Make us your home page

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Herman Cain wins Presidency 5 straw poll

ORLANDO — From the bottom of the polls to the top of the pack, businessman Herman Cain won a surprise victory at the Republican Party of Florida's nationally watched presidential straw poll Saturday in a sign that front-runner Rick Perry is in deep trouble.

Cain's landslide victory, with 37 percent of the vote, exceeded the combined total for Perry and Mitt Romney, who only garnered 15 percent and 14 percent, respectively.

But it was a particularly stinging defeat for Perry, the front-runner in Florida and national polls. He had wooed the nearly 3,000 party faithful with fliers before the Presidency 5 weekend and a free breakfast Saturday.

"Folks, this is what you call momentum," Cain, the former CEO of Godfather's Pizza, said in a video message from his campaign bus. "The Herman Cain train is picking up steam."

The vote also showed how soft Republican support is for Romney. Unlike Perry, though, he avoided schmoozing the voters.

The straw poll is a mock election and doesn't necessarily reflect the sentiment of the voters at large. In past years, it has predicted the party's national nominee, but that streak could be in jeopardy because even some Cain voters doubted that he could ultimately win. Still, the vote is a major indication of how badly damaged Perry was by a poor debate performance Thursday when he fumbled answers and failed to give specifics.

Many straw poll voters were especially dissatisfied by the answers Perry gave over his moderate immigration position and his plan to inoculate girls from human papillomavirus — issues that have haunted him since his first debate weeks ago.

"I came in thinking Rick Perry," said Tommy Langford, a Gilchrist County commissioner who voted for Cain. "I didn't like the debate at all. I really thought Perry lost it."

Cain's momentum was evident throughout the weekend. At a faith rally before the debate and a conservative forum after, Cain earned the loudest applause. By Friday night, he was so popular that his staff had to find a bigger room to accommodate admirers. But even then, in a room with a capacity of 700, a long line snaked out the door.

Cain's centerpiece: his plan to scrap the tax code and replace it with a flat 9 percent tax on income, national sales and business profits. Saturday morning, in a speech before the vote, the crowd chanted "9-9-9!" and had an electric response to almost everything he said.

"Let's send a message to Washington," he shouted. "We the people are still in charge of this country!"

It resonated in a convention where vendors sold "Don't Tread on Me" ties and some activists dressed as revolutionary soldiers with tricorner hats. After the vote, people streamed out of the convention hall roaring: "No more RINOS! No more RINOS!" — an acronym for Republicans in Name Only.

The vote and spectacle underscored that Cain, who polled in single digits last week, is the new tea party darling. And Michele Bachmann isn't. She was the big loser of the straw poll, coming in last. Once a top-tier candidate who won the Iowa straw poll, Bachmann had trouble breaking through in recent debates, failed to give specifics and didn't reach out to the Presidency 5 grass roots voters.

Perry issued a written statement congratulating Cain, saying the vote underscored the fact that the conservative message of job creation, fiscal responsibility and limited government is gaining momentum.

"Floridians and voters nationally want a candidate who is clear on the issues and talks honestly about the future," Perry said. "Today's vote demonstrates that Floridians are energized and ready to help get America working again."

Moments later, Perry's supporters tried to spin the results as a "devastating" defeat for Romney because he couldn't overtake Perry.

But other delegates said they're both losers.

"This seriously undermines the electability of Perry and Romney," said Ralph Camp, 64, of Marianna, who voted for Cain.

Ana Navarro, of Miami-Dade and an adviser to candidate Jon Huntsman, said Perry is more show than substance.

"Rick Perry is a Texas stud, a real macho man who looks great in a cowboy hat and boots and was supposed to come galloping on his stallion to rescue Republicans and lead us to the promise land," Navarro said. "But it's become increasingly clear he can't perform. He has electile dysfunction."

Pinellas County delegate Rachelle Warmouth said Perry's loss wouldn't end his campaign. But the debate performance and the effect it's having on party loyalists are a call to step up his game.

"He'll have to have a strong recovery," she said. "He needs to focus on his message."

Warmouth attended the Saturday breakfast hosted by Perry. She said he worked the room hard by shaking hands, posing for pictures and making small talk. He also took a shot at Romney for not wooing the delegates.

"There are a number of folks in some campaigns who have spurned this tradition of the Florida straw poll," he said. "And I think that's a big mistake."

Still, Perry left to attend a Michigan straw poll without addressing the full Florida convention immediately before the vote. Standing in for him: former Texas Railroad Commissioner Michael Williams, who attempted to do what Perry failed to do in repeated appearances: address the issue of the so-called Texas Dream Act that helped the children of some illegal immigrants go to college. "He has opposed amnesty. He fought against sanctuary cities," Williams said.

An official primary vote in Florida is months away, in February. That means there's plenty of time for Perry to repair his image, Romney to overtake him or Cain to grow stronger. Cain's win should mean more media attention, a boost in the polls and access to more campaign cash.

Lee County delegate Dane Eagle said he's for Romney. He likes the candidate's message and polish on stage. And he fears that President Barack Obama would walk all over Perry in debates.

"That's what Obama does," Eagle said. "He debates."

St. Johns County delegate Randy Covington said he arrived in Orlando ready to vote for Perry, but the debate "shattered" that plan.

Covington decided to support Cain after the businessman's rousing speech Friday at the Conservative Political Action Conference. It was wedged in between the party's Presidency 5 Thursday debate and Saturday straw poll.

But Covington said he wasn't sure if Cain would or should be the Republican nominee. He said the primary shouldn't be a two-man race.

"We need this process to go on," Covington said.

Florida Gov. Rick Scott, who announced the straw poll results from the Orange County Convention Center stage, said the candidates "need to take very seriously whatever the results are."

"It shows you something," said Scott. "It pays to be here."


Straw poll results

In a stunning upset Saturday, Herman Cain won Florida's Presidency 5 straw poll, a vote of 2,657 Republican activists that in past years has predicted the party nominee. Here are the results:

Herman Cain: 37.1 percent, 986 votes

Rick Perry: 15.4 percent, 410 votes

Mitt Romney: 14 percent, 372 votes

Rick Santorum: 10.9 percent, 289 votes

Ron Paul: 10.4 percent, 276 votes

Newt Gingrich: 8.4 percent, 224 votes

Jon Huntsman: 2.3 percent, 60 votes

Michele Bachmann: 1.5 percent, 40 votes

Herman Cain wins Presidency 5 straw poll 09/24/11 [Last modified: Saturday, September 24, 2011 10:57pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Unborn baby dies, two critically injured in Largo crash


    LARGO — Two people were critically injured and an unborn baby was killed in a crash that shut down an intersection on Ulmerton Road late Wednesday night, the Florida Highway Patrol said.

  2. Forecast: Tampa Bay's workweek wraps up with more afternoon rain, hot temperatures


    After a few sporadic afternoon showers over the last few days, Tampa Bay will wrap up the workweek with some higher storm activity.

    Tampa Bay's 7 day forecast. [WTSP]
  3. Florida education news: Creaky air conditioning, hate speech, home visits and more


    OVERHEATED: Several Hillsborough County schools suffer air conditioning breakdowns during the first days of classes, and maintenance workers are striving to …

    Aging air conditioning is faltering at some Hillsborough County schools.
  4. Students, staff, parents celebrate opening of two new schools in Pasco


    After months of anticipation, Pasco County's two newest schools made their debuts Monday to largely rave reviews.

    Bryce Navarro, left, a junior at Cypress Creek High School, helps fellow student Michae’la Davis and her mother, Valarie White, with the registration process Monday, the first day of classes.
  5. Residents warned after gator kills dog at Joe's Creek in St. Petersburg

    Public Safety

    The Pinellas County Sheriff's Office is issuing a warning to pet owners after a woman's dog was killed by a 9-foot alligator at Joe's Creek in St. Petersburg on Wednesday.

    The Pinellas County Sheriff's Office issued a warning on its Facebook page after a 9-foot gator killed a 75-pound dog at Joe's Creek in St. Petersburg on Aug. 16, 2017. [Pinellas County Sheriff's Office]