Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

'Stand your ground' needs thoughtful changes, not doomed crusade for repeal

In terms of brevity and accuracy, most of the headlines from last week's House committee meeting were right on target.

For instance:

Lawmakers vote down repeal of "stand your ground"

This would be the concise version of events. The straightforward telling of a story that has captured the state's attention for months.

Here's the alternate version:

Grandstanding on "stand your ground" leads nowhere

The five-hour House committee meeting wasn't a debate, it was a charade. The proposal had zero chance of making it out of that committee, and everyone knew it.

Now that isn't a judgment on the law itself; that is simply reality.

Republicans understand that. So do common-sense Democrats.

They all pay attention to the way winds are blowing around the state, and so they know there is not a lot of enthusiasm among voters to repeal "stand your ground."

Poll after poll has shown a majority of Florida residents favor keeping the law the way it is. A smaller number of residents would like to see the law modified. Those who want to reverse the law entirely are outnumbered by a hopeless margin.

So like it or not, "stand your ground" is here to stay.

That's why last week's proposal should not be portrayed as some valiant effort to fight the good fight. Instead, it was a predictably doomed crusade that could potentially hamper a more realistic effort to close "stand your ground's" loopholes.

It's almost like the old courtroom adage:

Never ask a question to which you don't already know the answer.

All that the highly publicized committee meeting did was allow "stand your ground" cheerleaders to point out how little support there is for repeal. Not only did the eight Republicans on the committee vote to quash the proposal, three of the five Democrats did, too.

So much for momentum.

Meanwhile, the Senate's Criminal Justice subcommittee has been working on bipartisan proposals that address some of the ambiguities in the law's language.

For instance, someone who was an aggressor in a confrontation would not necessarily have "stand your ground" immunity.

The Senate proposal would also require law enforcement agencies to conduct full investigations even when "stand your ground" has been claimed as a defense. And local police departments would be asked to establish guidelines for neighborhood watch associations to play an "observe and report" role.

These Senate proposals are similar to some of the recommendations made earlier this year by a task force convened by the governor to examine "stand your ground," and so they should have legitimacy across party lines.

So does that mean there is a chance the law will be fixed?

The proposals have made it past one committee, and it would not be shocking to see some version of reform reach the Senate floor.

Unfortunately, getting past the House will be another story. Republican leaders have not been enthusiastic about changes and, if they want to be disingenuous, could claim to have already given the issue a public hearing.

House Democrats should remember that before congratulating themselves on last week's futile fight.

'Stand your ground' needs thoughtful changes, not doomed crusade for repeal 11/11/13 [Last modified: Monday, November 11, 2013 9:19pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. A long-awaited vision for Tampa's Westshore Marina District

    Real Estate

    TAMPA — More than a decade after plans to develop a vacant waterfront tract were first announced, a new rendering finally gives a hint of what Westshore Marina District will ultimately look like.

    Rendering of Marina Pointe, a condo project overlooking Tampa Bay as part of the Westshore Marina District. [Courtesy of Masterfile Corp.}
  2. Buddy Brew Coffee to open downtown Tampa location


    TAMPA — Buddy Brew Coffee plans to open a new location in downtown Tampa at Park Tower. The specialty coffee craft roaster, which was founded in 2010, has five other locations throughout Tampa including the Oxford Exchange, Sarasota, Hyde Park Village and Terminal F inside the Tampa International Airport.

    A cappuccino is displayed at Buddy Brew in Tampa in January 2017. [CHARLIE KAIJO | Times]
  3. What you might have missed in the second episode of the Bucs on 'Hard Knocks'


    We're back for another episode of The Annotated Hard Knocks, trying to find behind-the-scenes insights and things you might have missed in Tuesday's second episode of "Hard Knocks," following the Bucs in …

    As the crowd recognized him and got loud, Jameis Winston jumped up and down in celebration. [GREG AUMAN | Times]
  4. Review: 'The Defenders' brings out the best in Marvel's unlikeliest heroes


    The ties that bind Daredevil, Jessica Jones, Luke Cage and Iron Fist run deep. But they're just starting to figure all that out in The Defenders.

    Mike Colter, Scott Glenn, Finn Jones, Krysten Ritter and Charlie Cox in The Defenders.
  5. Ryan Reynolds and Samuel L. Jackson can't keep 'The Hitman's Bodyguard' on-target


    The Hitman's Bodyguard is an assault tank on semi-automatic pilot, spraying jokes and bullets with only the ammo consistently hitting its targets. The irresistible teaming of Ryan Reynolds and Samuel L. Jackson might be even funnier if they missed once in a while.

    Samuel L. Jackson, left, and Ryan Reynolds star in "The Hitman's Bodyguard." (Lionsgate)