Make us your home page
Instagram

Today’s top headlines delivered to you daily.

(View our Privacy Policy)

PolitiFact.com | Tampa Bay Times
Sorting out the truth in politics

PolitiFact: Earning $500,000 in Manhattan puts you well above middle class

The statement

An annual income of $500,000 "in Manhattan, believe it or not, is middle class."

Sal Albanese, candidate for mayor of New York City, on MSNBC

The ruling

Albanese, a Democratic former city council member, made the claim as he was criticizing a municipal tax proposal offered by one of his rivals, Bill Thompson, the former city comptroller.

"I disagree with Bill's proposal to tax people even more in the city," Albanese said. "As I said, what's at stake — in Manhattan, a half a million — half a million more in Manhattan, believe it or not, is middle class."

At this point, an off-screen voice shouted, "Half a million or more is not middle class!"

Unfortunately, there is no official definition of "middle class." The phrase has such a mom-and-apple-pie ring to it that politicians have been using the term expansively for generations.

But we'll look at a few methods. One is to define the upper boundary of the middle class as twice the median income.

Using demographic data from the U.S. Census Bureau, we found that for Manhattan, the median income for all households was a little more than $66,000. Using this definition, the upper limit of the middle class would be $132,000.

The second way is to break the population into three broad categories. The bottom fifth would be lower-income, the middle 60 percent would be middle-income, and the top fifth would be high-income.

Census data shows that someone who makes $200,000 ranks in the top 16 percent of Manhattan earners. So a household could make it into the top 20 percent with roughly $180,000.

Just to be sure that Manhattan wasn't an unusual case, we also tried to factor the Big Apple's famously high costs. We used a city cost-of-living calculator provided by CNNMoney.com that accounts for food, housing, utilities, transportation and health care. The calculator allowed us to determine what income in other cities was equivalent to $500,000 in Manhattan.

We found a handful of cities in which $500,000 in Manhattan money worked out to roughly $200,000 in local income — Birmingham, Ala.; Tulsa, Okla.; Tampa; Cincinnati; Detroit; Charleston, W.Va.; Salt Lake City; Des Moines, Iowa; and Phoenix. Using Census data, we found that in each of these cities, the percentage of local households earning $200,000 ranged between 1 percent and 5 percent.

This confirms that in this far-flung sampling of cities, earning the local equivalent of $500,000 in "Manhattan money" puts you in the top 5 percent of local earners. Even by the most generous definition, that's not close to middle-class status.

When we contacted Albanese's campaign, spokesman Todd Brogan said Albanese got carried away during the televised appearance and defined middle class in a way he normally does not. "It was, quite frankly, a gaffe," Brogan said.

We rate the claim False.

Edited for print. Read the full version at PolitiFact.com.

PolitiFact: Earning $500,000 in Manhattan puts you well above middle class 03/30/13 [Last modified: Friday, March 29, 2013 3:35pm]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times

    

Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

Loading...
  1. Manhattan Casino choice causes political headache for Kriseman

    Growth

    ST. PETERSBURG — Days before the mayoral primary, Mayor Rick Kriseman's decision to let a Floribbean restaurant open in Midtown's historic Manhattan Casino has caused political angst within the voting bloc he can least afford to lose: the black community.

    Last week Mayor Rick Kriseman chose a Floribbean restaurant concept to fill Midtown's historic Manhattan Casino. But that decision, made days before next week's mayoral primary, has turned into a political headache for the mayor. Many residents want to see the building's next tenant better reflect its cultural significance in the black community. [JAMES BORCHUCK   |   Times]
  2. FSU-Bama 'almost feels like a national championship game Week 1'

    Blogs

    The buzz is continuing to build for next Saturday's blockbuster showdown between No. 1 Alabama and No. 3 Florida State.

  3. Plan a fall vacation at Disney, Universal, Busch Gardens when crowds are light

    Florida

    Now that the busy summer vacation season is ending, Floridians can come out to play.

    Maria Reyna, 8, of Corpus Cristi, TX. eats chicken at the Lotus Blossom Cafe at the Chinese pavilion at Epcot in Orlando, Fla. on Thursday, August 17, 2017.  Epcot is celebrating it's 35th year as the upcoming Food and Wine Festival kicks off once again.
  4. USF spends $1.5 million to address growing demand for student counseling

    College

    TAMPA — As Florida's universities stare down a mental health epidemic, the University of South Florida has crafted a plan it hopes will reach all students, from the one in crisis to the one who doesn't know he could use some help.

    A student crosses the University of South Florida campus in Tampa, where visits to the school's crisis center more than doubled last year, part of a spike in demand that has affected colleges across the country. The university is addressing the issue this year with $1.5 million for more "wellness coaches," counselors, online programs and staff training. [OCTAVIO JONES   |   Times]
  5. PTA treasurer at Pinellas school accused of stealing $5,000

    Crime

    The treasurer of the Parent-Teacher Association at a Pinellas County elementary school faces a felony fraud charge after she was accused of stealing from the organization to pay her credit card and phone bills.

    Lisa McMenamin, 50, of Tarpon Springs, is facing felony charges of scheming to defraud the Brooker Creek Elementary Parent-Teacher Association, where she served as treasurer. She is accused of stealing $5,000 to pay credit card and phone bills. [Pinellas County Sheriff's Office]