Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

PolitiFact.com | Tampa Bay Times
Sorting out the truth in politics

PolitiFact Florida: Experts disagree on red light cameras' effects

ST. PETERSBURG — Hopefuls for St. Petersburg mayor are divided on the city's red light camera program.

Mayoral candidate Kathleen Ford argued in her response to a Tampa Bay Times questionnaire that the city's technology is flawed, the cost to appeal is "prohibitively high" and unfair, and the program should be stopped. Mayor Bill Foster, who pushed for the cameras, still supports them.

Mayoral candidate Rick Kriseman aligns with Foster. "I support them for the purposes of public safety. … The fact is that red light cameras change driver behavior and cut down on the most dangerous types of accidents," Kriseman wrote.

We wanted to know if Kriseman's point is accurate.

St. Petersburg is one of about 70 municipalities in Florida with red light cameras, along with Tampa, Miami, Orlando and five other cities in Pinellas County, including Clearwater.

The St. Petersburg program started in fall 2011. Tickets for running a red light are $158.

A number of municipalities have had buyer's remorse. In Houston, a voter referendum killed the program. Collier County, Fla., commissioners voted to kill their program in December 2012 because they didn't find evidence that the cameras reduced accidents. Los Angeles officials ended their program after realizing it was difficult to pursue violators.

Still, other cities tout benefits. More than a year in, the question remains for St. Petersburg: Are the cameras reducing the most dangerous crashes?

A consultant's performance report in December concluded that the red light crash rate fell by 31 percent at St. Petersburg traffic approaches with cameras from November 2011 to October 2012, compared with the three-year average preceding it.

But the report contained omissions, such as the fact that rear-end wrecks at intersections with red light cameras jumped 44 percent and overall crashes at those intersections increased 10 percent from the previous year.

Interpretations all depend on how you dice the data, said Michael Frederick, the city's transportation manager. The consultant compared the first year of traffic data with a three-year average instead of data just for the year before. A more in-depth review is expected after three years.

Kriseman's campaign said he was talking about the effect of red light cameras in general on motorist behavior and dangerous crashes. The campaign sent us materials from national pro-camera groups, the National Coalition for Safer Roads and the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, in addition to a study that appeared in the Journal of Trauma in 2010.

But while those studies supported Kriseman's assertion — at least to a degree — we found other studies that did not.

That's the problem, experts say.

"There isn't a conclusive study that would say that in all circumstances that red light cameras are going to provide the safety benefits that they're looking at," said Jason Bittner, director of USF's Center for Urban Transportation Research. "It's kind of on a case-by-case basis."

Three USF researchers who have been reviewing red light camera studies say there is no consensus that red light cameras improve public safety.

They noted that some studies deemed sound by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration actually stated that injury or severe crashes increased with the cameras. Yet other studies did not factor in traffic trends, such as an overall decrease in red light running.

The professors agree that red light cameras influence driver behavior — just not for the better. "There's a difference between a driver being more aware and a driver being more skittish," said Etienne Pracht, a USF professor of health care economics.

Our ruling

Kriseman said that "red light cameras change driver behavior and cut down on the most dangerous types of accidents."

Studies show the cameras change motorist behavior. But whether they truly "cut down on the most dangerous types of accidents" is up for debate. We rate his claim Half True.

This fact-check has been edited for print. Read the full version at PolitiFact.com/Florida.

The statement

"The fact is that red light cameras change driver behavior and cut down on the most dangerous types of accidents."

Rick Kriseman, July 28, in the Tampa Bay Times

The ruling

PolitiFact ruling: Half True
Studies show the cameras change motorist behavior — either putting them on high alert or teaching them a lesson. But whether they truly "cut down on the most dangerous types of accidents" remains a matter of debate. We rate his claim Half True.

PolitiFact Florida: Experts disagree on red light cameras' effects 08/01/13 [Last modified: Friday, August 2, 2013 12:37am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Dodgers close in on World Series with 6-1 win over Cubs

    Ml

    CHICAGO — Yu Darvish pitched into the seventh inning, Chris Taylor homered again and the Los Angeles Dodgers beat the Chicago Cubs 6-1 on Tuesday night to open a commanding 3-0 lead in the NL Championship Series.

    Los Angeles Dodgers' Chris Taylor hits a home run Tuesday during the third inning of Game 3 of baseball's National League Championship Series against the Chicago Cubs. [Associated Press]
  2. Peter Budaj, Lightning lose to Devils in shootout; Nikita Kucherov scores

    Lightning Strikes

    NEWARK, N.J. — For Peter Budaj, Tuesday's season debut had a shaky start.

    The Lightning’s Vladislav Namestnikov, right, battles Damon Severson for the puck.
  3. Mother's testimony about toddler's death brings judge to tears

    Criminal

    TAMPA — Nayashia Williams woke up early on May 7, 2014, to the sound of her daughter calling for her. It was the last time the young mother's mornings would begin with a summons from Myla Presley, who couldn't yet climb over the mesh fencing around the playpen she used as a bed.

    Deandre Gilmore looks towards the gallery Tuesday in a Tampa courtroom. Gilmore is accused of killing the 19 month-old daughter of his girlfriend in 2014. He said the child fell while he was giving her a bath. [CHRIS URSO   |   Times]
  4. Speakers: Getting tough can't be only response to teen car thefts

    Crime

    ST. PETERSBURG — Bob Dillinger remembers coming to Pinellas County as a legal intern in 1975. There were five major poverty zones in St. Petersburg.

    Wengay Newton, Florida House of Representatives (in front, in center), talks as a panelist to a packed room during a community forum on "Reclaiming our Youth: Is Juvenile Justice a Reality?" at the Dr. Carter G. Woodson Museum in St. Petersburg Wednesday evening (10/17/17). The event was presented by the Fred G. Minnis, Sr. Bar Association. Community leaders discussed the ongoing auto theft epidemic among Pinellas youth.
  5. Internal White House documents allege manufacturing decline increases abortions, infertility and spousal abuse

    Politics

    White House officials working on trade policy were alarmed last month when a top adviser to President Donald Trump circulated a two-page document that alleged a weakened manufacturing sector leads to an increase in abortion, spousal abuse, divorce and infertility, two people familiar with the matter told the …