it became engulfed in flames on …

    Neil and Claudia Cook were trapped in their smoking car on Sunday when an off-duty deputy kicked out the window, rescuing them just before the car became engulfed in flames. [Courtesy of Manatee County Sheriff's Office]