Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

PolitiFact Florida | Tampa Bay Times
Sorting out the truth in state politics

Fact-checking dueling claims in the Brande/Frishe state Senate primary

TAMPA — Two sitting state House members, Jeff Brandes and Jim Frishe, are duking it out for the Republican nomination in state Senate District 22.

And both men have third-party groups coming to their aid.

The group Committee to Protect Florida claims in a new mailer that Brandes voted in the House to allow state-run Citizens Property Insurance to dump policies onto "out-of-state, unregulated private companies."

Accountability in Government counters in a TV ad that Frishe wanted to "tax us for doing our taxes" through an accountant.

PolitiFact Florida decided to check out both claims ahead of the Aug. 14 primary. (District 22 covers southern Pinellas County and parts of Hillsborough County including South Tampa, East Tampa and Seminole Heights.)

We'll start with the claim attacking Brandes, which centers on one of the diciest issues of the 2012 legislative session. The measure (HB 245) would have allowed "surplus lines" companies to take over Citizens policies in an effort to shrink the company. These companies, which Democrats likened to vultures, are not overseen by the state Office of Insurance Regulation and usually have higher premiums.

Many Republicans, including Gov. Rick Scott, say Citizens would be overexposed should a calamitous storm hit the state. Put simply, Scott and others say that Citizens does not have the ability to pay out claims in the event of the storm, which would leave the state in a disastrous position. So they think it's better to move policyholders to other, more stable companies, they say, even if it means higher premiums.

Supporters of the bill pointed to a few consumer-minded safeguards, such as requiring companies to have at least $50 million in surplus and the financial strength to withstand two hurricanes. Opponents said homeowners would be out of luck should such a company became insolvent, though, because it would not be covered by the Florida Insurance Guaranty Association.

The version that passed a full vote of the House on Feb. 3 would have automatically moved policyholders to a surplus lines company if they did not opt out within 30 days notice.

The House approved the measure 66-48. Brandes voted Yes.

But that's not the entire story.

When the Senate later considered the proposal, it altered the bill to be more consumer-friendly. The Senate made the measure "opt-in," meaning a consumer had to proactively approve the switch with a signature.

Supporters of the original proposal argued that the change would gut the intent of the bill: to reduce the number of policies held by Citizens. And when the amended bill bounced back to the House, Republican members proposed to reject the opt-in provision and kick the bill back to the Senate.

But that idea failed in the closest House vote of the session.

This time Brandes essentially switched sides, voting against blocking the Senate's opt-in amendment (put another way, in favor of the opt-in requirement.)

The sponsor of the original bill then killed the proposal, since it had an opt-in requirement. On balance, we rated Brandes' claim Mostly True.

The claim against Frishe, meanwhile, goes all the way back to 1987, when Frishe was serving his first stint in the state House.

The plan to tax accountant services was part of a much broader proposal to create a sales tax on services.

The idea was to broaden the state's tax base, Frishe explained. There was no recession that year; rather, Florida's economy was booming. Still, the state needed money to fix roads and pay for an influx of new public school students.

To do that, the Legislature passed a 5 percent sales tax on many personal and professional services, including accountants' fees, agricultural services, house-building, architect and engineering fees, pest control, cleaning services, computer and data processing, advertising, legal fees, magazine and newspaper subscriptions and newspaper rack sales, pet-grooming and cleaning services.

Frishe voted in favor of creating the tax in April 1987.

The plan quickly backfired, however, amid public uproar. The services tax was repealed in December 1987 and replaced with a 1 percent increase in the sales tax on goods — from 5 percent to 6 percent.

Frishe voted against the repeal — though he said he supported the repeal — because it included the increase in the sales tax on goods.

While those caveats give a fuller picture of Frishe's position and his vote, they do not undermine the statement made by the group Accountability in Government. We rated the claim True.

PolitiFact Florida is partnering with 10 News for the 2012 election. See video fact-checks at

The statement

Says state Rep. Jim Frishe wanted to "tax us for doing our taxes" through an accountant.

Accountability in Government, in a TV ad

The ruling

PolitiFact ruling: True

In 1987, Frishe voted to tax services, including accountants' fee, 5 percent. The proposal was repealed months later — something Frishe supported, he says. Still a vote is a vote. We rate the claim True.

The statement

Says state Rep. Jeff Brandes voted to allow state-run Citizens Property Insurance to dump policies onto "out-of-state, unregulated private companies."

Committee to Protect Florida, in a campaign mailer

The ruling

PolitiFact ruling: Mostly True

Brandes voted in favor of a proposal to have customers of Citizens transferred to different insurers. But he also voted to support changes made in the Senate that would have watered down the proposal dramatically. We rate this claim Mostly True.

Fact-checking dueling claims in the Brande/Frishe state Senate primary 07/22/12 [Last modified: Monday, October 15, 2012 3:23pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Police: 8 found dead in truck, 20 dire in immigrant smuggling case


    SAN ANTONIO — Authorities called to a Walmart parking lot in San Antonio overnight found eight people dead and 20 others in dire condition in the back of a sweltering tractor-trailer, in what police are calling a horrific case of immigrant smuggling.

    San Antonio police officers investigate the scene Sunday, July 23, 2017, where eight people were found dead in a tractor-trailer loaded with at least 30 others outside a Walmart store in stifling summer heat in what police are calling a horrific human trafficking case, in San Antonio. [Associated Press]
  2. Winner and loser of the week in Florida politics


     Winner of the week

    Peter Antonacci. Gov. Rick Scott tapped his go-to utility player to lead his Florida job recruiting agency, Enterprise Florida, having previously picked him for his general counsel, to lead the South Florida Water Management District and to serve as Palm Beach state …

  3. On the Camino de Santiago, Day 19: A peregrina spends the whole day under the weather, and part of the day under the table


    Day 19: El Burgo Ranero to Puente Villarente: 25.4 km, 7.5 hours (Total for Days 1-19 = 454 km (282 miles)

    This list pretty much sums up my day:

    Eat two bananas

    Walk 13.1 kilometers


    Walk 6.2 kilometers


    Eat half an apple

    Walk 6.1 kilometers

    Crash< …

  4. Storm routs Cleveland


    TAMPA — Alvin Ray Jackson intercepted two passes, returning one for a touchdown, and recovered two fumbles as the Storm routed Cleveland 57-27 Saturday night in its home regular-season finale at Amalie Arena.

  5. Miscue sends Rays to another stinging loss to Rangers (w/video)

    The Heater

    ST. PETERSBURG — The Rays gave away DJ Kitty onesies Saturday night. Then they gave away the game.

    Rays centerfielder Mallex Smith misses a drive hit by Adrian Beltre with two outs in the sixth, allowing the tying runs to score. Beltre puts Texas ahead 4-3 when he scores after two wild pitches.