Wednesday, October 17, 2018
Politics

Experts: Tampa candidate's photo cuts Buckhorn from his own portrait

TAMPA

Is a City Council candidate using a campaign photo that superimposes her own image on Mayor Bob Buckhorn's official city portrait?

It looks that way, say five digital photography experts who examined both photos.

Background details in both match, they said, and a sliver of Buckhorn's suit appears reflected in a glass tabletop next to the image of candidate Jackie Toledo.

"Indeed, this looks like a bad composite," Kevin Connor, president of Fourandsix Technologies, which specializes in image forensics and authentication, said in an email to the Tampa Bay Times.

Buckhorn doesn't approve. He said Toledo's photo could mislead voters into thinking she has an endorsement he hasn't given.

"I knew I would be a lame duck someday, but I didn't think people would be Photoshopping me out of my own picture," he said.

"It was incredibly stupid, but I'll write it off to rookie mistakes," Buckhorn said. "If her consultant did it, she ought to fire the consultant. And if she did it, then hopefully she'll learn a lesson from this."

Toledo, 37, is a civil engineer and first-time candidate running for the City Council District 6 seat, which will open next March when council chairman Charlie Miranda leaves it because of term limits. Early this week, she said she couldn't remember when the campaign photo was made. But she said she has often been in the conference room that it shows since joining the Mayor's Hispanic Advisory Council in 2009.

On Friday, responding to additional questions from the Times, Toledo said a friend sent her the photo. She said she did not "ever alter or edit it."

"Posting it on Facebook was not intended to be deceptive," she wrote, attaching to her email additional photos of herself, singly and in a group, in front of the seal with Buckhorn, as well as with former Mayor Pam Iorio.

"None of the pictures attached imply an endorsement," she said. "They are just pictures I have been fortunate enough to take in my role, over the last five years, as a member of the Mayor's Hispanic Advisory Council."

Toledo did not respond to followup questions about whether she actually posed for the campaign photo in front of the seal, knew the photo to be altered or planned to continue using it. Nor did she identify who sent it to her.

Campaign consultant Anthony Pedicini, who called the Times on Toledo's behalf early this week, said Friday that he didn't know who made the photo and wasn't involved himself.

The background for both Buckhorn's portrait and Toledo's campaign photo, which appears on her campaign Facebook page and website, is the city's seal, which hangs in Buckhorn's private conference room. Though familiar to political insiders, the room is not open to the public.

Connor, of Fourandsix Technologies, is a 15-year veteran of the team that builds Photoshop-branded products at Adobe, most recently as vice president of product management. Four others also examined both photos at the request of the Times:

• Jason D. Moore, an Adobe certified expert in Photoshop who served as the lead subject matter expert, head writer, editor and producer of the New York Institute of Photography's "Complete Course in Digital Photography: Photoshop for Photographers."

• Philadelphia area commercial photographer Richard Quindry, who has served as an expert witness in legal cases involving Photoshop.

• Jeff Sedlik, a forensic image analyst, expert witness and professor at the Art Center College of Design in Pasadena, Calif.

• Damien Symonds, who works with and has a Photoshop training business in Brisbane, Australia.

All mentioned the similarities of the backgrounds, and four noted the reflection of Buckhorn's sleeve on the tabletop of Toledo's photo.

Moore, Connor and Quindry said that when the two images are laid over each other, the backgrounds line up.

Sedlik said the precise alignment of the seal indicates that the background photos were shot with the camera in the same position using the same lens. But differences in the quality of light and the direction of light on Toledo and the background indicate the use of different lighting in different positions.

Symonds said blurred parts around the edges of Toledo's image "seem implausible," and he noted "the absence of any wisps of hair which could be expected in such a portrait."

Experts in politics and public relations offered varied opinions on using a photo like Toledo's.

While "clumsy," such a photo doesn't seem to present "any out-right ethical issues," said former Michigan Rep. M. Robert Carr, an adjunct professor of ethics and Congress in the Graduate School of Political Management at George Washington University.

"The use of a such a Photoshopped photo in a city council race does raise some legitimate questions, but without additional facts, they are not questions of ethics," Carr said in an email. "This is particularly the case as we seem to live in a Photoshopped world where people are on notice that photos are not always what they are made to appear to be."

But Beth Rosenson, a University of Florida associate professor of political science, finds Toledo's photo "problematic because it is misleading," almost implying that she already holds city office.

"As a candidate, you have a responsibility to think about what conclusions people are going to draw," said Rosenson, author of Shadowlands of Conduct: Ethics and State Politics. "Obviously, everyone wants to make a favorable impression on voters, but you shouldn't mislead them."

Comments
Daniel Ruth: For Hillsborough voters, transportation tax is leap of faith they can ponder while stuck in trafffic

Daniel Ruth: For Hillsborough voters, transportation tax is leap of faith they can ponder while stuck in trafffic

Perhaps one way to approach the ongoing community-wide debate over imposing a one-cent sales tax to pay for a variety of transportation needs is to think of all this dickering as a sort of family Thanksgiving dinner that has suddenly turned into a Th...
Updated: 6 hours ago
Approach to charter schools separates Toledo, Bellanti in state House 60 race

Approach to charter schools separates Toledo, Bellanti in state House 60 race

TAMPA — Republican state Rep. Jackie Toledo won her first term by 14 percentage points, a lopsided victory that shows how the district she represents favors a Republican.Two years later, Toledo has drawn a challenge from Democrat Debra Bellant...
Updated: 8 hours ago
John Romano: Liberals are dreaming when it comes to holding on to Florida’s Supreme Court

John Romano: Liberals are dreaming when it comes to holding on to Florida’s Supreme Court

This was a smackdown, no doubt about it.The state Supreme Court just rendered the judicial equivalent of a loud guffaw regarding Gov. Rick Scott’s claim he is entitled to replace three retiring Supreme Court justices before he leaves office.And yet, ...
Updated: 11 hours ago
In race to represent Hernando residents in Tallahassee, it's prominent Republican incumbent versus optimistic Democratic newcomer

In race to represent Hernando residents in Tallahassee, it's prominent Republican incumbent versus optimistic Democratic newcomer

Much as it did two years ago, this year's race for the Florida House of Representatives' District 35 seat casts a titan of his party against an underdog political newcomer.Blaise Ingoglia, the Republican incumbent who also chairs Florida's GOP, has o...
Published: 10/17/18
Florida House District 66: Candidates differ on education, school security

Florida House District 66: Candidates differ on education, school security

Republican Nick DiCeglie and Democrat Alex Heeren have widely different viewpoints on key issues
Published: 10/17/18
It's a battle of numbers in Pasco County commission races

It's a battle of numbers in Pasco County commission races

Incumbents tout job growth. Challengers focus on poverty, low wages.
Published: 10/17/18
Democrat Jennifer Webb and Republican Raymond Blacklidge pick up the pace as they battle for State House District 69 seat

Democrat Jennifer Webb and Republican Raymond Blacklidge pick up the pace as they battle for State House District 69 seat

Democrat Jennifer Webb and Republican Raymond Blacklidge are pulling in campaign donations from a wide swath of supporters as they try to capture the State House District 69 seat
Published: 10/17/18
Realignment at Big Bend intersection promises safer traffic flow after construction headaches

Realignment at Big Bend intersection promises safer traffic flow after construction headaches

GIBSONTON – A new north-south road is coming to relieve traffic along U.S. 301, but making way for it promises some short-term traffic headaches for a South Shore region already stymied by congestion.The new road would run more than four miles...
Updated: 4 hours ago
Trump criticizes rush to condemn Saudi Arabia over Khashoggi

Trump criticizes rush to condemn Saudi Arabia over Khashoggi

Trump criticizes rush to condemn Saudi Arabia over Khashoggi
Published: 10/16/18
To understand homeless people, Tampa photographer spent 18 months meeting with them

To understand homeless people, Tampa photographer spent 18 months meeting with them

TAMPA — On Jim’s arm was a tattoo of a hinge with screw holes indicating where the recovering addict used to inject heroin.Fernando liked to belt out songs he wrote about a love he lost when he fled from Cuba.Timothy had a dog he refuse...
Published: 10/16/18