Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Backers of lavish courthouse in Tallahassee apologize and dodge

TALLAHASSEE — There were apologies all around Wednesday as members of a Senate budget committee heard from those involved in building the posh courthouse for the 1st District Court of Appeal.

Two of the court's judges apologized if they went beyond what legislators wanted when they built the $50 million courthouse. Legislators apologized for giving the court so much money in the first place. The Department of Management Services apologized for not supervising the project properly.

"Any role that I've had that brought this project beyond legislative intent was never my intent, and I would apologize for that,'' said Judge Paul M. Hawkes, who pushed the project through the Legislature and supervised construction.

The other, Judge Brad Thomas, said he was sorry if anybody was bothered by what he did: "… To the extent that any expenditures were made on this building and any construction done that exceeds the legislative intent and has offended you and this committee … I sincerely apologize.''

Supreme Court Chief Justice Charles T. Canady said the state's highest court is coming up with rules and remedies to keep it from happening again.

Canady noted that he referred an audit of the project to the Judicial Qualifications Commission and changed the leadership at the court, ordering Hawkes to resign as chief judge. Hawkes remains on the court.

Canady will require future projects to be under the direct supervision of the state court administrator and is drafting rules that would prohibit judges from lobbying for any substantive changes in the law or budget priorities without approval from the Supreme Court. He is also planning to relocate 50 employees from rental quarters into the new courthouse.

Hawkes repeatedly said he could not remember things, including comments he made to a House committee chairman who refused to put money in the budget for the courthouse in 2007. Nor could he remember when asked about an e-mail in which he said the court would need to "kiss the rings'' to get lawmakers to approve more money for the building.

"You don't recall?'' committee chairman Mike Fasano said in a voice loaded with sarcasm. "Would you rely on this kind of testimony in a courtroom, judge?"

Fasano said later: "I'm saddened that two judges of the 1st DCA were not honest, were not straightforward, didn't give us answers they should have given and avoided answering questions. They are truly expert at playing dodgeball.

"You had two judges who wanted a Taj Mahal and cost the taxpayers tens of millions of dollars.''

When asked about equipping the court with miles of African mahogany and granite countertops and an impressive dome, Hawkes blamed prior members of the very committee he was standing before, who he said wanted the court to use quality construction materials and build an environmentally conscious structure, even if it cost more. He said architects and the builder recommended the mahogany trim after the woodworking company recommended it.

"I could see how the builder and the architect might say, 'We're going to make a nice pile of money with change orders,' '' noted Sen. Ronda Storms, R-Valrico.

Committee members raised questions about the dismissal of a DMS employee and the demotion of another who questioned giving so much authority to the judges. Reading from e-mails the judges sent demanding more control, Storms said it was a clear abuse of power by judges who should be investigated by the JQC.

"Let this be a lesson to you,'' Storms said to DMS employees in the room. "I understand what happened. You got political pressure and somebody's knees buckled. You did what was not right — you did this to save your job. Was it worth it?''

Acting DMS Secretary David Faulkenberry said former DMS Secretary Linda South would have to answer questions about political pressure and whether anyone's job was threatened.

Fasano said the committee needs to take a closer look at the DMS employees who were demoted or fired for doing a good job. But he said he doesn't think Senate leadership supports further investigation of the building.

Senate President Mike Haridopolos said as much later Wednesday. He said lawmakers already have learned "plenty'' and need to move on to more pressing issues, like the state's $3.5 billion budget shortfall.

"Our job isn't to go out to a construction site and see what's going on,'' Haridopolos said. "We need a DMS that will tell them what to do. I hope we've learned from this.''

Sen. John Thrasher, R-St. Augustine, who is on the budget committee and chairs the powerful rules committee, said he does not oppose further investigation and believes legislative rule changes can help prevent similar occurrences.

Thrasher acknowledged getting a friendly visit from Hawkes after the meeting, saying the judge is a longtime friend who just stopped by to "say hello.''

Before the meeting ended, Fasano told DMS officials they need to turn out the lights at the building. Deputy Secretary Tom Berger said the courthouse has a "very sophisticated lighting controls'' to illuminate the glass dome and building at night.

"It's kind of sad,'' Fasano said. "Turn those lights off. We don't need to advertise the Taj Mahal, we don't need the building lit up as if we were visiting Disney World.''

Some committee members suggesting selling the building or moving the Supreme Court into it. Several wondered if the expensive art work — 400 photos framed at a cost of $357,000 — could be sold on eBay.

Whatever happens next, it's clear the fallout will have lasting impact on the state's courts. Lawmakers must prepare a budget to run the courts, and Fasano said the failure to spend dollars appropriately and arrogance in how it's been spent will not be rewarded.

"We're going to penalize you, and we're going to do that with the five district court of appeals in this year's budget.''

Staff writer Katie Sanders and researcher Caryn Baird contributed to this report. Lucy Morgan can be reached at [email protected]

Backers of lavish courthouse in Tallahassee apologize and dodge 01/12/11 [Last modified: Wednesday, January 12, 2011 10:56pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Hooper: Jean Chatzy chats about the intersection of wealth, health

    Personal Finance

    Public safety officials can readily identify a city's most dangerous intersections.

    Personal finance adviser Jean Chatzky is one of several high profile speakers on the slate for the Women's Conference of Florida in Tampa next week. [Handout photo]

  2. Video: Buckhorn, Kriseman team up in Tampa Bay pitch to Amazon

    Economic Development

    Across the United States, cities and metro areas are in a frenzied bidding war to convince Amazon their regions are the best fit for its new headquarters, HQ2.

    The Tampa Bay area is no exception. …

    The first  video, rolled out on Oct. 19, 2017, features Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn, left, and St. Petersburg Mayor Rick Kriseman welcoming Amazon and talking about why Tampa Bay would be a perfect fit for the second Amazon headquarters.
  3. Dirk Koetter sounds Bucs alarm: 'They're the players that we have'


    The other day, Bucs defensive coordinator Mike Smith was asked about the lack of production and pressure from the defensive line, especially off the edge.

    Then it happened.

    Tampa Bay Buccaneers cornerback Vernon Hargreaves (28) takes the field for the start of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers game against the New England Patriots on October 5, 2017 at Raymond James Stadium in Tampa, Fla.
  4. Police seek public's help as they investigate third death in Seminole Heights


    TAMPA — Police are seeking the public's help in their investigation of three suspicious deaths in southeast Seminole Heights during the past two weeks.

    Interim Tampa police Chief Brian Dugan addresses reporters about the latest suspicious death in southeast Seminole Heights Thursday night. [JONATHAN CAPRIEL | Times]
  5. Listen: Soldier's widow shares her call with Trump


    Natasha De Alencar had just returned home on April 12 after making T-shirts and pillowcases in her husband's memory when the Army casualty assistance officer told her there was someone on the phone for her. It was President Donald Trump.

    Army Staff Sgt. Mark R. De Alencar was killed during a firefight with Islamic State fighters in eastern Afghanistan on April 8, 2017. His widow, Natasha De Alencar has shared the condolence call she had with President Donald Trump on April 12. [Image from video via Washington Post]