Wednesday, November 14, 2018
Politics

Condo owners being forced out look to legislators for help

Condo owners statewide say they're being forced from their homes by bulk buyers and former Rep. Keith Fitzgerald, D-Sarasota, was one of few who saw it coming.

"Either I'm onto something, or I'm crazy," he thought of his lone vote in opposition to a 2007 condo law change.

Seven years later, Fitzgerald is far from alone. Legislators, lawyers, the governor and his challenger's campaign recently called for change to protect condo owners.

"These are people that are just going about their lives and suddenly their whole life has become this turmoil," said Rep. Carl Zimmermann, D-Palm Harbor. "Every single day their second job is trying to research and find ways to protect themselves."

Owners are fighting what they call a loophole in Florida condominium law. As of 2007, an investor who buys 80 percent of the condos in a complex can vote to convert the complex into apartments and force the remaining individual owners to sell and leave, unless the condo's governing documents state otherwise.

Doreen Rosselli, 52, has lived in her Carrollwood condo that she now shares with her boyfriend since 2006. She planned to stay awhile.

"Till the day I died."

That changed once bulk buyers acquired a large majority of units in her complex.

"It really bothers me," Rosselli said. "It's wrong to be able to take the house just to make money."

Rosselli has protested the statute alongside people in similar situations. Palm Harbor condo owner Stephanie Krasowski formed the activist group Floridians Against Condo Takeover with people from at least 13 complexes statewide. East Lake, Tampa, Winter Springs, Boynton Beach, Boca Raton, Fort Myers, Orlando and Pembroke Pines are all on her radar.

Krasowski reached out to Zimmermann for help last year, explaining her circumstances.

In 2007, she put down $32,500 on her home. There's $124,500 left on her mortgage and the investors, Madison Oaks Partners, said they feel they already have the legal grounds necessary to convert the condos to apartments but are waiting to negotiate deals with each remaining owner individually.

"I really do empathize with people who have mortgages that are greater than the current value of the real estate," said Eric Granowsky, one of the four Madison Oaks Partners investors.

When Granowsky and his partners move forward with termination, Krasowski expects them to pay her $82,000 at most to leave her home. That would go straight to the lender and leave her on the hook for the difference.

"It's been an exhausting year of trying to stay above water and fight with everything we've got," she said at an August news conference Zimmermann held on the statute.

'Deeply concerned'

Zimmermann first raised the issue in the 2014 legislative session, but aside from one minor tweak, he couldn't make headway in changing the law. Now he has others on board to support new legislation next year: Rep. John Wood, R-Winter Haven, Rep. James Grant, R-Tampa, and, most notably, a powerful Senate ally in Jack Latvala, R-Clearwater.

Gov. Rick Scott recently called for a legislative change, writing to Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation secretary Ken Lawson saying he's "deeply concerned" and requesting recommendations by the 2015 session.

The statute change in question came about because in many cases developers and investors needed consent from every single owner before they could convert condos into apartments. Then, hurricane-damaged and obsolete properties sat vacant because developers had trouble getting consent from elderly and out-of-state owners. All it took was one unreachable owner to thwart a much-needed condo termination.

"It's just not possible to get 100 percent signatures in the larger condos, even for something that was completely innocuous or had to be done," said then-Senate Minority Leader Steve Geller, D-Cooper City.

So in the early 2000s, Geller began working with the Florida Bar to draft legislation that would lower the threshold for condominium terminations to 80 percent owner approval.

"Sen. Geller's motives were absolutely pure," said Pete Dunbar, a real estate lawyer and lobbyist who worked on the change with others in the Florida Bar Real Property Probate and Trust Law Section. "(We) agreed with him and provided technical assistance to him, never realizing that there was something unforeseen that was built into the words."

The change passed both chambers in 2006, but then-Gov. Jeb Bush vetoed it, warning there might be "unintended consequences."

When Gov. Charlie Crist took office the next year, he signed a similar bill into law. The 80 percent threshold stuck, but now 10 percent of owners could veto a termination. The Senate voted 37-0 and the House 117-1, with all but Fitzgerald supporting the measure.

Before the recession hit, most people hadn't considered the possibility of investors buying out homeowners and leaving them in debt, Dunbar said. Had values kept climbing, owners would have made money by selling.

But given the economic turn, Dunbar agreed with Scott and legislators who say the law needs changing, as did a campaign spokesman for Crist. "This is an abuse of the spirit and the intent of the law," said Brendan Gilfillan. "No one should be pressured to leave their home."

Potential fix unclear

If legislators are able to pass a bill next session, it likely wouldn't do much for condo owners like Krasowski, who face termination from bulk buyers now. It's also not clear yet what route they'd take to fix the loophole, whether it's offering more money to owners reluctant to sell, or only allowing owners one vote each, no matter how many units they own.

That debate will come later. For now, Zimmermann's focus is still on trying to raise awareness, since he's noticed people are reluctant to believe condo owners at first, just like he had been last year.

"I thought for sure she had misread the law," he said. "So I looked it up and I read it and I thought, 'Wow, she's right. But this can't be right. She's right, but this can't be right.' "

Times researcher Carolyn Edds contributed to this report. Contact Julie Kliegman at [email protected] or (727) 445-4159. Follow @jmkliegman.

Comments
The Daystarter: A whole lot of suing going on in the Florida recount; why Rick Scott and Bill Nelson are smack in the middle; a Hall of Fame kind of night for Martin St. Louis

The Daystarter: A whole lot of suing going on in the Florida recount; why Rick Scott and Bill Nelson are smack in the middle; a Hall of Fame kind of night for Martin St. Louis

The Daystarter: Marc Topkin on Rays’ manager Kevin Cash falling short of the top AL manager award; Graham Brink on why Amazon just isn’t that into Tampa Bay; and Tom Jones on why the Bucs are keeping Jameis Winston on the bench.
Updated: 2 hours ago
Here’s a handy guide to all those Florida 2018 recount lawsuits

Here’s a handy guide to all those Florida 2018 recount lawsuits

Since a statewide recount was ordered last week for three major races in Florida, lawsuits have been filed all over the state.
Updated: 3 hours ago
Joe Henderson: Hillsborough voters charted a reasonable path forward with school tax approval

Joe Henderson: Hillsborough voters charted a reasonable path forward with school tax approval

Voters agreed that excellent schools and a decent transportation system are vital to this community.
Published: 11/14/18
Palm Beach County gets recount extension from judge

Palm Beach County gets recount extension from judge

The online docket suggests a Tallahassee judge entered an order Tuesday afternoon “suspending certain deadlines.” The judge, Karen Gievers, also allowed Sen. Bill Nelson, who is locked in a tight race for his Senate seat with Gov. Rick Scott , to intervene in the case.
Updated: 11 hours ago
Will Gov. Rick Scott certify an election that he claims is fraudulent? He won’t say.

Will Gov. Rick Scott certify an election that he claims is fraudulent? He won’t say.

The Elections Canvassing Commission is set to meet Tuesday. Sen. Bill Nelson is saying he should recuse himself from it.
Updated: 11 hours ago
Bill Nelson and Democrats file three new election lawsuits

Bill Nelson and Democrats file three new election lawsuits

The legal workload is rapidly multiplying for judges in federal court in Tallahassee.
Published: 11/13/18
Broward finally begins its recount as new lawsuits seek to extend deadline

Broward finally begins its recount as new lawsuits seek to extend deadline

As Broward County began to recount ballots from the midterm elections, candidates filed new lawsuits seeking to extend the deadline for the process
Published: 11/13/18
Rick Scott’s campaign sues Hillsborough County Supervisor of Elections

Rick Scott’s campaign sues Hillsborough County Supervisor of Elections

The campaign is alleging that election observers were forced to watch recounts from another room.
Published: 11/13/18
A woman went to Mexico for a cheap nose job. Now she's in a coma and might never wake up.

A woman went to Mexico for a cheap nose job. Now she's in a coma and might never wake up.

A Texas woman decided to get a nose job in Mexico instead of the United States because it was much cheaper -- just $138.But now she is on life support after the procedure went terribly wrong. Her family has been told that they can either remove her f...
Published: 11/13/18
A wrong-way driver slammed into her on the Howard Frankland Bridge. She's alive and grateful.

A wrong-way driver slammed into her on the Howard Frankland Bridge. She's alive and grateful.

Andrea Rusch, a 24-year-old bartender at Ferg's Sports Bar and Grill in St. Petersburg, has undergone three surgeries but is expected to be discharged from St. Joseph's Hospital this week.
Published: 11/13/18