Pasco landfill proposal spawns a battle of money, lobbyists

Caught unaware that a decision on a disputed landfill was near, ranch owner Robert Thomas moved bureaucracy last month like an experienced hand.

He and fellow rancher Bill Blanchard, who hightailed back from the slopes in Vail, Colo., sat down Dec. 4 with some of Florida's top environmental regulators in Tallahassee. They said they wanted more time to make their case against the proposed Angelo's Aggregate Materials landfill near Dade City.

Within days, the decision on the landfill permit that has been two years in the making was postponed until this Monday. The agency line noted the big, time-consuming holidays — not the big gun who set up that meeting for the ranchers:

Bob Martinez, former governor of Florida.

Opposition to the landfill, which one day could run 1,000 acres near Green Swamp and the Hillsborough and Withlacoochee rivers, has often appeared to be a low-frills outfit against a big company.

It's really been well-heeled resistance.

Blanchard and Thomas have spent tens of thousands of dollars on lobbying and experts, and made a similar investment in campaign contributions. Thomas' Two Rivers Ranch paid Martinez, a lobbyist for Holland & Knight, an estimated $35,000 in early 2008 — and his fees for the run-up to the agency decision have not yet been disclosed.

"Gov. Martinez has been helping us make the proper contacts," Thomas said, noting the former Tampa mayor's connections.

Lobbying for a landfill

So far, the focus has been on the other side. Opponents have highlighted the fact that Angelo's Aggregate Materials delivered political donations of at least $89,000 and hired big name lobbying for the project.

Well-connected lobbyist Brian Ballard and his firm have worked since December 2007 for Angelo's, an arm of Michigan-based Angelo Iafrate Cos., seeking approval from the Florida Department of Environmental Protection.

Ballard's firm also employs another Angelo's lobbyist, Greg Turbeville, who was an adviser to former Gov. Jeb Bush. Ballard, a senior partner, said he worked last year against legislation that tried to scuttle the project, but Turbeville has done most, if not all, of the work involving DEP.

Compensation reports show Angelo's has paid an estimated $90,000 to the firm through September, the most recent period available.

"We hired a lobbyist because they hired a lobbyist," Dominic Iafrate, vice president of Angelo's, said last week of landfill opponents. "If they hadn't hired a lobbyist, we wouldn't have hired one."

But that's not the only explanation Iafrate has given for hiring Brian Ballard.

In response to a written question from the Times about Ballard in January 2008, Iafrate stated:

"As you know we are attempting to get a permit from FDEP for our composting and recycling facility. We were advised that he is very good at helping to navigate through the regulatory environment in Tallahassee."

Besides Ballard's ties to top lawmakers and Gov. Charlie Crist, Ballard's brother Bob is a deputy secretary at FDEP.

Questioned over the relationship, the agency told the Times that Bob Ballard, who oversees land and recreation, would recuse himself from having any role.

His post does not rule on solid waste or environmental permits, though he did attend a Nov. 20 meeting about the landfill because of questions over nearby state conservation land. Critics such as County Commissioner Ted Schrader and resident Carl Roth seized on the relationship as a potential conflict last week.

The agency declined to make the deputy secretary available, but press secretary Doug Tobin said Bob Ballard had no inkling of his brother's involvement until reading the Times last week.

For their part, landfill opponents Martinez and Thomas said they have seen nothing to indicate Bob Ballard has played any role.

"Any notion that there's any improper involvement is not only unfounded — it's absurd," said attorney Chris Kise, a friend of Brian Ballard — and lobbyist for Blanchard, the landfill critic.

Fighting the 'absurd'

Kise's hiring is another indication of the landfill opposition's deep pockets. Blanchard hired Kise, a confidante of Crist, in December for legal work and starting this month, lobbying. Blanchard also had hired four lobbyists in December from the Akerman Senterfitt firm, records show. Blanchard said he believes only one, Frank Tsamoutales, has done work on the case.

Another environmental lobbyist, James Harvey of West Palm Beach, is registered to lobby for Thomas' Two Rivers Ranch, but Thomas said he's only on standby for this case.

None of the lobbying payments have been disclosed yet.

A notable public relations consultant from Lutz, Honey Rand, also works for their cause, but not as a lobbyist.

Blanchard's family owns almost 1,900 acres near the proposed landfill, much of it under conservation protection but some home to a tree and plant business. Thomas' ranchland span 14,000 acres in Pasco, Hillsborough and Hernando counties. He also owns Crystal Springs Preserve, which Nestle pumps for drinking water, and is a developer.

"We are deeply concerned," Thomas said. "I never really expected DEP would ever consider issuing a permit for something so colossally absurd, but evidently they are."

The wealthy duo, their family members and their companies have contributed more than $50,000 to politicians and interest groups after Angelo's applied to run the landfill, campaign finance records show. At least one recipient, Schrader, opposes the project.

Schrader received $500 from Two Rivers Ranch, based in Thonotosassa, in 2008 before defeating challenger John Nicolette in the County Commission race. Nicolette is a family friend of Iafrate.

"Ted Schrader was my son's baseball coach," Thomas said. "Pasco County's lucky to have Ted Schrader."

By hiring Martinez, who has promoted land preservation locally and statewide, and other lobbyists, Blanchard and Thomas say they're trying to change the course of the permit. In December, they sensed a permit was imminent. As of last week, they saw reasons for optimism.

Martinez confirmed he has set up meetings, saying he did most of his work since latter 2008. He declined to say who he contacted about "basically trying to get the story out as to why it shouldn't be done."

Last week, Kise, Blanchard and others made the case to DEP Secretary Michael Sole and other officials in Tallahassee.

"I think we helped DEP realize some of the flaws in the permit. You know, they are very busy in that office," Blanchard said.

This week, Martinez and Thomas will darken the doorway of Tampa Bay Water general manager Gerald Seeber to urge that agency to take a closer look at the landfill, too.

A 2007 review by the agency — the regional overseer of drinking water supplies —found the project was "outside the zone that could affect our water supply system."

Thomas wants to win a different outlook — with a little help from his friends.

Times staff writer Lisa Buie contributed to this report. David DeCamp can be reached at ddecamp@sptimes.com or (800) 333-7505, ext. 6232.

Key players in Pasco County landfill fight

After Angelo's Aggregate Materials proposed a landfill near Dade City, the company and opponents hired top lobbyists and consultants to wage their arguments.

Brian Ballard

Ballard, one of Tallahassee's most powerful lobbyists, registered as Angelo's advocate in December 2007, according to state disclosure records. His firm, Smith & Ballard, has been paid an estimated $90,000 through September 2008 by Angelo's to lobby the Legislature and state agencies, compensation reports show. His firm also employs another Angelo's lobbyist, Greg Turbeville, a former policy advisor to Gov. Jeb Bush. Ballard is a top Republican Party fundraiser and friend of Gov. Charlie Crist. His partner and father-in-law is former secretary of state Jim Smith. His brother Bob is a deputy secretary of the Department of Environmental Protection, which is reviewing the proposed landfill.

Bob Martinez

Martinez, Florida governor from 1987-91, registered as a lobbyist in September 2007 for landfill opponent Bob Thomas of Two Rivers Ranch. Martinez, former mayor of Tampa, remains a Republican power broker with local and state reach. His firm, Holland & Knight, has received an estimated $35,000 from the ranch through September 2008, state records show. Martinez has opened a variety of doors for opponents at state and local offices, said Thomas, who serves with Martinez and fellow landfill critic Bill Blanchard on the Lowry Park Zoo board. Martinez's ties extend well beyond that: As governor, his chief of staff was Ballard.

Chris Kise

A partner in Foley & Lardner law firm, Kise was special legal adviser to Gov. Charlie Crist before becoming an unpaid adviser on energy and climate change. When Crist was attorney general, Kise was his solicitor general. He has represented utilities only as a lawyer, but he was registering as a lobbyist last week. He was hired by landfill opponent Bill Blanchard in December, and Kise said he provides legal advice reviewing the proposal.

Honey Rand

President of the Environmental PR Group, Rand works for Blanchard to provide public relations help. Rand is known for her aggressive approach and her knowledge of environmental issues. She has assisted the campaign against the landfill run by Protectors of Florida's Legacy, though resident Carl Roth is the spokesman. Her agency also helped promote the expansion of the county's garbage incinerator. Her firm also represents developments such as SunWest Harbourtowne near Hudson. She previously was a public face of the Southwest Florida Water Management District as its communications director.

Fast facts

Follow the money

Since the rise of a proposed landfill in 2006, opponent Robert Thomas, his Two Rivers Ranch and other holdings have contributed more than $49,000 to politicians and political groups. Landfill critic Bill Blanchard, his family and businesses have donated $4,500 to candidates. Some recipients:

Floridians for

Smarter Growth

$40,000 from Two Rivers Ranch, July 2007. The political action committee is a business-backed effort to defeat a proposal to require the elections decide large growth management changes.

Ted Schrader, Pasco

County commissioner

$500 from Two Rivers Ranch, June 2008. Schrader opposes the landfill, but he and Thomas say their friendship goes back years.

Ann Hildebrand, Pasco County commissioner

$500 from WRB Enterprises, October 2008. WRB Enterprises in Tampa is run by Blanchard. The County Commission should ultimately vote on the landfill. Blanchard said he hasn't spoken with Hildebrand on the project.

Republican Party of Florida

$5,000 from Two Rivers Ranch, August 2008. The donation came amid the run-up to the last legislative and statewide election.

State Sen. Jeff Atwater

$1,000 from Two Rivers Ranch and Crystal Springs Preserve, June 2008. Thomas is president of the ranch and preserve. Atwater, R-North Palm Beach, is president of the Florida Senate.

Sources: Florida Division

of Elections, Pasco County Supervisor of Elections Office

Pasco landfill proposal spawns a battle of money, lobbyists 01/10/09 [Last modified: Sunday, January 11, 2009 7:10pm]

© 2014 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...